Gunnar Henderson’s future in Baltimore suddenly feels a lot less settled than it did not long ago.
The Orioles are sitting outside the postseason picture, and that has opened the door to a conversation about whether they could move Henderson this offseason or even next summer. Baltimore already showed this year that no name is off limits, sending catcher Adley Rutschman to the Boston Red Sox at the trade deadline.
That possibility is complicated by Henderson’s recent form. He is still under club control until 2029, but the longer the Orioles wait, the trickier the trade calculus becomes.
FanSided’s Christopher Kline put it plainly: "He is still a winning player (3.2 fWAR), but Henderson's sloppy execution and crumbling confidence are becoming impossible to write off. It's far too early in his career to completely abandon hope, but the Orioles are working against the clock," FanSided's Christopher Kline wrote.
Kline also noted the risk that Henderson’s value could keep slipping if the defense at shortstop doesn’t hold up and the bat doesn’t come around again. "If he does not age well as a shortstop, that will tank his value.
If he can't recapture past glory at the plate, his value crumbles," Kline added. "And the longer Baltimore waits, the less opposing teams will be willing to cough up in a trade.
The more club control, the more value he still has."
The New York Mets are one team that could make sense if Baltimore decides to listen. Henderson, who won AL Rookie of the Year with a 6.1 bWAR season in 2023, is no longer producing at that level. He is hitting .220/.303/.397 with 22 home runs and a career-worst .700 OPS.
Even so, there is still a path for a team to bet on a rebound. Kline pointed out that if Henderson ends up at third base rather than shortstop, the Mets could pair him with Francisco Lindor on the left side of the infield, with Bo Bichette able to move to second base or DH in the meantime.
He also said New York’s financial muscle could help both in a trade and later in a potential extension. "New York is also the richest team in MLB, which would help improve their odds of re-signing Henderson down the road and potentially increase their appetite for trading multiple high-level prospects."
Whether the Orioles would actually deal Henderson before his walk year is still unclear. But if they do decide to move him, the Mets fit as a potential landing spot.
In Other News...
Orioles Wild Card Push Suddenly Hinges On Pete Alonso Concern
A tense moment in Oakland briefly sent a ripple through Baltimores wild-card chase when Pete Alonso was struck in the head by a 95 mph pitch from Kade Morris during the Aug. 30 game against the Athletics. Alonso was able to leave the game without any apparent major injury, and Orioles manager Craig Albernaz later said he was fine, but the scare landed at a time when every close call feels amplified for a club trying to stay alive in the playoff race.
Alonso has been central to Baltimores season, leading the team in home runs and WAR, so any concern around him naturally changes the tone of the conversation. Even with the early reassurance, the Orioles are left watching closely, because their push for a postseason spot depends heavily on keeping one of their most productive bats on the field and out of harms way. [Read more 🡒]
Coby Mayo Just Created A Tough Orioles Lineup Decision
Coby Mayo spent the first part of 2026 looking like a young hitter still finding his footing, but the second half told a different story. The 24-year-old Orioles third baseman settled in and started driving the ball with much more authority, especially against left-handed pitching, where he led MLB in home runs, slugging percentage and OPS. He also made progress against right-handers, which only adds to the sense that his late-season run was no fluke.
For Baltimore, the timing matters because Mayos surge points toward a larger role in 2027, and not just as a bat waiting for a matchup. The Orioles already have infield depth to sort through, so even a clear step forward from Mayo does not make the path simple. If his second-half production carries over, the club may have to make a real lineup adjustment to find him the kind of playing time his bat now seems to deserve. [Read more 🡒]
Orioles Injury Picture Just Got More Interesting With Ryan Helsley
Ryan Helsley took another meaningful step in his recovery Tuesday, throwing 24 pitches in his first live batting practice since June 27. The right-hander, who has been on the 60-day injured list with an elbow issue, had his work closely watched by the Orioles as they continue to sort through a pitching staff that has had to manage injuries and uncertainty all season.
Craig Albernaz said Helsley threw every pitch in the session with velocity in the mid-90s and upper 90s and looked great, a encouraging sign for a team that could use another late-inning arm if the rehab keeps moving forward. The Orioles also released their lineup for the game against the Guardians, while Luis Robert Jr. will stay with the club instead of reporting to Sarasota as initially expected, adding another small but notable layer to a roster picture that is still evolving. [Read more 🡒]