With the Orioles heading toward a second straight missed postseason, the front office’s winter to-do list starts with a hard look at Samuel Basallo. Of all the homegrown hitters who didn’t live up to expectations, his collapse after the All-Star break stands out the most.
That’s what makes Basallo such a frustrating case. Last summer’s extension felt like a milestone for this version of the Orioles: a homegrown player locked up long term, a rare win for an organization that had spent years trying to build that kind of trust with its fan base. He came out of a renewed push into Latin America, and he did it as a catcher - the same position that was then occupied by Adley Rutschman, the all-star face of the club’s rise in the 2020s.
A lot has changed since then. The Orioles have endured another disappointing year and seem set to miss the playoffs for the second straight season.
Rutschman was injured, then got back to his all-star level in the first half before the team still slipped away from him, and he was traded to the division rival Red Sox in early August. Basallo, meanwhile, opened the season with promise before injuries and a deep slump dragged him down as the Orioles faded.
The split in his season is stark. Before his IL stint for right shoulder inflammation began on July 22, Basallo was hitting .241/.305/.450 with a 110 wRC+, 16 home runs, a 26.4% strikeout rate and an 8.4% walk rate. For a 22-year-old rookie, that’s strong production.
Since coming back on August 19, the numbers have cratered. He’s at .150/.250/.217 with a 39 wRC+, one home run, a 26.5% strikeout rate and a 7.4% walk rate.
The swing-and-miss hasn’t changed much. The damage on contact has.
The contact quality tells the story. Basallo’s average exit velocity was 91.3 mph before the IL move, fourth on the team behind Pete Alonso, Coby Mayo and Blaze Alexander. Since then, it’s dropped to 86.2 mph, a mark that sits alongside Jackson Holliday, who has also struggled in the second half and could use his own writeup.
The ball isn’t coming off his bat the same way, and it’s showing up in the shape of his contact too. His line drive rate was 18.3% through July.
Since the start of August, it’s been 9.5%. He was pulling 46% of pitches earlier in the year, but that number is down to 38.1%, with much of the difference shifting to opposite field contact.
Pitchers, though, haven’t really changed the way they’re attacking him. Fastball rates versus breaking and off-speed pitches have stayed fairly steady, even if individual matchups vary. The bigger issue is that Basallo simply hasn’t been able to get the bat moving like he did earlier in the year.
That decline is visible in his bat speed, which has trended down all season. It was 75 mph in April, then slid month by month to a season-low 73.1 mph in September.
The injury trail helps explain why the Orioles need to take this seriously. Basallo was scratched from a game against the Yankees on May 11 with left knee discomfort.
On May 30 against the Blue Jays, an awkward swing left him grabbing at his left shoulder/pec. A few days later, he was said to be dealing with a “bony growth” in his left wrist.
Then came the shoulder inflammation and IL stint. At the end of August, he also briefly dealt with a hand injury.
His handling of those issues became a topic inside the organization in mid-June. Orioles manager Craig Albernaz said the young slugger needed to work on “knowing how to play through some pain and not being 100% all the time.”
Basallo pushed back the next day, saying players “are not robots.” In hindsight, that exchange looks a little different now.
The production line backs up the suspicion that he hasn’t been right for a while. His exit velocity has been down since June, his bat speed has never bounced back from April, and the results have gotten worse almost every step of the way.
His monthly OPS tells the same story: .754, .974, .584, .694, .481, .444. The last two numbers belong to August and September, the months after he was cleared as “healthy” enough to return following two rehab games.
None of this changes the big-picture reality. Basallo is not going anywhere.
He’s signed through 2033 at least, with a team option for ’34. And those first few months still matter; they showed enough to make it easy to believe he can be a middle-of-the-order fixture for a long time.
But the Orioles have to figure out what changed after that early stretch. Maybe they needed to take his discomfort more seriously sooner.
Maybe he needs to catch less often. If the bat ends up being what they think it can be, they’ll have to do whatever it takes to keep him in the lineup as much as possible, even if that doesn’t line up neatly with what Albernaz or the organization expects from their catcher.
In Other News...
Orioles Suddenly Have A Real Third Base Answer For This Stretch Run
With 13 games left, the Orioles are still trying to keep themselves in the Wild Card race while juggling the realities of a season that has been battered by injuries and roster turnover. Jordan Westburgs surgery and the setbacks that followed have left a hole at third base, but the club has kept searching for answers even as it navigates the broader effort to blend present-day urgency with future-minded development.
Coby Mayo has been one of the more encouraging developments in that mix, showing better performance at a time when Baltimore needed somebody to stabilize the position. The Orioles have also continued folding in young talent from the trade deadline as part of that balancing act, and with the front office recently parting ways with vice president Matt Blood, the broader organizational picture is shifting even as this stretch run demands immediate production at the hot corner. [Read more 🡒]
Orioles Face A Tough Kyle Bradish Decision At The Worst Time
Kyle Bradishs latest turn only sharpened the questions already circling around the Orioles rotation. In a recent loss to Toronto, he was knocked out after three innings and gave up five runs, another uneven outing at a time when Baltimore can least afford one. The timing is especially awkward with the club still fighting through a tight playoff race and the calendar running thin.
Manager Craig Albernaz said the team is weighing all of its options, even as he continues to view Bradish as a competitor he trusts. Bradish, for his part, said fatigue is not the issue, which leaves the Orioles trying to sort out whether the problem is something they can fix on the fly or something that forces a tougher call soon. [Read more 🡒]
Orioles Just Reached A Painful Point In Their Season
The Orioles have reached the kind of point no contender wants to confront in August, with the standings and the tiebreakers now working against them enough that a real postseason run looks out of reach. A lopsided loss in Toronto only underlined what has defined too much of this season: the offense has gone quiet at the wrong times, and the defense has not been sharp enough to survive it.
At this stage, the better question is no longer how Baltimore can chase down the Wild Card, but how it can make the most of the games left. That means giving younger players more runway, being mindful of workloads, and protecting pitchers as the club starts thinking about next year rather than clinging to a path that keeps narrowing. [Read more 🡒]