The Cardinals still haven’t made a major splash this offseason, but a cryptic note from a team insider was enough to get fans thinking about a much bigger move.
Jeff Jones of the Belleville News-Democrat stirred the pot on Tuesday when he reposted something he had written in July about Jackson Holliday and added a simple “Still true” on X. That was enough to send Cardinals fans down the rabbit hole, especially with Baltimore’s name already floating around in trade chatter this winter.
Back in his July 29 post, Jones wrote, “Let’s be irresponsible: I believe there are people in the Cardinals organization who would move heaven and earth (short of JJ Wetherholt, Jordan Walker, and maybe three-ish prospects) to get their hands on Jackson Holliday, who in theory could play third. So that’s fun,”
Jones later clarified that his comment tied back to The Athletic’s Ken Rosenthal and Will Sammon, who reported that both Holliday and Gunnar Henderson could be trade candidates.
Holliday’s name carries obvious weight in St. Louis because he’s the son of Cardinals great Matt Holliday.
The younger Holliday has also been labeled a bust by some, though that feels awfully harsh given how early his career has gone. He appeared in only 60 major league games in 2024, then bounced back in 2025 with a .242/.314/.375 line, 17 home runs, 55 RBIs, 17 stolen bases, 21 doubles, three triples and 70 runs scored.
Injuries limited him to 98 games in 2026, and his numbers dipped a bit as a result.
He’s still only 22, though, and that matters. The Cardinals have seen this movie before with Jordan Walker, who was tagged with the same kind of bust talk before breaking out in 2026 and earning his first All-Star nod.
Holliday was the No. 1 overall pick out of high school in 2022, and he’s already a three-year big league veteran. That kind of timeline takes patience, especially when injuries keep interrupting the process.
If Baltimore really is willing to move him and take less than full value, St. Louis should be paying attention.
Third base remains unsettled, and Jesus Baez could be part of the picture eventually in 2027, but it would be a surprise to see him on the Opening Day roster since he hasn’t played above Double-A. Holliday, meanwhile, is under team control through 2030 and could slide right into the hot corner.
In that scenario, the Cardinals could be looking at Holliday at third, Masyn Winn at shortstop, JJ Wetherholt at second base and Alec Burleson at first base.
That kind of infield would be elite.
Of course, landing Holliday would not come cheap. The Orioles would almost certainly ask for at least one or two elite pitching prospects, and probably more.
The good news for St. Louis is that the Cardinals do have one of the strongest farm systems in baseball.
And Chaim Bloom has already left the door open to a trade-market addition if it fits the long-term plan.
The Cardinals are not likely to spend big for a short-term fix. Holliday would be the opposite of that, with four seasons of team control left and a profile that fits the club’s window. He’s also younger than both Wetherholt and Walker.
For now, this is still more dream than reality. But Jones’ post made one thing clear: if Holliday becomes available, the Cardinals should be ready to pounce.
In Other News...
Red Sox Just Won A Catching Battle Orioles Fans Will Hate
The Red Sox have filled a need behind the plate by landing veteran catcher Nick Fortes from the Rays, a move that also cost them 17-year-old reliever Angel Roa in the deal. Fortes is expected to back up Adley Rutschman, and Boston cleared the roster spot by releasing Connor Wong after the trade came together.
For the Orioles, the more frustrating part is that they were in the mix for Fortes too before Boston got the deal done. Baltimore has been looking at ways to shore up its catching depth, so watching a division rival beat them to a player they wanted only adds another layer to an already familiar AL East annoyance. [Read more 🡒]
Orioles Are Taking Another Chance On Two Intriguing Pitching Arms
The Orioles kept working the margins of their pitching depth by adding two arms with some real intrigue attached. Baltimore claimed right-hander Braden Nett off waivers from the Athletics, then brought back right-hander Carter Baumler from the Rangers and optioned him to Triple-A Norfolk, another reminder that this front office is still hunting for upside wherever it can find it.
Nett has not yet reached the majors and was designated for assignment by Oakland, while Baumler already got a taste of the big leagues earlier this year before injuries interrupted his progress. He had been selected in the 2025 Rule 5 draft and later traded to Texas, so Baltimore is clearly willing to take another look at a pitcher it once had in the system. For a club trying to keep building pitching inventory, these are the kinds of moves that can quietly matter later. [Read more 🡒]
Orioles Just Lost One Possible Westburg Path At The Worst Time
The Royals six-player deal with Seattle, sending third baseman Maikel Garcia to the Mariners for pitcher Bryce Miller, has a ripple effect that reaches Baltimores offseason planning. The Orioles had been among the teams viewed as possible trade partners with Seattle for third baseman Jordan Westburg, and any movement around the Mariners infield picture naturally mattered to a club still trying to map out ways to upgrade before the lockout.
Westburg remains in recovery from Tommy John surgery, with his goal still to be ready by Opening Day, so Baltimores timeline is tied to both health and market conditions. With the Orioles continuing to explore different roster paths, the latest trade only narrows the field a bit more at a moment when they would rather have more options, not fewer. [Read more 🡒]
