Holden Geriner’s short-run revival at Pitt hit a wall in Week 6, and it came against Bill Belichick and North Carolina.
After Mason Heintschel’s season-ending injury in Week 5, the former Auburn quarterback was forced into the Panthers’ quarterback room and quickly gave Pitt a jolt. Geriner helped lead a 35-33 win over Virginia Tech last week, a result that pushed the Panthers into the AP Top 25 Poll. But the momentum didn’t last long.
North Carolina walked into Pittsburgh and left with a 21-17 win, knocking Pitt out of the rankings in the process. It was the first ranked win of the “Chapel Bill” era at North Carolina, and Belichick kept the celebration muted afterward, saying only that he’d have his Heels prepared for Duke next week.
For Pitt, the loss made last week’s rise feel fleeting. Pat Narduzzi had famously made the case for his team to be ranked after beating the Hokies, but the Panthers’ No. 25 spot is now a one-week stay. So much for that.
Geriner finished the game 27 of 44 passing, but the turnovers were the difference. He threw two interceptions, was sacked twice, and went 1-for-4 on the final drive, with his lone completion producing negative yardage.
Pitt entered the game as only a field-goal favorite at home, a line that suggested oddsmakers weren’t fully sold on Geriner carrying the load. That caution proved warranted.
The result also offered a harsh reminder of why Geriner never won a starting job at Auburn or Texas State. He had never started anywhere before Pitt, whether on the Plains or in San Marcos, and his limitations had shown up before. His mobility in the pocket has long been an issue, and while he has a strong arm, he has never quite put everything together.
At Texas State, Brad Jackson’s dynamism kept Geriner from seizing the job. At Auburn, the opening was there, but not the full starting-caliber package. Pitt has gotten solid work from him in a pinch, but the UNC game made the ceiling look clear: he’s been a bridge quarterback, not the kind who can carry a team for long.
And with Heintschel out, Pitt’s CFP hopes were already gone.
In Other News...
Tennessee Still Has The Same QB Problem Auburn Just Exposed
Tennessees depth chart heading into the Arkansas game offered a clear look at how unsettled things still are under center. Faizon Brandon and George MacIntyre were listed as co-starters, a reflection of the uncertainty that has followed the Volunteers even after their recent win over Auburn, where the Tigers helped expose how shaky the quarterback picture can look when the pressure rises.
Josh Heupel has already acknowledged Brandons shoulder issue, and both quarterbacks remain available, which keeps the decision in motion rather than settled. For Auburn fans watching from a distance, the update is a reminder that the loss still carries some aftereffects for Tennessee, and that the Volunteers are carrying real questions into a crucial SEC stretch. [Read more 🡒]
Auburns Defensive Portal Class Is Already Raising One Big Concern
Five games into the season, Auburns defensive transfer class is starting to get a position-by-position audit, and the early picture is a mixed one. The defensive line has held up reasonably well, earning the strongest mark of the bunch at a B thanks in part to Cody Siglers contributions, while the edge rusher group has landed at a C+ as the Tigers keep looking for more consistent disruption off the edge.
The concern is showing up a level deeper in the defense, where the cornerback group has been graded C- because the transfer additions have not produced much so far. Linebacker and safety have also brought only limited impact from the portal, which leaves Auburn with one obvious question as the season settles in: whether the defensive additions can become more than just depth pieces before the schedule starts pressing harder. [Read more 🡒]
Auburn Fans Will Recognize The Frustration In Florida's Latest Spiral
Floridas Week 6 loss to South Carolina brought the kind of frustration Auburn fans know well, the sort that starts with turnovers and quickly spills into bigger questions about direction. In a 38-19 defeat, Florida could not overcome the mistakes, and Jon Sumrall owned the result afterward while trying to steady a program that already feels like it is searching for answers.
For Auburn fans, the resemblance to Alex Goleshs early challenges is easy to spot. Both coaches have had to navigate quarterback uncertainty while making staffing decisions that are supposed to help solve the problem, not create more of it, and Floridas choice to bring in offensive coordinator Buster Faulkner and quarterback Aaron Philo only adds to the sense that the margin for patience is shrinking. [Read more 🡒]