Stephen A. Smith didn’t see any reason to fight Alabama’s place in the latest College Football Playoff rankings.
On Wednesday’s edition of “First Take,” Smith said he had “no problem” with the Crimson Tide sitting at No. 3, even with Alabama’s 26-10 loss to Tennessee still on the résumé and Texas and Tennessee both chasing from behind at No. 5 and No. 9.
“When I look at Alabama, clearly the committee is not holding the (20-17) loss to Georgia against them. I think they should have held the Tennessee loss against them, because they got beat down in that particular game, make no mistake about that.
But then I’m looking at you right here, (and) you beat LSU. You stomped ’em.
You won at Kentucky when they were a higher-ranked team. I’m looking at you against South Carolina, against Mississippi State.
They were relevant at that particular moment in time when you handled your business against them.”
That Mississippi State win stood out in a big way. Alabama rolled 56-23 on Oct. 3, and the Bulldogs were 4-0 and ranked No. 16 in the US LBM Coaches Poll at the time.
The same idea applied to Kentucky and South Carolina, even if both were unranked when Alabama played them. Kentucky later climbed to No. 6 in the committee’s rankings before dropping back-to-back games to Tennessee and Florida. South Carolina reached No. 17 before Arkansas snapped its five-game winning streak in Week 12.
Alabama didn’t just beat those teams; it handled them. The Tide rallied from a 17-13 hole to beat Kentucky 45-17 in Lexington on Sept. 12, then turned around and beat South Carolina 49-18 on Sept. 26.
Smith also leaned on Alabama’s Nov. 7 win at LSU as another reason the committee had the right idea. He contrasted that 31-13 result with Texas’ one-point escape against the Tigers a week later.
“You did stomp LSU just over a week ago. I mean, you beat ’em like they stole something.
It wasn’t (like) Texas’ thriller, 22-21 come-from-behind win in the last second. They beat LSU significantly more convincingly than Texas did.
I get that Texas has got five wins in the top 25. I get that, but it’s not like Texas got bounced to No. 10 or 12 or something like that.
They’re right there.”
For Smith, the timing mattered too.
“I just think that it’s appropriate not to put (Texas) ahead of Alabama when you go up against a team like LSU, and you’ve got to come to the rescue and score in the waning seconds in order to win that game -- when Alabama, just a week earlier, I mean, beat the brakes off of them. I think that does matter, the proximity with those games...
I’ve got to take that into consideration. I have no problem with where Alabama is.”
Alabama is 8-2 overall and 6-2 in the SEC, with wins over East Carolina, Kentucky, Florida State, South Carolina, Mississippi State, Texas A&M, LSU and Vanderbilt. Its two losses came against Georgia and Tennessee.
The Tide’s remaining schedule includes Chattanooga on Nov. 21 and Auburn on Nov. 28.
In Other News...
Alabama Is Losing A November Tradition Fans Know Too Well
A familiar November quirk is coming to an end in the SEC, and for Auburn fans it changes one of the more recognizable rhythms of the season. Starting next year, the league will move FCS and Group of 6 matchups out of November and into September as part of a nine-game conference schedule, which means Auburn and Alabama will no longer get those late-season tuneups against lower-tier opponents.
For Auburn, the shift matters because those games have often served as a breather before the stretch run, even if they also came with their own share of scrutiny when the competition level dipped. The new setup should make the early season busier and the back half of the schedule more demanding, while also ending a November tradition that fans on both sides of the state have come to know all too well. [Read more 🡒]
Auburns Next QB Battle May Already Have A Real Contender
Byrum Browns time at quarterback is already giving Auburn a longer view of what comes next. The fifth-year starter will run out of eligibility after the 2026 season, which naturally pushes attention toward the depth chart behind him and who might be ready to step into the job when the Tigers need a new face under center.
Alex Golesh has at least one name to monitor in redshirt freshman Tristan Tia, who has drawn praise for how he has developed and prepared as the backup this season. No final call has been made on the position for next year, but Tia has put himself in the conversation as a real contender to compete for the starting role when the time comes. [Read more 🡒]
Auburns Quarterback Future Suddenly Looks More Complicated Than Expected
With Byrum Brown in his final college season, Auburns quarterback picture is already shifting toward what comes next, and it is not a simple handoff. Head coach Alex Golesh has a decision to make, and backup Tristan Tia has at least made the conversation more interesting after arriving from Oregon State and showing enough development to draw real notice from the staff.
Golesh and offensive coordinator Joel Gordon have both praised Tia for the way he has prepared and improved during the season, which could put him in line for more playing time as Auburn sorts out its plans. Even so, the Tigers are also expected to look at quarterback help in the transfer portal, a sign that the position could remain unsettled well beyond this year. [Read more 🡒]
