When the Orioles tore down a chunk of their roster in the middle of a lost 2025 season, Anthony Nunez was one of the names buried in the return package. Fifteen months later, he was no longer just part of the haul from that summer fire sale - he had carved out a real role in Baltimore’s bullpen.
Nunez ended up making 52 appearances for the Orioles, good for fifth on the team, after arriving from the Mets in the Cedric Mullins deal alongside Raimon Gomez and Chandler Marsh. And for a stretch, he looked like one of the better finds from that wave of trades.
His big league debut came on March 28, when he tossed two perfect innings in mop-up duty against the Twins, and he quickly worked his way into higher-leverage spots. By early April, he had picked up holds in three straight outings.
Through his first 12 games, he owned a 1.35 ERA with 16 strikeouts, and he looked every bit like a bullpen hit.
That shine faded as hitters started making adjustments. By the end of May, his ERA had climbed to 5.67, and he had already endured six outings in which he allowed multiple runs. The roughest came on May 20 in Tampa Bay, when he entered the eighth with a 3-1 Orioles lead and left with Baltimore on the wrong end of a 5-3 loss after surrendering four runs.
A month later, when closer Ryan Helsley came off the injured list, Nunez lost his roster spot. He was optioned to the minors and spent much of the rest of the season bouncing between Norfolk and Baltimore. September brought a longer run in the Orioles’ bullpen, and he finished the year with a 4.07 ERA and an exactly league-average 100 ERA+ across 52 games.
The line wasn’t dazzling, but the stuff was real. Nunez struck out 10 batters per nine innings and kept the ball in the park with a 0.8 HR/9 rate.
His walk rate, 3.9 BB/9, was a little on the high side, but not disastrous. What stood out most was how nasty his offspeed pitches were.
His sweeper - classified that way by Baseball Savant - became his most-used pitch, and opponents hit just .147 with a .200 slugging mark against it while he generated a 45.8 whiff percentage. His changeup was even sharper in the batter’s box, holding hitters to a .102 average and .163 slugging.
He also mixed in a cutter just 6% of the time, and that pitch held its own too, limiting hitters to a .125 average and .313 slugging.
The problem came fastball-to-fastball. Nunez’s heater averaged 96.1 mph, but the pitch didn’t have enough movement to keep hitters guessing.
Opponents hit .316 with a .561 slugging percentage against his four-seamer, while his sinker was even more exposed, allowing a .458 average and .667 slugging. That’s the area he’ll need to sharpen this offseason if he wants hitters to stop locking in on the offspeed stuff.
Nunez’s journey to this point has been anything but straightforward. A standout shortstop at Miami Springs HS, he was drafted by the Padres in the 29th round in 2019, then released two years later after reaching Low-A.
He used an NCAA rule to return to college as a former high school signee, landing at Division II University of Tampa in 2022. There, he became a two-way player and first took the mound in 2024, striking out 20 batters in 11.2 innings.
That arm ultimately mattered more than the bat. He signed a minor league deal with the Mets as a full-time pitcher and moved quickly through their system, reaching Double-A Binghamton in 2025 before the Orioles acquired him.
FanGraphs was especially bullish on him, ranking Nunez as Baltimore’s sixth-best prospect in May, ahead of Ike Irish, Nate George, and Joseph Dzierwa, among others. Eric Longenhagen and Brendan Gawlowski described him as “a premium reliever with three plus or better pitches and uncommon strike-throwing consistency,” and said he could eventually be stretched out as a starter. They also singled out his fastball, changeup, and a slider they called “an elite swing-and-miss pitch.”
His 2026 season had its rough patches, but it also showed why the Orioles were intrigued in the first place. At 25, he got his first real taste of the majors and flashed enough quality to matter. Baltimore has not announced any plan to turn him into a starter, but even if he stays in relief, he should enter next spring with a clear path to another bullpen job.
In Other News...
Mike Elias Just Raised A Bigger Orioles Power Question
The Orioles used Jared Banners introduction as new general manager on Oct. 27 to draw a clearer line in their front office, and it was a revealing one. Mike Elias said Banner will handle the clubs internal side of the operation, including players, coaches, player development, performance and healthcare, while Elias will lean more toward scouting and acquisitions.
For a team that has built much of its recent identity around drafting, developing and promoting from within, the arrangement points to how seriously Baltimore wants to sharpen those processes. Elias even acknowledged that Banner is stronger than he is in the areas tied to internal growth and development, a notable admission for a franchise trying to turn its pipeline into a lasting edge. [Read more 🡒]
Why Billy Ripkens Infamous Orioles Card Still Gets Fans Talking
A strange little piece of Orioles history still comes up whenever baseball card collectors start talking about the games most notorious photos. Billy Ripkens 1989 Fleer card, shot at Fenway Park, captured him holding a bat with an expletive written on the knob, and the image quickly turned into one of those oddball items that outlived the season itself. What began as a routine card photo became a lasting bit of memorabilia, one that fans still remember for everything around it as much as the player in the picture.
The uproar around the card only added to its legend, with the issue drawing immediate attention beyond Baltimore and forcing the company into a scramble to address it. Ripken eventually leaned into the attention rather than run from it, and the card has stayed part of baseballs pop-culture lore ever since. For Orioles fans, it remains one of those offbeat reminders that the franchises history includes more than just box scores and standings. [Read more 🡒]
New Orioles GM Just Changed The Mike Elias Conversation
Jared Banners introductory news conference gave Orioles fans a first look at how the front office will operate with him in the general manager chair. Banner spent much of the session talking about his background, the clubs strengths and weaknesses, and the working relationship hell have with president of baseball operations Mike Elias, while also signaling that the organization wants as much continuity as possible on the coaching side.
The bigger takeaway was less about titles and more about structure, with Elias spelling out that the job will now be split in a way that clearly defines who handles which parts of the operation. Banner said his focus will be on building a winning team, and the way the responsibilities are now framed suggests Baltimore is trying to sharpen its decision-making without changing the overall direction of the baseball operation. [Read more 🡒]