Chris Bassitt gave the Orioles exactly what they needed Wednesday afternoon: five-plus sturdy innings, a veteran’s feel for the moment, and a 4-2 win over the Blue Jays that kept Baltimore’s slim wild-card pulse going for one more game.
At Camden Yards, in front of 10,562 for a makeup of Tuesday night’s rainout, the Orioles did enough to stay mathematically alive for the time being. But the margin is razor-thin.
Entering the first game of the doubleheader, Baltimore needed to win its final five games while the Chicago White Sox lost their final five. The Orioles improved to 77-81, while Toronto fell to 77-81 and was eliminated from playoff contention.
Baltimore would be eliminated if the Blue Jays win Wednesday night’s second game.
Bassitt, who improved to 9-5, worked 5-plus innings and allowed two runs on seven hits, with one walk and two strikeouts. Craig Albernaz called it “a gritty outing,” pointing to the way Bassitt kept finding pitches when he needed them.
“It was definitely a gritty outing,” manager Craig Albernaz said. “Just a veteran presence, knowing how to navigate that, making pitches when he had to. He had more in the tank, but he did his job today.”
The biggest swing of the afternoon came off the bat of Pete Alonso, whose two-run homer in the fifth - his 41st - pushed Baltimore ahead 4-0 against Max Scherzer, who took the loss to fall to 3-9. The blast also came in Scherzer’s 500th appearance.
Bassitt and Scherzer know each other well. They were teammates with the New York Mets in 2022 and again with Toronto last year, and Bassitt made it clear how much he respects the future Hall of Famer.
“He’s No. 1 in my book as the most respect I’ve ever had on someone in the game,” Bassitt said about Scherzer.
“Any time I can face him, it’s always going to be a lot more fun than just, I’d say, the normal game,” Bassitt said. “Obviously, I think both teams are wishing that we would have better standings.”
Baltimore built its early cushion in the second. Jeremiah Jackson drove in Christian Encarnacion-Strand with an RBI single, then the Orioles tried to get aggressive with Jackson at first and Colton Cowser at third. Jackson was caught in a rundown, but Cowser broke for home and scored to make it 2-0.
Toronto finally pushed back in the sixth. George Springer scored on a throwing error by Jeremiah Jackson, and Brandon Valenzuela followed with a run-scoring single to cut the lead in half.
That was enough to end Bassitt’s afternoon, with Luis De León coming in to handle the two-on, none-out jam. De León allowed two hits and recorded two outs.
From there, Anthony Nunez, Rico Garcia and Andrew Kittredge closed it out, combining for the final 10 outs. Kittredge picked up his 11th save.
The Blue Jays were just 1-for-14 with runners in scoring position, a big reason the Orioles were able to keep control after Toronto made it interesting.
Baltimore also made a roster move for the second game, recalling Trey Gibson from Triple-A Norfolk to start Game 2. De León was optioned to the spring training complex in Sarasota after finishing his first major league season with a 1.93 ERA in eight appearances.
Bassitt’s afternoon wasn’t just about the standings or the box score. It also came with a little reflection on what might come next. He said he wants to keep pitching and indicated he’ll work in relief Sunday at Yankee Stadium.
“My future is, the last game of the season, I’ll be throwing,” Bassitt said. “That’s my future right now.
As for everything else, man, I’ve got a 7-year-old at home, I’ve got a 3-year-old at home and a wife that wants me to be home. So, yeah, we’ll cross that bridge when we do.
“Overall, I still have a lot of fire in me to definitely do something. I’m gonna have to win the wife over, I’ll tell you that.
But, yeah, there’s a lot of fire still in me. I know I still can play this game at a really high level.”
Bassitt also had plenty to say about Alonso, who was his Mets teammate in 2022 and added another milestone to his season Wednesday. With 41 home runs, Alonso moved into ninth place on the Orioles’ single-season home run list, tied with Nelson Cruz before the game and now ahead of him. Rafael Palmeiro’s 43 sit in eighth.
“Listen, I love Pete,” Bassitt said. “I know I’m a Baltimore Oriole, but Pete deserves MVP votes, and he deserves them every single year.
That’s just the reality. He’s one of the most underappreciated players in our game.
He’s easily a top-3 hitter every single year. He’s doing it now in the AL when everyone says that the NL, AL, always the battle between those two.
So it’s like, now what?
“He’s not having a crazy historical year for his standards. It’s just Pete being Pete, and people are like, ‘Dang, this is really, really special.’
But he’s been doing that for years. So, yeah, Pete just held the standard of what he’s done for years, and I think people are now realizing, ‘This guy’s really good.’
But he’s always been really, really good. So, yeah, it’s Pete being Pete.”
For Bassitt, the larger takeaway may be what his finish says about the Orioles’ next wave. He sees a club that has endured plenty this season but may be building toward something better, even if he won’t be around for it.
“It’s been pretty bloody, a little bit, for the season where just we took our shots. It hasn’t been pretty a lot.
I’ll be honest with you, it sucks for me in the aspect like I need to freaking win right now, because I don’t have much runway left. But these young guys, the way that they have handled this year, a lot of struggles, some obviously good moments, but just the way that they have approached every day, I know it’s setting up for something a lot more special in the future.
It’s just I’m not part of the future.”
The second game was set for 6:35, with Gibson facing CJ Van Eyk.
In Other News...
Orioles Still Have Tough 40-Man Calls On Several Young Players
The Orioles took care of six roster decisions on Nov. 19, adding Flix Bautista and Kyle Bradish to the 40-man as part of the usual offseason protection process, even with the 2021 Rule 5 draft canceled. But the bigger work is still ahead. Baltimore is sorting through the rest of its 40-man picture with an eye on the wave of young talent moving through the system, and the next set of choices could say as much about the organizations priorities as anything it has done so far this winter.
Enrique Bradfield Jr., Aron Estrada, Michael Forret, Creed Willems and Nestor German are among the names in the mix, and each brings a different kind of case. Recent performance matters, but so do ceilings, injuries and the bumps that have shaped their seasons. For a club that has built so much of its identity around stocking the pipeline, these are the kinds of decisions that can feel routine on the surface and revealing underneath. [Read more 🡒]
Orioles Suddenly Have A Jackson Holliday Problem This Offseason
The Orioles offseason health picture took another hit as Jackson Holliday is set to undergo wrist surgery later this week or early next week, a development that adds another layer of uncertainty around one of the organizations most important young players. The expected recovery window is about 10 weeks, which at least gives Baltimore a clearer sense of the timeline, even if it leaves the club waiting longer than it would have liked for a full offseason reset.
Holliday was already central to whatever the Orioles hope to build moving forward, and his situation now sits alongside a few other notable injury updates. Samuel Basallo has been placed on the 7-day concussion injured list, while Tyler ONeill received a PRP injection in his shoulder as the team looks toward getting him ready for next spring. For Baltimore, it is a reminder that even in the quiet months, the roster picture can shift quickly before the new season even begins. [Read more 🡒]
Orioles Front Office Move Wont Silence The Bigger Mike Elias Debate
The Orioles have added Ty Holub back into the organization, hiring him as a senior analyst in the scouting department after his time with the Mariners and a previous stint in Baltimore as a Baseball Operations Assistant. Holubs background gives the front office another voice with a track record in both scouting and player evaluation, and it fits a franchise that has spent years trying to sharpen every layer of its talent pipeline.
Still, moves like this tend to raise the larger question around Mike Elias rather than quiet it. Baltimore has steadily tried to build out its staff and improve the process behind player acquisition, and Holubs return is another piece of that effort, but the broader debate over whether the Orioles have enough impact in the front office to match their on-field ambitions is not going away anytime soon. [Read more 🡒]