Notre Dames Surprising Start Is Raising One Big Rotation Question

Notre Dame Basketball's unexpected rising stars emerge as the team defies low preseason expectations in Players Era 8 Tournament, earning mixed reviews across their rotation.

Notre Dame left the Players Era 8 Tournament with something it didn’t have coming in: proof.

The Irish were supposed to be a team living near the bottom of the ACC, but that idea started to wobble after the season-opening win over Villanova. Then came a brutal draw in Las Vegas, opening against No.

1 Florida. Notre Dame still pushed the Gators hard before dropping an 86-78 decision.

From there, the Irish steadied themselves, outlasting Rutgers in overtime, 110-100, and then taking down Auburn, 78-73, in Thursday’s fifth-place game to improve to 6-1.

With an eight-man rotation carrying most of the load across those three games, there was plenty to sort through. Here’s how each rotation player graded out.

Braeden Smith: A

Smith’s four points against Florida kept him from a perfect mark, but what he did in the other two games more than made up for it. Against Rutgers and Auburn, he piled up 49 points, 14 rebounds and 10 assists, giving Notre Dame exactly the kind of engine it needed in two huge wins.

He also did it with remarkable efficiency, missing only five shots on 22 field goal attempts. Outside of Dedan Thomas of Houston, Smith was the best ball-handler at the event.

Braeden Shrewsberry: A

Shrewsberry looked every bit like Notre Dame’s projected top scorer. He delivered his two best scoring games of the young season, putting up 20 against Florida and 18 against Auburn.

He also knocked down 10 total three-pointers, which lifted his season three-point percentage to 41%. For Notre Dame, it was the kind of week that showed Shrewsberry can be the No. 1 option on a good team.

Brady Koehler: A+

Koehler was the biggest breakout of the tournament for the Irish. The sophomore looked like a player who could grow into an all-league forward, and he backed it up with production against quality competition.

He scored a career-high 27 points and grabbed eight rebounds against Rutgers, then added 17 against Florida’s elite frontcourt. That kind of showing against top teams gives Notre Dame a frontcourt piece it can trust.

Logan Imes: B+

Imes kept giving the Irish steady minutes and steady scoring off the bench. He posted at least seven points in each game, and his efficiency has been a real plus early in the season. Through this stretch, he’s shooting almost 60% from the field and 44% from three.

Jonathan Sanderson: B-

The freshman had his best moment against Florida, scoring 14 points and helping cover for Smith’s quieter night. He managed only five points combined in the other two games, and the overall shooting numbers still need work, with Sanderson at 36% from the field on the season. Even so, the Florida game showed why he matters in the backcourt rotation when a starter is off.

Ethan Roberts: C

Roberts had a rough finish to the week. Just 10 days after his 36-point outing, he was held scoreless against Auburn and fouled out in 19 minutes.

He did bounce back with 17 points against Rutgers in overtime, though he needed 11 shots from deep to get there, making just 3 of them. The encouraging part for Notre Dame is that Smith and Shrewsberry were able to cover for his inconsistency.

Logan Duncomb: C

Duncomb spent much of the tournament living dangerously in foul trouble, sitting one whistle away from fouling out in all three games. Still, he gave Notre Dame 12 points against Rutgers and battled against some strong frontcourts. The senior center looks set for a secondary role behind Koehler, but the Irish will benefit if he can stay on the floor.

Bryce Ruglass Dortch: C+

Dortch also ran into foul trouble against Florida and fouled out in that game, but his value showed up more on the defensive end. He isn’t going to bring much offense, and Notre Dame doesn’t need him to. What it did get was solid defense over 40 minutes across the three games, which is enough to make him a useful backup big.

In Other News...

Auburn Fans Need To Rethink Their Jordan-Hare Routine This Season

Auburn is asking fans to rethink their Jordan-Hare routine this fall as the stadium continues to operate around the Jordan-Hare North Project. With construction reshaping the north end of the venue, athletics officials have put several operational changes in place to help pedestrian flow and cut down on congestion, a sign that gameday access around the stadium is going to look a little different for the foreseeable future.

The biggest adjustment for regulars may be less about what happens inside the stadium than how they get there. Auburn is encouraging fans to use all available entry gates and follow designated routes, while familiar gameday touchpoints like Tiger Walk and Tiger Walk Plaza now come with updated schedules and locations. The construction is expected to run through spring 2029, but the long-term goal is a transformed north end without sacrificing seating capacity. [Read more 🡒]

Auburns Next Facilities Push Could Change More Than Fans Realize

Auburns next big facilities push is moving forward, and soccer is now part of the picture. The Auburn University Board of Trustees approved plans for a new Auburn Soccer Complex as part of Ever Auburn: Phase II, the latest step in the athletics departments capital campaign. The broader phase also touches several familiar corners of the athletic footprint, with planned investments in the Auburn Softball Complex, Neville Arena, Plainsman Park and the Jack Key Golf Teaching Facility.

For Auburn, this is about more than fresh concrete and updated seating. The campaign is being framed as a way to strengthen womens athletic programs, improve the day-to-day experience for student-athletes and fans, and build new revenue opportunities through premium seating and hospitality offerings. The soccer complex is one piece of a larger vision, and the real significance may come in how these upgrades reshape the way Auburn presents and supports its programs across campus. [Read more 🡒]

Saban Just Handed Auburn Fans New Iron Bowl Fuel

Nick Saban spent part of his latest national assessment praising the usual heavyweight programs, putting Georgia, Utah and Notre Dame at the top of his College Football Playoff list because of the balance they bring on both sides of the ball. He also left room for Alabama in the championship conversation, but the larger point for Auburn fans is the standard he set: the Tide are being measured against teams he sees as cleaner, more complete and less prone to mistakes.

That matters with the Iron Bowl looming, because the conversation around Alabama is not just about the quarterback play from Keelon Russell and the offense he has helped drive. The defense and running game are still being evaluated as the matchup approaches, and Sabans framing gives Auburn plenty to hold onto. If Alabama is still searching for the version of itself that can stack up with the nations best, the rivalry game is exactly where that uncertainty gets put under the brightest lights. [Read more 🡒]