The College Football Playoff is heading for a major overhaul in 2027, and not everyone is buying into the bigger-is-better pitch.
A new setup that would expand the CFP from 12 teams to 24 has already sparked a split reaction, with the change expected to eliminate conference championship games and open the door for more teams to reach the postseason. On SEC Now in Knoxville, TN, the discussion turned quickly from possibility to philosophy: what does college football even become when more teams can survive a few losses and still stay alive?
Paul Finebaum leaned into the idea after initially being skeptical.
“I think a lot of us were not in favor of this going in. But I woke up yesterday and instead of choosing violence, I chose to embrace this new paradigm,“ Paul Finebaum said.
He said the expanded format could actually sharpen the regular season, especially in the early months when marquee matchups sometimes get buried beneath weaker nonconference games.
“And I think it’s a good idea because you may boo, you may not like who you are, but let me tell you something, Tennessee fans. If you lose this game today, you’re probably out of the playoffs.
If you lose this game next year, and that’s your second loss. You’re still in the playoffs.
But I think overall, a year from now, fans are going to embrace it, especially those early season games instead of some of the garbage games that schools force fans to attend and buy tickets to. We’re going to see premier matchups, and I think that’s a plus.”
But the rest of the panel wasn’t nearly as comfortable with the shift.
Tim Tebow said he could see the upside, but he also thinks the playoff expansion changes the whole standard by which teams are judged.
“I think there will be some good things that come from this,” Tebow said.
“I think there will be some excitement around the tournament. I think more access to more teams, but I also think that it’s just important that we’re honest.
I think we changed the goalposts before. It was about how consistent could you be throughout this seat.
Now it’s about can you just get in and get hot at the right time. So it takes away the consistency.
Before you had to focus every single week and you had to show up, and you had to bring your best. Now you can have weeks where you don’t have to show up, and I think it changes the goalposts of what we’re asking teams, and really what this game of college football is about.”
Chase Daniel went even further, calling the idea flat-out terrible.
“I absolutely hate it, and for that reason, I mean, like, like, look, you-we have six ranked matchups this weekend in October,” Daniel said. “None of them matter next year.
They don’t matter. You’re, you’re going to see 2-3-4 loss teams get into these playoffs.”
Daniel also argued the expanded field could lower the standard and lead to even more mismatches once the bracket is set.
“I just think you are rewarding a level of mediocrity where, hey, you know what you don’t have to be good in the regular season every game doesn’t matter in the regular season you’re going to get more of these JMU matchups like we said at these first round games that are going to end up being blowouts and yes it does create access right but you’re going to see a lot of these teams and a lot of these coaches they’re going to schedule early season cupcakes.”
For now, the countdown to 2027 is on, and the debate around the “new” College Football Playoff is only getting louder.
In Other News...
Auburns Georgia Stunner Carried An Emotional Twist Tigers Fans Will Love
Auburns win over No. 1 Georgia in Athens already stood out as one of the seasons biggest shocks, but the finish made it feel even more memorable. The Tigers snapped a long drought with their first victory in Athens since 2005 and their first over Georgia since 2017, and they did it with a last-minute 34-yard field goal that sent the visiting sideline into celebration.
Alex McPherson has been through far more than a pressure kick at the end of a rivalry game. The Auburn kicker battled inflammatory bowel disease and underwent surgery before returning to the field, and head coach Alex Golesh made sure he got the game ball afterward, praising his leadership and perseverance as much as the winning kick itself. [Read more 🡒]
Auburn Still Has One Big Xavier Atkins Problem Heading Forward
Xavier Atkins was nowhere to be found when Auburn knocked off No. 1 Georgia on Saturday, and his absence was one of the quieter storylines inside an upset that will be remembered for a long time. The All-SEC linebacker has been central to what Auburn wants to do defensively, so losing him for a game of that magnitude only adds to the uncertainty around a unit that managed to come through anyway.
By Monday afternoon, there still was no update on Atkins status, leaving Auburn to carry the win while also waiting on one of its most important defenders. For a team that just took a major step forward, the lingering question is whether it can keep building on that momentum without knowing when one of its top playmakers will be back in the mix. [Read more 🡒]
Georgia Is Already Answering Auburn's Biggest Rivalry Win
Auburns rivalry win over Georgia on the field may have landed with extra force, but the recruiting battle is already swinging back the other way. Christian Mays, the top-ranked JUCO defensive lineman in the 2027 cycle, officially decommitted from Tennessee and announced his commitment to Georgia on his personal social media account, giving the Bulldogs another highly regarded addition to their front.
Mays currently plays at Northeast Mississippi Community College and brings the kind of profile that can shift an early recruiting board fast. For Auburn, it is another reminder that one big moment in the rivalry does not end the bigger chess match, especially when Georgia is already making its move for one of the cycles most sought-after defensive linemen. [Read more 🡒]