Orioles Already Flipped Kyle Nicolas Again For Something Else

A significant trade between the Orioles and Nationals ushers in a new era of collaboration between the once-feuding teams.

The Orioles and Nationals finally crossed paths in a trade, and it came with a little history attached.

Baltimore sent reliever Kyle Nicolas to Washington in exchange for minor league infielder Randal Diaz, ending the long drought between the two clubs. It’s the first deal the franchises have made since the Nationals moved from Montreal to Washington in 2005. The Nationals optioned Nicolas to Triple-A Rochester and created a 40-man roster opening by moving Mitchell Parker, who is expected to undergo Tommy John surgery, to the 60-day injured list.

The swap won’t register as a headline-grabber, but it still lands as a notable moment for two organizations that have spent years at odds. Their friction dates back to the relocation, and the clubs also spent much of the last two decades locked in a dispute over rights fees tied to their complicated Mid-Atlantic Sports Network setup.

That arrangement finally ended in January, when Washington cut ties with MASN and shifted its in-market broadcasts to the league. Since the Angelos family sold the Orioles to David Rubenstein in 2024, the temperature has eased.

Baltimore chose a depth piece to get things moving, and Nicolas fits that bill. He has never pitched in an MLB game for the Orioles, and he arrived from the Reds just last month.

In Triple-A Norfolk, he has given up three runs in 4 1/3 innings. This is already his third organization of the year after Pittsburgh dealt him to Cincinnati in Spring Training for bat-first utility player Tyler Callihan.

The right-hander’s track record is built around stuff more than results. Over parts of four big league seasons, Nicolas has posted a 4.96 ERA in 105 1/3 innings.

He’s 27, throws hard, and features a pair of breaking balls that can miss bats, but the strike zone has remained the problem. In his MLB career, he has walked nearly 14% of the hitters he’s faced.

With Cincinnati this year, he handed out 13 free passes in 7 1/3 innings, and in Triple-A this season he has walked nearly a quarter of opposing batters across 20 innings.

That kind of control simply doesn’t work at the highest level, but the appeal has always been obvious enough that teams keep taking a shot. Nicolas also gets good extension from his 6’3″ frame, and Washington is the latest club willing to see whether a mechanical adjustment can help him stay around the zone more often. He’s in his final minor league option year and will remain in Triple-A for now.

Diaz, meanwhile, gives Baltimore a young infield option with some versatility. The 23-year-old was drafted in the fifth round out of Indiana State two years ago and is a right-handed hitter from Puerto Rico.

He’s been solid in High-A this season, hitting .253/.360/.406. He has drawn walks at an 11% rate, struck out 23% of the time, and gone 13-for-16 in stolen base attempts.

Diaz has not drawn much prospect buzz, but he does offer flexibility, spending most of this season at third base while also seeing time at all four infield spots.

Baltimore sent cash to the Reds for Nicolas less than a month ago, so landing Diaz in return gives the front office at least a modest win on the transaction.

In Other News...

Orioles Fans Are Running Out Of Patience With Mike Elias

The Orioles pitching problems have become hard to ignore, and so has the frustration surrounding the man tasked with fixing them. After eight years with Mike Elias in charge of baseball operations, the club still looks like a team searching for reliable arms, and the patience from a restless fan base is wearing thin as the front office keeps coming up short on the area that has most defined the rosters shortcomings.

Around the league, there is at least one example of a franchise choosing a different path and finding some relief from it, with the Nationals moving on from Mike Rizzo during the season last year and then showing signs of improvement afterward. For Baltimore, the question is no longer whether the pitching staff needs help, but whether that help has to start with a change at the top before the draft and trade deadline arrive and another chance to build a contender slips by. [Read more 🡒]

Orioles Finally Get A Key Arm Back But The Cost Is Real

Baltimores pitching shuffle finally brought a familiar arm back into the mix, but the ledger still came out with several moving parts attached. Dean Kremer returned from the injured list, giving the Orioles a needed boost on the mound, while the club also sent Trey Gibson to Triple-A Norfolk, designated catcher Dom Keegan for assignment, optioned left-hander Josh Walker and brought Cameron Weston back to the majors.

For Gibson, the demotion comes after a rough outing in his last turn, and Weston now gets another look after already making his big league debut earlier this season. The Orioles have been trying to keep the staff stabilized through injuries and roster churn, and this latest round of moves suggests the return of one key pitcher has only sharpened the pressure to keep finding answers elsewhere. [Read more 🡒]