Tyler Allgeier went to Arizona looking for a bigger lane, but the Cardinals may have closed it before he ever got rolling.
The former Falcons running back signed a two-year, $12 million deal with Arizona this offseason after wanting out of Bijan Robinson’s shadow and chasing a real shot to be a lead back. That logic made sense. In Atlanta, with a true generational talent already headlining the backfield, Allgeier was never going to be more than a change-of-pace option.
Then the Cardinals changed the picture fast.
Arizona used the third pick in the 2026 NFL Draft on Notre Dame running back Jeremiyah Love, instantly making an already crowded backfield even messier. Now Allgeier is part of a group that also includes Love, Trey Benson and James Conner, and the path he thought he was signing up for looks a lot different.
Bleacher Report’s Moe Moton pegged Allgeier as Arizona’s biggest bust for 2026, but the criticism seems aimed more at the situation than the player. Moton wrote, "Even if Love doesn't see the lion's share of touches out of the backfield, Arizona will likely be in catch-up mode for most of the campaign," Moton wrote.
"Allgeier hasn't caught more than 18 passes in any of his four seasons. So, unless Arizona has leads to protect, he'll be an afterthought in the run game."
That’s the bind for Allgeier. He’s not suddenly a different player because the Cardinals drafted Love, but the roster math is working against him.
If Arizona had taken Arvell Reese or Francis Mauigoa at No. 3, this signing would look a whole lot cleaner. Instead, the Cardinals brought in a back who profiles a lot like Bijan Robinson, the same type of player Allgeier was trying to escape.
The game script may not help either. Arizona is expected to spend plenty of time trailing with Jacoby Brissett at quarterback, and that only makes Allgeier’s lack of pass-catching production more of an issue. Across four NFL seasons, he has never caught more than 18 passes in a year, while Love is the better fit if the Cardinals are forced into a more aerial, comeback-heavy approach.
Love also comes with plenty of draft capital and attention. Moton noted that he is set to make the most cash of any running back in the NFL this year and was the highest-drafted RB since Saquon Barkley. Arizona clearly plans to use that investment, and a heavy workload for Love would fit the team’s goal of getting fans in the building.
Allgeier will still make more than $6 million per year over the next two seasons in Arizona, but the role he imagined when he left Atlanta has already shrunk. He came to the Cardinals to get away from an elite dual-threat back. Now he may be stuck behind one again, and the “bust” label that’s starting to follow him says more about the Cardinals’ draft choice than it does about Allgeier himself.
In Other News...
Falcons Just Got Linked To A Receiver Trade Fans Will Debate
With Drake London and Kyle Pitts now locked in on new extensions, Atlanta has some financial flexibility to keep shaping the offense, and wide receiver depth is one area that could still use attention. Bleacher Report floated the Falcons as a possible trade team to watch, pointing to the idea that the front office may not be done adding help for the passing game as it looks ahead to the 2026 season.
The appeal is easy to see from Atlantas side: there is room to make a move, and there are still questions about how much reliable production the receiver room can provide beyond the top options. The suggested target is a young pass catcher who flashed with a career-high 503 receiving yards in 2024, even if his situation in Denver never fully settled, which is exactly the kind of profile that can spark debate about whether a trade would be worth the cost. [Read more 🡒]
Falcons Created A Defensive Problem Fans May Regret All Season
Kaden Elliss is gone, and with him goes one of the more important stabilizers Atlanta had on defense. The Falcons are now left trying to sort through a linebacker room that looks thinner and less proven than it did a month ago, which is a problem because Elliss was doing far more than just filling a spot. He helped hold the group together, and his departure leaves a noticeable hole in both leadership and production.
For Atlanta, the concern is less about finding a body and more about finding someone who can actually do the job Elliss was doing. The current options bring different skill sets, but the Falcons are still searching for the kind of presence that can keep the defense organized and competitive over the course of a season. After finishing near the bottom of the league against the run, losing a player like Elliss only adds another layer of uncertainty to a unit that already had plenty. [Read more 🡒]