The Orioles’ catching picture has turned into one of the more fluid parts of their offseason.
Not long ago, the club seemed set on building around Samuel Basallo and Adley Rutschman, with the organization making the case that both could fit together. That changed when Baltimore sent Rutschman to the Red Sox at the deadline for four prospects and catcher Carlos Narváez, a deal the Orioles felt they couldn’t pass up after failing to work out an extension or mount a real playoff push.
That trade brought in a serious haul. Three of the organization’s top 12 prospects came from the deal, including right-hander Anthony Eyanson, who ranks No. 2 in the system and No. 45 overall on MLB Pipeline’s list. Outfielder Enddy Azocar is ranked 99th.
Even with Narváez in the mix, president of baseball operations Mike Elias has been clear that the Orioles do not see Basallo as a catcher who should carry a full-time workload. Basallo may not even start half the games behind the plate, with first base and designated hitter both part of the plan to keep him from the wear and tear that has affected him before.
Elias has also said he’s comfortable with the Basallo-Narváez combination and expects Narváez to hit better after a rough stretch with Baltimore, where he posted a .104/.198/.117 line with 24 strikeouts in 33 games. Still, the Orioles are looking beyond just depth. They want another catcher, and they may be aiming higher than a simple backup.
One name that surfaced was Hunter Goodman. According to The Athletic’s Ken Rosenthal, the Orioles “checked in with the Rockies” early in the offseason about Goodman, who blasted 41 home runs and earned his second straight All-Star selection.
He played 144 games one year and 138 the next, which tells you this is no part-time option. The report said no names were exchanged and the talks “failed to advance.”
Goodman also had left shoulder surgery, though he is expected to be ready for spring training.
Baltimore also reportedly had interest in Nick Fortes before the Rays dealt him to the Red Sox this week. Fortes has hit .231/.285/.351 with 34 home runs over six seasons. He’s not in Goodman’s class offensively, but he’s a steady defender, and his name fits the broader theme: the Orioles are not content to stand still behind the plate.
There are several other catching options floating around the market. Ryan Jeffers accepted his $23.15 qualifying offer from the Twins after MLBTradeRumors.com ranked him No. 9 among free agents and projected a four-year, $75 million deal. Carson Kelly sits at No. 33 on that list with a projection of two years and $20 million.
A move like that would be a major commitment if paired with Basallo, but Baltimore has money to work with.
Kelly’s name might ring a bell for Orioles fans who remember the 2017 Winter Meetings, when the previous front office discussed him in trade talks with the Cardinals involving Manny Machado. Right-handers Jack Flaherty, Luke Weaver and Jordan Hicks were also part of those conversations.
Machado eventually went to the Dodgers in a deal that included starter Dean Kremer and outfielder Yusniel Díaz, who was viewed as the prize but didn’t pan out. Baltimore also asked about pitchers Walker Buehler and Dustin May, infielder Gavin Lux, outfielder Alex Verdugo and catchers Will Smith and Keibert Ruiz, none of whom were included.
There was also a separate round of Machado talks with the Phillies, who were asked about pitching prospect Sixto Sánchez and outfielder Scott Kingery. Philadelphia passed, especially with Sánchez considered untouchable at the time.
Tyler Stephenson is another name to watch. MLBTradeRumors.com has him ranked No. 40 among free agents and projects a two-year, $15 million deal. The site described him this way: “Stephenson is one of the best hitting but worst fielding catchers in the game.”
That’s not exactly a ringing defensive endorsement. Statcast has rated him as the majors’ worst framer since 2024, and no catcher allowed more stolen bases than his 94 this year.
The Red Sox also non-tendered Connor Wong, who hit .280/.333/.425 with 24 doubles, 13 home runs and 52 RBIs in 126 games in 2024. Orioles manager Craig Albernaz has ties to Guardians free-agent catcher Austin Hedges, and the organization has a history with James McCann. Baltimore also drafted Jonah Heim in 2013, and he went on to become an All-Star and Gold Glove winner with the Rangers 10 years later before his production dropped off sharply.
Somebody is going to be added, whether by trade or free agency.
A few other Orioles notes: the club signed infielder Luis Vázquez to another minor league contract with a spring training invitation. He played in 32 games in 2025 and just one this year after breaking his thumb on March 22 in D.C.
He hit .226 with a .642 OPS in 52 games for Triple-A Norfolk. A source confirmed ESPN’s Jorge Castillo’s report on the signing.
Jared Banner also said in a podcast taping with The Baltimore Sun that the Orioles hired Jeff Taylor as vice president of high performance. Taylor had been the Marlins’ director of strength and conditioning. Head athletic trainer Scott Barringer has been moved to director of player health, and Ben Fraser will take over Barringer’s old role.
In Other News...
Orioles Keep Familiar Infield Piece As Bench Battle Starts Taking Shape
The Orioles have added a familiar name back into the mix as spring training competition starts to take shape. Baltimore re-signed infielder Luis Vzquez to a minor league contract and brought him into major league camp, keeping a player around who has spent parts of three big league seasons in a mostly defensive role while also logging six Triple-A seasons.
For the Orioles, Vzquez fits the kind of depth piece teams like to have in camp when the bench picture is still coming into focus. He gives Baltimore another experienced infield option to evaluate this spring, and his return suggests the club still sees value in his glove as it sorts through the roster mix for the upcoming season. [Read more 🡒]
Orioles Face One Costly Roster Question On Non-Tender Day
The Orioles have already done plenty of business this winter, working through trades and extensions involving Dean Kremer, Adley Rutschman, Kyle Bradish and Shane Baz as they try to keep the roster moving in the right direction. Even with those deals in place, the club still has some important arbitration work left before the tender deadline, and the front office has been juggling those talks while also keeping an eye on a possible lockout and the broader uncertainty around the market.
Four players are still in arbitration discussions, with Gunnar Henderson and Flix Bautista among the names still waiting on salary resolution ahead of a potential hearing. Baltimore has also watched some players opt for free agency after clearing waivers, which only adds to the sense that the roster is still being sorted piece by piece. For a team trying to stay competitive while protecting its core, this is the kind of deadline that can quietly shape the next phase of the offseason. [Read more 🡒]
Orioles Still Have One Catching Question With Time Running Short
The Orioles have spent the offseason looking for catching help, and Hunter Goodman surfaced as one name they checked on before talks stalled out. Baltimores interest never got to the point of formal offers, but it fit the broader picture for a club still sorting through its options behind the plate as the winter market has moved slowly and the MLB lockout looms.
Goodman, a two-time All-Star whose bat has made him one of the more intriguing catchers available, also had offseason surgery, though he is expected to be ready for spring training. For the Orioles, the bigger issue is still unresolved: they have not made any confirmed roster moves yet, and time is running short to answer a catching question that could shape the rest of their offseason. [Read more 🡒]
