Kalen DeBoer is walking into fall camp at Alabama with a quarterback competition that says a lot about where the sport is right now. Austin Mack and Keelon Russell will battle for the starting job, and with the Crimson Tide set to open against East Carolina on Sep. 5, the answer is still very much up in the air.
That uncertainty has already created a pretty uncomfortable contrast. DeBoer’s move to Alabama brought Mack with him from Washington, and it also pushed Julian Sayin out the door.
Sayin is now the starter for preseason-ranked No. 1 Ohio State, while Alabama is still trying to figure out who will take the first snap.
Sports Illustrated’s recent ranking of every projected starter in the power four conferences only added to the odd feeling around Alabama’s quarterback room. Out of 68 players, Mack didn’t make the list and Russell checked in at No.
- Those rankings are built on projected talent, hype and vibes, and they don’t know who Alabama’s starter will be.
Still, it’s hard to ignore how unusual this feels for a program that has usually been stocked with elite quarterback talent.
The last time Alabama was in a situation that felt remotely similar, you have to go all the way back to 1998. JD Phillips, a fifth-year senior from Anniston, finally got his chance under Mike DuBose, with Neil Callaway serving as offensive coordinator. Phillips threw one touchdown and two interceptions that season and lasted just four games before Andrew Zow replaced him.
That history is part of why this current situation feels so loaded. DeBoer is expected to give Mack every opportunity to win the job over Russell, and there’s a real question hanging over that choice. Alabama’s Week 2 trip to Kentucky already looms in the background.
The larger issue, of course, is one college football keeps running into: nobody likes all the transferring. At the same time, loyalty still matters to a lot of people, and that’s where this debate gets messy.
Mack has been patient, and there’s something admirable about that. But Alabama is also supposed to be chasing the best quarterback available, not the most sentimental one.
Miami offers a pretty clear example of how ruthless the sport has become. Emory Williams waited three years in Coral Gables hoping to become the starter, but in 2025 the Hurricanes spent more than $4 million for Georgia quarterback Carson Beck.
This season, Miami spent $8 million on Duke quarterback Darian Mensah. Williams has since moved on to East Carolina for his senior year and is hoping to start against Alabama in Week 1.
Mack’s path has been longer than most. DeBoer and offensive coordinator Ryan Grubb recruited him to Washington in 2022, and Mack reclassified from the graduating high school class of 2024 to 2023.
Since then, he hasn’t started a football game in four years. He redshirted his only season at Washington, then sat far down the depth chart at Alabama in 2024 before backing up Ty Simpson in 2025.
There’s plenty to like about his staying power. He knows the system, and DeBoer has a strong reputation for developing quarterbacks.
But that doesn’t mean DeBoer owes Mack the job. These players are being paid, and that’s what the money is for.
Maybe Mack wins it and makes this whole thing look smart. If that happens, the story writes itself, and Sayin becomes just another footnote in the background. If not, and Mack starts over Russell only to struggle, then the accountability question gets a lot louder.
Either way, Alabama’s quarterback decision is about to tell us plenty.
In Other News...
Former Auburn NIT Starter Faces A Career-Defining College Decision
Keyshawn Halls path back into college basketball has turned into one of the more watched transfer-market decisions of the offseason. The former Auburn player, who went undrafted in the NBA, now has a fresh opportunity to extend his career after earning another year of eligibility, and a long list of programs has already taken interest in the versatile forward.
Kentucky, Indiana, Kansas, Gonzaga, SMU, LSU, Providence and UCF are among the schools linked to Hall as he weighs what comes next, and the timing makes the choice especially important. With the NCAA expected to cap his eligibility after this season, wherever he lands could shape the final chapter of his college career and go a long way toward determining what comes after it. [Read more 🡒]
Auburn Fall Camp Will Decide Which New Faces Force Their Way Up
The first official day of fall camp is about to put Auburns new-look roster under the microscope, and there are already plenty of places where the depth chart could change in a hurry. Under Alex Golesh, the Tigers enter camp with open competition across the lineup, from the secondary to the offensive front, and that means fresh faces will have real chances to turn summer momentum into actual playing time.
Bryson Washington remains one of the more intriguing names to watch after the Baylor transfer joined the running back mix, while sophomore Blake Woodby gives the defensive backfield another young option trying to carve out a role. The guard spots on the offensive line are also unresolved, adding another layer of intrigue to a camp that could quickly reshape how Auburn fills out its two-deep. [Read more 🡒]