A long-term Gunnar Henderson deal once felt like a foregone conclusion in Baltimore. Two seasons ago, the Orioles looked like a team ready to do whatever it took to keep one of baseball’s brightest young stars in place for the long haul. Henderson was viewed as a future MVP type, the kind of player who could push a contract well past $300 million.
That conversation looks different now.
According to Jon Heyman of the New York Post, the Orioles reportedly offered Henderson an extension before the 2026 season. The exact number wasn’t reported, but it clearly would have been a significant commitment. Henderson chose to bet on himself, aiming for a big year that would make him one of the sport’s most highly paid players.
Instead, the season that followed fell short, especially in the later months. As Baltimore’s disappointing 2026 campaign gets picked apart, Henderson’s regression has become one of the biggest reasons fans point to. That’s not hard to understand when his offensive numbers are compared with his standout 2024 production.
There is still plenty of time for that story to change. Henderson is only 25, and it would be reckless to write off a rebound or assume his OPS won’t climb back over .800.
Even with the offensive dip, he still put together a 3.6 fWAR season in 2026, which ranked ninth among shortstops across baseball. But with free agency not arriving until 2029, the Orioles are already staring at the real question: what does a Henderson extension actually look like now?
Is a .715 OPS in 2026 enough to justify a deal that starts at $300 million or more? That’s the kind of calculation Orioles GM Mike Elias and the front office have to make.
There’s also a clear warning sign in the market already. Vladimir Guerrero Jr. signed a 14-year, $500 million contract with the Blue Jays in April 2025, and after looking solid in 2025, he went through the worst season of his career in 2026. Toronto is now living with that reality for 13 more years.
A more useful comp for Henderson may be Francisco Lindor. The Mets shortstop signed a 10-year, $341 million deal in 2021, and that level may be closer to the territory Henderson can still reach after his 2026 season.
Lindor, the current highest-paid shortstop in baseball, makes $34.1 million a year and has averaged 4.5 fWAR over his 12-year career. Henderson, through his first four full seasons, has averaged 4.9 fWAR.
But the trend line matters. Henderson’s production has slipped since his excellent 2024 season, and that changes the calculus.
If he wants to secure a deal now, the logic says he may be better off doing it sooner rather than later. Wait too long, and the money could keep sliding.
Any contract north of $35 million annually would put him in the top spot among shortstops, and that might be enough to get serious attention.
The problem is that Henderson is represented by Scott Boras, and that usually complicates extension talks. Boras clients have a long history of testing the market and passing on long-term deals with their current clubs, and Henderson may be no exception.
There’s also the injury side of this equation. Henderson has said he has dealt with a few injuries over the last two seasons, and while he insisted they weren’t excuses for his results, the connection is hard to ignore. It’s also fair to wonder whether the Orioles handled his health well enough in 2026.
Neither issue was severe enough to send him to the injured list, but Henderson said a shoulder impingement affected his swing in 2025. He has still appeared in at least 150 games in each of the last four seasons, yet the idea of more rest now seems worth revisiting. Playing through problems can turn small issues into bigger ones, and that would only muddy Baltimore’s future plans.
So while Henderson is still young enough to recover and still talented enough to command major money, the certainty around a massive Orioles extension is gone. He may yet bounce back and put himself back in position for a huge payday. For now, though, his sliding offense, the injury questions, and Boras’ presence have turned what once looked inevitable into a real mystery.
In Other News...
Orioles Suddenly Have A Tough Call On A Pitching Prospect
After missing time to a torn UCL and Tommy John surgery, some encouraging news has started to pile up around Orioles pitching prospect Kyle Bragg in the Arizona Fall League. The 2023 eighth-round pick has returned to game action and, in his brief Fall League work, has been sharp enough to remind the organization why he was worth developing in the first place, showing both strike-throwing ability and the kind of velocity that stands out this time of year.
Now the Orioles have to weigh the bigger-picture roster question that comes with a healthy Bragg. Because he is Rule 5 eligible, Baltimore has to decide whether to protect him with a 40-man roster spot, and those choices can get tricky fast when a pitcher is coming off surgery but also performing like someone other clubs might be tempted to grab. For a farm system that is always trying to balance depth against upside, Braggs progress has made this one worth watching. [Read more 🡒]
Orioles Have A Christian Encarnacion-Strand Question Fans Should Watch
Christian Encarnacion-Strand gave the Orioles a useful glimpse of what he can still be after arriving in Baltimore, flashing the kind of offensive production that made him such an intriguing young hitter when he first reached the majors with Cincinnati in 2023. After injuries slowed him down in 2024 and 2025, the change of scenery helped him settle in with Baltimore, where his bat played especially well against left-handed pitching and added another layer to an already deep lineup.
The challenge now is less about whether Encarnacion-Strand can hit and more about where he fits. Baltimores infield is crowded, and that makes his role for the 2027 season far from settled, even after the strong showing he delivered once he got into games for the Orioles. For a club trying to balance present production with long-term roster fit, he has become one of those players whose value is obvious, but whose usage still needs sorting out. [Read more 🡒]
Former Orioles Lefty Finds A New Chance After Brutal Setback
Nick Raquet has landed a new opportunity with the Tigers, who signed the left-hander to a two-year minor league contract as he works his way back from Tommy John surgery. For a pitcher looking for stability during a long rehab, the deal gives him that breathing room, with Detroit planning to keep him in the fold until he is ready to pitch again.
For Orioles fans, the name still carries some familiarity, since Raquet was let go in early September before this move to Detroit. The recovery timeline is a long one, and the Tigers are essentially betting on his health for 2028, but the contract at least gives him a clear path and a place to aim while he grinds through the comeback. [Read more 🡒]