The Orioles have two Cubs outfielders sitting near the top of the free-agent board, and the choice between them comes down to fit, price and how much Baltimore wants to pay for upside.
Seiya Suzuki and Ian Happ are both age 32 candidates, both have spent the last five seasons in Chicago, and both could slide into the Orioles’ everyday lineup next season. The fit is straightforward on paper: Suzuki would play right field, Happ would handle left. The bigger question is which one makes more sense for a club that still has obvious outfield needs after Mike Elias missed on trying to fill left field with a Taylor Ward trade last year.
The production comparison is close enough to make this interesting, even if the styles are different. Over the last five seasons, Happ has played 775 games and posted a .245 average, .343 on-base percentage, .429 slugging percentage and .772 OPS with 110 homers, 389 RBI and 46 stolen bases. Suzuki, in 675 games, has hit .269 with a .351 OBP, .472 slugging percentage and .823 OPS, along with 113 homers, 382 RBI and 39 steals.
Suzuki brings the stronger bat. He gets on base a little more, hits for more power and is coming off his best defensive season.
Happ, though, has been a regular Gold Glove guy and brings the switch-hitting element Baltimore badly needs. That matters for a roster that could be overloaded with right-handed power bats depending on what Elias does next.
There’s also the money. Suzuki is being projected in the 4- to 5-year range at roughly $23 million to $25 million per season.
Happ is coming in lower, around 3 to 4 years at about $15 million to $17 million a year. The gap is enough to change the conversation, especially for an Orioles team that has not exactly shown a willingness to spend aggressively.
The market buzz also seems to favor Suzuki. He’s getting more hype this offseason and showing up on top free-agent lists from evaluators like Kiley McDaniel.
Happ has his supporters, but Suzuki appears to be the hotter name. Even so, the Orioles may find Happ easier to land, and a deal in the neighborhood of 3 years and $50 million is presented as something the club should be able to handle.
There’s a real argument for Suzuki as the better player and the higher-upside bat. He’s the one more likely to hit more home runs, and the offensive profile is stronger overall.
But Baltimore would likely have to outbid more teams for him, and that kind of deal could move quickly. That is not usually how Elias operates.
Happ, meanwhile, checks a lot of boxes: switch hitter, solid glove, lower price and a better fit for the Orioles’ roster construction. He’ll strike out more, but he also brings the walk rate and the versatility that stand out here.
The broader point is that Baltimore needs help in the outfield, and if the choice is between these two Cubs free agents, Happ makes the most sense at the right price. Suzuki is the better ballplayer. Happ is the cleaner fit.
In Other News...
Orioles First Rounder Is Finally Showing Why Fans Should Pay Attention
Vance Honeycutt spent much of his first full pro season trying to find his footing, and for a while the results matched the growing pains. The Orioles 2024 first-round pick, taken 22nd overall, had a rough run in Single-A and High-A, where the bat lagged and the strikeouts piled up, but the organization kept pushing him forward because the tools that made him such an intriguing pick were still there.
Since moving up to Double-A, Honeycutt has started to look more like the player Baltimore hoped it was getting, and that progress carried into the Arizona Fall League. He has been working with a hitting coach to tweak his swing, while also putting emphasis on the rest of his game, including baserunning and defense, which is the kind of all-around development the Orioles want to see as he tries to turn early struggles into real momentum. [Read more 🡒]
Trevor Rogers May Have Played His Way Beyond Baltimore
Trevor Rogers has given the Orioles enough to make him more than a short-term stopgap, and that is part of what makes his market so interesting now. After a solid recent run in Baltimore, the left-hander is drawing attention as free agency opens, with clubs looking at him as a young starter who can still fit into a long-term plan rather than just patch an immediate hole.
St. Louis is one of the teams being linked to Rogers, and the fit is easy to see from the Cardinals side. They need bullpen help, a veteran starter and possibly a third baseman, but they also have the payroll flexibility to chase a pitcher like Rogers if they decide he is worth the investment, which leaves Baltimore facing the familiar question of whether a rebound arm can be kept after he has reestablished his value. [Read more 🡒]
Orioles Face A Fast Moving Offseason Puzzle Before Time Runs Out
With a little more than three weeks before a potential lockout could freeze the market on December 1, the Orioles are staring at an offseason that suddenly feels compressed and complicated. Baltimore has been active over the past year, reshaping the roster with notable trades and locking up Shane Baz and Kyle Bradish on extensions, but the next wave of work looks less straightforward and far more urgent.
The list of needs is clear enough: starting pitching, a left-handed reliever, a backup catcher and right-handed hitting help in the outfield. The problem is that the free-agent pool does not look especially deep, which pushes the Orioles toward the trade market if they want to keep moving the roster forward before the calendar closes on them. [Read more 🡒]