The Orioles have leaned hard into early extensions, and that strategy can cut both ways.
In the past 18 months, Baltimore has locked up Samuel Basallo on an eight-year deal, then followed with five-year extensions for Shane Baz and Kyle Bradish before adding Yennier Cano on a two-year contract. These kinds of pre-arbitration and arbitration deals can be a real advantage for a team, since they give clubs a chance to buy out years at a lower overall cost. The structure often helps the team later, even if the average annual value looks heavier on the luxury-tax side early on.
But the upside comes with real danger, especially when the player is still barely established in the majors. Basallo had only five days of MLB experience when he signed.
That is a huge wager on what he might become. He could grow into the impact bat the Orioles are banking on, or he could settle into a much smaller role as a backup catcher, first baseman, or DH if the development never fully arrives.
That’s where the cautionary tale comes in. Baltimore needs to avoid the kind of long-term trap the Boston Red Sox are dealing with after giving second baseman Kristian Campbell an eight-year deal just days into his MLB tenure back in 2025. Campbell was sent down to the minors in June last year and has not been called back up since, yet Boston is still carrying the contract and the AAV still counts against the books.
There’s another problem when an extension goes sideways: the trade market can dry up. Other teams are not eager to take on money for a young player who hasn’t shown enough to justify it. At that point, the player becomes more of a reclamation project than a valuable asset.
David Rubenstein made the Orioles’ stance clear at Shane Baz’s introductory press conference, saying they are “open for business” on early extensions. He added that it has to make sense for both sides, but Baltimore has already moved two more times since then.
The financial appeal is obvious. The final three years of Basallo’s contract will each count for far less than what the Orioles are actually paying, with over seven million in savings on the final two years.
Baz’s final two seasons will count for $8 million and $12 million less, respectively.
That’s the balancing act for a young Orioles roster. Clubs that can’t always pay full market prices once players reach free agency, like the Braves, often try to get ahead of the curve with early deals.
It can work. It can also leave a team boxed in if it extends the wrong players too soon.
With so much young talent in Baltimore’s majors and minors, the Orioles have to weigh each player’s ceiling against what else is available internally and what they might be able to acquire before handing out too many more long-term commitments.
In Other News...
Orioles Still Have One Obvious Outfield Problem After Latest Roster Moves
The Orioles kept trimming and sorting their roster this week, a familiar offseason task for a club trying to balance flexibility with a clear need in the outfield. Jos Barrero and Albert Surez cleared waivers and chose free agency, Colin Selby was reinstated from the injured list and sent to Triple-A Norfolk, and Codi Heuer accepted an outright assignment to Norfolk, leaving Baltimore with 33 players on the 40-man roster.
Luis Robert Jr. remains the most notable name in the middle of it all, because the Orioles moved on from his contract option and sent him into free agency. Even after the latest roster moves, the outfield still looks like a spot Baltimore will have to keep addressing, and the front office now has room to keep working on it without forcing a decision just yet. [Read more 🡒]
Orioles Just Turned Luis Robert Jr Into An Offseason Debate
Luis Robert Jr.'s Baltimore stint never really got the chance to get going, and now it has already become an offseason decision point. The Orioles have declined his 2027 team option, another sign of how aggressively they are sorting through their roster after a season in which they also moved on from several other players' options for next year.
Robert was claimed off waivers from the Mets in 2026, but injuries kept him from making much of an impact in Baltimore. He appeared in only three games for the club before ending up on the injured list, and the stop-start season left the Orioles with little choice but to treat his future as part of a broader reset rather than a simple return plan. [Read more 🡒]
Orioles Hold A Luis Robert Decision That Could Help Boston
Bostons offseason planning already has a familiar name in the mix, and it comes with a Baltimore wrinkle. Luis Robert Jr., now with the Orioles, is one of the offensive options the Red Sox are weighing as they look ahead to building a club that can contend in 2027, especially if they wind up moving Jarren Duran and need another dynamic outfield bat to consider.
Robert still carries the appeal that made him an All-Star in the first place, with power and speed that can change a lineup in a hurry. The concern, as always, is whether the health questions that have followed him in recent years will keep him from becoming the kind of dependable target Boston would want before committing to a major pursuit. [Read more 🡒]