Buck Showalter isn’t buying the idea that the Orioles’ troubles came out of nowhere.
On "The Daily Flock" this week, the former Baltimore manager pointed to the organization’s draft approach under Mike Elias and said there were warning signs in the way the club evaluated and handled high picks.
"I won't name names," Showalter said on "The Daily Flock" this week, "but there's a couple guys they drafted high that you can tell they want no part of the spotlight on them."
Showalter then laid out what he believes matters most when a team is making premium draft decisions: flexibility. In his view, players with the ability to move around the field give a club more ways to maximize the bat, while prospects tied to one spot have to be right from the start.
“You always look at players and you make them play their way off the premium position if they're a bat,” Showalter explained. “You know, you want them to fail at shortstop.
Let's fail at center field. Let's fail at catcher because we can find a lot of guys, you know, first base, left field, DH, whatever.
But you want him to fail there.
“And that's what was so intriguing about Bobby Wit coming out of the draft. This guy could play seven positions.
And wherever you had a guy who couldn't play … Bobby could play there. Even the guy CJ Abrams (taken sixth overall by the Padres and now an All Star shortstop with the Nats), you know, he could play multiple places.
“But when you draft somebody that can only play one place, you better be right because you’ve got nowhere to go in a different direction. And I think we all know what we're talking about.”
The piece of the Orioles’ rebuild that drew the sharpest criticism centered on Mike Elias’s first major draft choice in 2019, and the way that decision fit a larger pattern. The source material argues that Elias favored a safer, numbers-driven process over the kind of scouting instincts that valued body type, comps and intangibles, and says Orioles top scout Dean Albany pushed Bobby Witt Jr. according to numerous sources with knowledge of the situation before getting fired for it.
That same criticism extends to how the Orioles have handled their young talent since then. Jackson Holliday, the club’s former first-overall pick, is described in the source material as someone who has not held up at AAA shortstop and is now not a competent MLB second baseman. Gunnar Henderson, Elias’s second draft pick, is also mentioned as a player who may eventually need to move to third base and could be packaged for trade in 2027.
The Orioles did try to shift Adley Rutschman into a DH role, and the source says he filled that spot more than anyone else for the club from June 21, 2024 until he was dealt in early August at the deadline. It also says he was arguably the worst regular DH in MLB during that stretch. Baltimore then went with veteran backup James McCann behind the plate in the first game of a best-of-three playoff series.
The source also notes that since June 21, 2024, the Orioles have gone 192-211, the ninth-worst record in MLB and tied with the Marlins. It adds that Baltimore has not reached the playoffs since.
Showalter’s broader point, though, was about how the Orioles built their roster and what happens when a team leans too hard on certainty with elite draft picks. In his telling, the margin for error disappears fast when a player has nowhere else to go.
In Other News...
Orioles Suddenly Have Surprise Contributors They Cant Easily Ignore
A few unexpected names have started to make the Orioles roster picture a little more complicated. Josh Walker has given Baltimore useful innings out of the bullpen, Alex Hoppe has turned heads on the right side of the staff, and Coby Mayo has added another layer to the clubs list of players forcing their way into the conversation as the season goes on.
Luis De Len is part of that same group of surprise contributors, and his work has made the Orioles think more carefully about how he fits going forward. Craig Albernaz has pointed to those kinds of developments as part of the larger point of player growth, with Baltimore now weighing not just who has helped in the moment but who deserves a longer look when the team keeps sorting out roles. [Read more 🡒]
Gunnar Henderson Has Become A Bigger Orioles Problem Than Fans Expected
Gunnar Henderson arrived in Baltimore looking like the rare young star who could anchor a contender for years, and for a while he looked every bit the part. After winning American League Rookie of the Year and reaching All-Star status in his first two full MLB seasons, he seemed to be the kind of everyday force the Orioles could build around as the lineup matured behind him.
Instead, his production has slipped in 2025 and again in 2026, with key offensive numbers trending the wrong way and his overall value dropping with them. For a team that has watched its playoff hopes fade in recent seasons, Hendersons decline has added a frustrating layer to the bigger picture, because the Orioles are no longer just waiting on team-wide improvement. They are waiting for one of their most important players to look like himself again. [Read more 🡒]
Orioles Front Office Shakeup Could Signal More Changes Ahead
The Orioles appear to be in the middle of a quiet front-office reset, with assistant general manager Sig Mejdal reportedly moving out of his longtime role overseeing the analytics department and into a new job centered on emerging technologies and innovative practices in baseball operations. It is a notable shift for an organization that has leaned heavily into data and process under its current leadership, even if the team has not confirmed the change.
Matt Bloods departure adds another layer to the uncertainty, especially because it has not been officially announced either. For a club that has built a reputation for staying ahead of the curve, any movement involving key voices in the front office naturally invites questions about how the Orioles want that structure to look going forward and whether more changes are coming. [Read more 🡒]