Before the Tampa Bay Rays and New York Yankees open their best-of-five American League Division Series, the Yankees’ sweep of the Boston Red Sox offered a sharp reminder of how good New York looked in the first round of the AL East elimination race.
The Yankees handled Boston 9-0 and 9-2, outscoring the Red Sox 18-2 over the two-game set. That left plenty to sort through, including a rough series for Adley Rutschman, who was 1-for-8 and took part in a sixth-inning sequence that unraveled fast for Boston in Wednesday’s 9-2 loss.
With New York ahead 2-1, Garrett Crochet entered to pitch for the first time since April 25th, when he defeated the Orioles. Rutschman had never caught him.
Spencer Jones chased strike three on a ball in the dirt, but it bounced off Rutschman’s chest protector and to his left. Rutschman gathered it, took an extra step and threw a strike to first, where Jones was initially called out before the call was overturned on a challenge.
Jones was ruled safe because first baseman Wilson Contreras caught the throw while standing on the back of the bag and toward the line. He never moved to the front of the bag to give Rutschman a target.
Contreras also drifted off the bag earlier, on a Ryan McMahon line drive up the middle in the third inning. Trevor Story nearly caught it in the air before the ball popped out of his glove, and Story then made a perfect throw to first, where Contreras caught it feet from the bag.
Rutschman then absorbed more of the blame when Jones stole second and the throw tailed away from the bag and into the outfield. Jones advanced to third, and the inning kept sliding downhill from there, capped by Cody Bellinger’s three-run homer that pushed the score to 8-1.
It was a tough couple of games for Rutschman, but Boston’s problems went well beyond him. The Red Sox were thoroughly outplayed, and their manager Chad Tracy was outmanaged by Aaron Boone. Boone let Cam Schlittler keep going in Game 1, and Schlittler rewarded that trust with 117 pitches over 6 1/3 innings, allowing two hits and striking out 10.
Tracy, meanwhile, moved quickly on both Payton Tolle and Sonny Gray. Tolle went 4 1/3 innings and allowed five hits and one run.
Gray worked 4 2/3 innings, gave up six hits and two runs, and wanted Tracy to trust him more; he had thrown only 70 pitches. Tracy then turned to left-hander Erik Miller after each starter, and that choice backfired.
Miller gave up a home run to Ben Rice on Tuesday night in his first batter faced, then allowed a run-scoring single to Bellinger in the same spot Wednesday night, with that run charged to Gray.
Gray did not address his removal directly, but Wilson Contreras did offer a pointed comment about the modern game.
“It’s not enough when you have talent, or you have data, or you have computers telling you what to do, because this is baseball,” Contreras told reporters. “The data is here to help us, but at the end of the day, you’re going to need experience and veteran guys to win games. There’s a lot of stuff that I would like to say, but I’ll stay [with] that.”
Asked whether the Red Sox lean too hard on data, Contreras added, “If you watch the game,” he said to reporters. “If you watch the game …”
After watching the series, it was hard not to come away thinking the Orioles may not be as far behind Boston as the records suggest - Boston finished 87-75, Baltimore 79-82. It also felt like Tracy and Craig Albernaz may lean too heavily on analytics, and that Mike Elias made the right move in trading Rutschman for the return he got: right-handed pitchers Anthony Eyanson and Kyson Witherspoon, outfielders Enddy Azocar and Harold Rivas, and catcher Carlos Narváez.
Even with Rutschman’s rough series, the bigger takeaway was how strong the Yankees looked without Aaron Judge. For now, they look like the beast of the East. We’ll soon find out.
In Other News...
Orioles Nearly Changed Everything With Adley Rutschman Deadline Talks
With the Orioles hanging around the wild card race, the front office spent the deadline exploring just how far it could push the market on Adley Rutschman. Baltimore did not limit the discussion to one club, either. The Orioles talked with the Yankees and Rays before ultimately sending Rutschman to Boston, a move that came only after New York turned down a four-player package the Orioles had put on the table.
The final deal with the Red Sox brought back a five-player return that included prospects and a player to be named later, with Jake Rogers also going to Boston. It was a reminder of how aggressively Baltimore weighed both present needs and long-term control, especially with the players involved carrying different levels of performance and team control. Even for a club still in the postseason mix, the deadline became less about standing pat and more about whether the Orioles were willing to rework everything around one of their most recognizable names. [Read more 🡒]
Orioles Offseason Decisions Are Starting To Separate Roster Holds From Risks
With the Division Series getting underway today, the Orioles are already staring past the postseason picture and into an offseason that will test how aggressively they want to trim the edges of the roster. Baltimore has seven players eligible for arbitration this year, and the early expectation is that four will be brought back into the process while three may be left exposed to the market.
The larger wrinkle is that these calls are not happening in a vacuum. Arbitration decisions often turn on money, performance, and roster fit, but this winter they could also be shaped by the ongoing collective bargaining agreement negotiations, which add another layer of uncertainty to every hold or cut. For an Orioles front office trying to balance continuity with flexibility, the first real separation between useful depth and avoidable risk may already be taking shape. [Read more 🡒]
Orioles Suddenly Have Another Roster Problem Fans Can't Ignore
The Orioles offseason list keeps getting longer, and the latest concern is behind the plate, where the team still looks short on the kind of catcher who can steady a pitching staff and help shape games with defense. Baltimore has spent enough time talking about offense and overall roster balance, but for a club trying to raise its floor in a hurry, the catching situation has become hard to ignore.
Mike Bordick and Buck Showalter both weighed in on the issue, and their comments only sharpened the sense that this is a real problem rather than a minor depth question. Samuel Basallo and Carlos Narvaez are part of the conversation, while names like Jonah Heim and Austin Wells only underline the sort of presence the Orioles would like to have, but the bigger question is whether they can get there before the season turns their weakness into an everyday issue. [Read more 🡒]