October has arrived, and Week 5 in the SEC brings a little bit of everything - big quarterback spots, ugly defensive games, and a handful of matchups where nobody seems willing to give much away. The Auburn Roundtable crew is back to sort through the slate and track the standings as the season rolls on.
Through Week 4, Christian sits on top at 46-3. Zac is right behind at 45-4, Trey checks in at 43-6, and Michael is at 41-8.
The conversation starts in Starkville, where Alabama visits Mississippi State. Zac sees a close one, taking Alabama 35-28.
Christian thinks the version of Alabama that showed up against Florida State is different from the one that played South Carolina, and he’s betting on Mississippi State’s momentum to carry over: “We have seen two different Alabama's this season, one against Florida State and one against South Carolina. Which one will we get in Starkville?
I think the Kamario Taylor magic continues. Mississippi State 35, Alabama 31.”
The other picks lean Alabama as well, with one caller taking Alabama 28-21 and Michael simply going with “Alabama Cover.”
Georgia gets Vanderbilt next, and Zac expects the Bulldogs to control things with a 34-17 win. Christian believes Jared Curtis has a big future, but says this is still too soon for him to be the answer for Georgia: “I think Jared Curtis will eventually be seen as one of the better quarterbacks in the country, but he's not ready for Georgia yet.
Bulldogs win 41-10.” The other prediction on the board has Georgia winning 45-21.
Florida’s trip to Missouri has the group split between respect for the Gators and a sense that the Tigers could make it messy at home. Zac takes Florida 27-21, while Christian likes Florida 31-24.
Trey doesn’t dismiss Missouri at all, pointing to Austin Simmons and the run game behind Jamal Roberts after what he saw in Starkville: “Don't count the Tigers out of this one - I was super impressed with Austin Simmons and the run game behind Jamal Roberts on the road in a raucous environment in Starkville. I think Florida wins, but it is a fight to the finish.”
At Auburn at Tennessee, the weather and the run game loom large. Zac has Tennessee 27-21, but Christian is going the other way, calling for Auburn to win 24-21 and saying the defense is moving in the right direction after the Vanderbilt game. Trey expects both teams to lean on the ground game in the wet conditions and believes Auburn will find a way to slow down DeShaun Bishop and leave Knoxville with a win.
Kentucky at South Carolina brings plenty of pressure into the mix. Zac takes Kentucky 20-17.
Christian thinks South Carolina has to handle this one if Shane Beamer wants to quiet the noise: “If South Carolina loses this game, Shane Beamer might want to pack his bags. Gamecocks 31, Kentucky 27.”
Trey sees the pressure mounting too, saying, “The seat keeps getting hotter and hotter for Shane Beamer, and the writing is already on the wall.” Michael goes with Kentucky covering, and another prediction on the board has Kentucky winning 27-10.
Arkansas at Texas A&M draws straightforward confidence from the panel. Zac has Texas A&M 31-17, while another prediction lists the Aggies winning 38-14. Michael also takes A&M to cover.
The roundtable closes with McNeese State at LSU, where nobody is expecting much drama. Christian calls it a blowout and says, “This will be a blowout, without question.
LSU 58-3.” Another prediction has LSU winning 49-3, while Michael takes McNeese to cover, even if not to win.
The picks are in, and the only thing left is to see who reads the SEC board best this week.
In Other News...
Auburn's Bye Week Just Got More Urgent After Alex Golesh's Remarks
Auburns 24-14 loss to No. 17 Tennessee left the Tigers at 3-2 overall and 1-2 in SEC play, and it made the upcoming bye week feel less like a breather and more like a reset button. Alex Golesh pointed to the second-half performance as the place where things slipped, with the run defense, pre-snap penalties and even the crowd noise all showing up as problems that disrupted what Auburn was trying to do on offense.
Golesh also touched on individual player performances, a reminder that this is not just about fixing one phase of the game but about sorting through several issues at once. The bye week now offers Auburn a chance to clean up communication, tighten the defense against the run and get the operation smoother before the schedule turns back toward SEC pressure. [Read more 🡒]
Auburns Late Fourth-And-1 Decision Deserves Fresh Scrutiny
Late in the fourth quarter against Tennessee, Auburn had one of those calls that can linger long after the final whistle. Facing fourth-and-inches at its own 24 with just over six minutes left, the Tigers went with a toss to Jeremiah Cobb, and Tennessees defense was waiting. The stop flipped the field immediately and put Auburn under pressure at the exact moment the game was tightening.
From there, the sequence only got worse for Auburn. Tennessee turned the short field into a game-sealing touchdown, and Auburns next possession ended with an interception near the goal line. It was the kind of stretch that turns one questionable decision into the focal point of a loss, especially when the margin for error is already gone. [Read more 🡒]
Auburn's Biggest Problem Just Got Harder To Ignore Before Georgia
Auburn heads into the Georgia game with the same offensive concerns that have been hanging over the season, only now they are louder after a 24-14 loss to No. 17 Tennessee. The Tigers fell to 3-2 after a day in which Byrum Brown never quite got the offense settled, even with a touchdown through the air and another on the ground, while Tennessee found enough answers to keep Auburn chasing the game.
The defense did give Auburn chances by forcing turnovers, but the missed opportunities piled up once Tennessee leaned on DeSean Bishop in the second half. Bishop finished with two touchdowns and helped turn a competitive game into another frustrating result, leaving Auburn with little margin for error and even less time to sort out what is going wrong before the trip to face Georgia. [Read more 🡒]