Orioles Face One Costly Roster Question On Non-Tender Day

As MLB non-tender day approaches, the Orioles face critical decisions on their arbitration-eligible players amidst a backdrop of roster changes and potential lockout implications.

The Orioles have already trimmed a lot of the fat off their arbitration picture, and now the focus shifts to the four names still standing.

Major League Baseball’s non-tender deadline arrives later today, and any arbitration-eligible player who doesn’t get a contract offer becomes a free agent. Baltimore has been working through its list for months, starting in the summer with trades that sent starter Dean Kremer to the Twins, catcher Adley Rutschman to the Red Sox and reliever Tyler Wells to the Rays. The club also locked up starters Kyle Bradish and Shane Baz with extensions.

A few other names have already moved on. Switch-hitting outfielder Leody Taveras is done in Baltimore after clearing waivers on Nov. 2 and choosing free agency instead of accepting an outright assignment.

MLBTradeRumors.com projected his 2027 salary at $3.7 million. Relievers Albert Suárez and Codi Heuer were both waived at $1.1 million; Suárez became a free agent, while Heuer accepted his outright assignment and joined Triple-A Norfolk’s bullpen.

That leaves four Orioles in line for arbitration decisions, though none of them are in danger of being non-tendered. The real question is salary, and if the sides can’t settle before a three-person panel hearing, the case can go to February.

The current schedule has the clubs exchanging figures by Jan. 8, but that could shift with the expected Dec. 1 lockout at 11:59 p.m., which may push hearings into the regular season. That happened in 2022, when John Means and Trey Mancini were still unresolved before Means agreed to a two-year, $5.925 million deal and Mancini landed at $7.5 million with a $10 million mutual option.

Shortstop Gunnar Henderson is the biggest name in the group, and the biggest payday too. MLBTradeRumors.com pegs him at $14.1 million, based on its model.

The number isn’t perfect, but it did get Sonny Gray’s two-year, $55 million deal with the Twins right. Henderson has also been part of trade chatter, a byproduct of the Rutschman deal and the idea that if Baltimore would move its former franchise catcher and former 1/1, it would at least listen on anyone.

For now, though, president of baseball operations Mike Elias sounds like someone planning to keep him around. At the GM Meetings, Elias said he expects Henderson “to have a great season for us.”

Henderson is due a major raise after earning $8.5 million in his first year of arbitration eligibility. He’s coming off a down year by his standards, hitting .225/.309/.403 with 27 doubles, six triples, 24 home runs and 59 RBIs in 158 games.

His bWAR dropped from 8.8 in 2024, when he finished fourth in Most Valuable Player voting, to 5.4 and then 3.2. The Orioles can revisit the trade market next summer or in the offseason if 2027 goes sideways again, but for now the move is simple: set the salary and hope the injuries don’t keep piling up.

Félix Bautista is another important piece, and one with a very different role in the bullpen picture. Elias hasn’t named a single closer, but he has said Ryan Helsley gets the first shot after appearing in only 17 games this season because of elbow injuries.

Bautista, who returned in September after surgery to repair his right labrum and rotator cuff, appeared in 15 fewer games than Helsley. Together, they could give Craig Albernaz a nasty late-inning tandem after a season in which the Orioles kept searching for answers at the back end.

Eleven different Orioles recorded a save, which broke the franchise record of 10 set in 1987.

Bautista already avoided arbitration once, signing for $2.25 million after the Orioles gave him a two-year, $2 million deal on Sept. 30, 2023 before his Tommy John surgery. MLBTradeRumors.com projects him at $2.4 million in 2027, the year before he becomes eligible for free agency.

Colton Cowser is next, and his number is projected at $2.2 million in his first year of arbitration, up from $801,500. His role could be shifting as Baltimore looks for an everyday outfielder who can be a real presence in the lineup.

Cowser was excellent in center field, and his walk-off home run robbery in Colorado was chosen as the year’s best play. At the plate, though, he hit .226/.317/.370 in 142 games, still below the level he reached in 2024 when he finished second in Rookie of the Year voting.

He did make his mark in dramatic fashion. The Orioles hit two walk-off home runs this season, and Cowser had both of them - in Game 1 of the May 24 doubleheader against the Tigers and again on May 25 against the Rays.

That made him just the second Orioles player to homer for walk-offs on consecutive days, joining Fred Lynn in 1985. He also became the 13th player in team history with multiple walk-offs in the same season, and the first since Manny Machado tied the club record with three in 2017.

Cowser can fit in a platoon, or he can try to force more at-bats with a strong spring. His ability to handle all three outfield spots only helps.

Jordan Westburg rounds out the group, and his projected $1.5 million salary reflects the market more than the season he just had. He missed the entire year after reconstructive-elbow surgery, but he’s expected to be ready for spring training, whenever that starts, and to make the Opening Day roster.

Third base is crowded with Westburg, Coby Mayo and Christian Encarnacion-Strand, while Blaze Alexander can move around anywhere. Elias said the Orioles can make it work, though a trade remains possible.

It won’t be with the Mariners, who acquired third baseman Maikel Garcia from the Royals on Wednesday. Westburg was a rumored target there, but in Baltimore he looks like a clear tender candidate.

In Other News...

Red Sox Just Won A Catching Battle Orioles Fans Will Hate

The Red Sox have filled a need behind the plate by landing veteran catcher Nick Fortes from the Rays, a move that also cost them 17-year-old reliever Angel Roa in the deal. Fortes is expected to back up Adley Rutschman, and Boston cleared the roster spot by releasing Connor Wong after the trade came together.

For the Orioles, the more frustrating part is that they were in the mix for Fortes too before Boston got the deal done. Baltimore has been looking at ways to shore up its catching depth, so watching a division rival beat them to a player they wanted only adds another layer to an already familiar AL East annoyance. [Read more 🡒]

Orioles Are Taking Another Chance On Two Intriguing Pitching Arms

The Orioles kept working the margins of their pitching depth by adding two arms with some real intrigue attached. Baltimore claimed right-hander Braden Nett off waivers from the Athletics, then brought back right-hander Carter Baumler from the Rangers and optioned him to Triple-A Norfolk, another reminder that this front office is still hunting for upside wherever it can find it.

Nett has not yet reached the majors and was designated for assignment by Oakland, while Baumler already got a taste of the big leagues earlier this year before injuries interrupted his progress. He had been selected in the 2025 Rule 5 draft and later traded to Texas, so Baltimore is clearly willing to take another look at a pitcher it once had in the system. For a club trying to keep building pitching inventory, these are the kinds of moves that can quietly matter later. [Read more 🡒]

Orioles Just Lost One Possible Westburg Path At The Worst Time

The Royals six-player deal with Seattle, sending third baseman Maikel Garcia to the Mariners for pitcher Bryce Miller, has a ripple effect that reaches Baltimores offseason planning. The Orioles had been among the teams viewed as possible trade partners with Seattle for third baseman Jordan Westburg, and any movement around the Mariners infield picture naturally mattered to a club still trying to map out ways to upgrade before the lockout.

Westburg remains in recovery from Tommy John surgery, with his goal still to be ready by Opening Day, so Baltimores timeline is tied to both health and market conditions. With the Orioles continuing to explore different roster paths, the latest trade only narrows the field a bit more at a moment when they would rather have more options, not fewer. [Read more 🡒]