The Orioles are staring at a deadline decision that could split two ways, but one target should stay on their board no matter how the next nine games go: Reid Detmers.
Baltimore is three games out of a playoff spot with nine games left before the trade deadline, which leaves the front office weighing two paths. If the club plays well, it can buy.
If it stumbles, it may have to sell. Either way, the Orioles should be looking hard at Detmers if the Angels decide to move him.
That’s because landing a top-tier starter has been a frustrating exercise for Baltimore. Over the last two offseasons, the Orioles thought they had a shot at several of the best free-agent starters and came away empty-handed.
This winter’s class is thin once you get past Tarik Skubal, and the Orioles are not going to be in that market. If they want a real impact arm anytime soon, trade is the route.
Detmers checks a lot of boxes for a team that needs pitching it can trust for the long haul. He’s under contract through the end of 2028, which makes him exactly the kind of controllable starter teams covet and almost never see hit the market.
If Baltimore passes and another club lands him, the Orioles are not likely to get a second crack at him this offseason. This may be one of their best chances to acquire a pitcher of this caliber with this much control.
His 4.05 ERA doesn’t jump off the page, but the deeper numbers tell a much different story. Detmers has four pitches that grade as above average by stuff+, and he pairs that with above-average command on all four pitches by location+. That combination is rare, and it’s the kind of profile Baltimore has seemed to chase without quite finding - pitchers with either stuff or command, but not often both.
The peripherals back it up, too. FIP, xFIP, xERA and SIERA all point to Detmers being one of the better pitchers in the league. Over a 120-inning sample this season, those numbers carry more weight than the ERA alone when you’re trying to identify a starter who can matter for years.
There’s also the fact that he has put up this kind of production while pitching for one of the least analytically advanced teams in baseball. With the right guidance, he could be even better than what he’s shown so far.
The Angels’ stance only adds to the intrigue. Reports out of Los Angeles this week say they are “very open” to trading their controllable players and beginning a much-needed rebuild. Baltimore has the kind of farm system that could make a deal happen, including a package of solid prospects similar to what it gave up in the Shane Baz deal, though this one would likely require a higher-end prospect than the best player in that trade.
A broad prospect package could help the Angels take a real bite out of their rebuild. The real question is whether the Orioles are willing to pay what it takes, or whether they let another chance to add impact pitching pass them by.
In Other News...
Orioles Top Prospect Ike Irish Faces A Brutal Injury Setback
The Orioles player development pipeline took a hit this week when Ike Irish landed on High-A Fredericks injured list after a knee injury, a tough turn for the clubs first pick in the 2025 draft and its No. 2 prospect. Irish had been one of the most closely watched young players in the system, so any extended absence immediately changes the conversation around Baltimores next wave of talent.
The setback was part of a rough stretch across the lower levels, with Delmarva infielder Cobb Hightower also undergoing ACL reconstruction and meniscus repair. Baltimore did make a pitching move to help cover the roster, recalling left-hander Josh Walker from Triple-A Norfolk, but the bigger concern for the organization is how much development time it stands to lose with two notable infield prospects suddenly sidelined. [Read more 🡒]
Orioles Ownership Just Weighed In On Mike Elias Before The Deadline
The Orioles used Kyle Bradishs five-year, $90 million extension as more than just a celebration of a homegrown arm. At a press conference announcing the deal, president of baseball operations Mike Elias and control owner David Rubenstein both tried to reinforce the bigger message around the organization: the club believes in where it is headed, and it is willing to keep investing in that direction as it builds around its core.
Rubenstein also made clear that the front office is not treating this as a one-off move, saying the team is open to more long-term deals with players who want to stay. With the Trade Deadline approaching, that matters for a club still trying to keep its season on track, and it puts a little extra weight on the next stretch of games as Baltimore sorts out whether its future is best served by adding, extending, or simply standing pat. [Read more 🡒]