Michael Penix Jr. Suffers Brutal NFL Setback

Atlanta's gamble on Tua Tagovailoa as the starting quarterback against the Steelers brings a mix of hope and caution for the new season.

The Atlanta Falcons are heading into Week 1 with Tua Tagovailoa at quarterback, and that decision has already nudged the betting market for Sunday’s trip to Pittsburgh.

According to the report, Atlanta has settled on the veteran starter for its regular-season opener against the Steelers while Michael Penix Jr. continues working back from the torn ACL he suffered last November. Penix was not cleared for 11-on-11 work until Aug. 22, and the Falcons are choosing not to push him back before he’s ready.

Tagovailoa’s preseason did not exactly light things up, but Atlanta is leaning on his experience. That’s the bet the Falcons are making with Week 1 looming.

The line has reflected that choice. Pittsburgh opened as a three-point favorite, then moved to 3.5 ahead of kickoff.

The shift to Tagovailoa as the starter may have accounted for part of that move, though Atlanta is still listed at -118 to cover. There’s also a chance the spread could drift back to three.

The betting splits point the other way, at least for now. At DraftKings, 78 percent of the moneyline bets and 58 percent of the spread bets are on the Steelers.

That makes sense on paper. Pittsburgh was a playoff team in the 2025 season, and it enters this matchup with Aaron Rodgers back at quarterback. Atlanta, meanwhile, is sitting as a long shot at +13000 to win the Super Bowl, and the market clearly isn’t sold on Tagovailoa after what happened last season.

His 2025 numbers tell the story. Tagovailoa was cut loose by the Miami Dolphins after throwing for 2,660 yards, 20 touchdowns and 15 interceptions while going 6-8 in 14 starts. He has finished a full 17-game season only once in his NFL career, which is why it wouldn’t be a surprise if Penix gets a shot early in the 2026 season.

For now, though, the Falcons are rolling with the former first-round pick in Pittsburgh. Atlanta is projected for 7.5 wins in 2026, with the UNDER at -140, and if Tagovailoa starts fast, the Falcons could at least keep themselves in the NFC South conversation.

Odds refresh periodically and are subject to change.

In Other News...

Falcons Week 1 Quarterback Decision Just Raised A Bigger Offensive Question

The Falcons have settled their Week 1 quarterback spot, with Tua Tagovailoa earning the job over Michael Penix Jr. after a summer competition. He will open the season against the Pittsburgh Steelers, giving Atlanta a clear answer at the most scrutinized position on the roster as the team tries to get its offense pointed in the right direction.

But the decision also leaves a bigger question hanging over the group, especially with Atlanta set to keep four quarterbacks on the roster in Tagovailoa, Penix, Cooper Rush and Jack Strand. The depth chart now has a defined top spot, yet the way the Falcons chose to build around it suggests the quarterback room will remain one of the most closely watched parts of the team as the season gets underway. [Read more 🡒]

Falcons Strange Running Back Decision Finally Makes Sense

The Falcons decision to open the 2026 season with just two running backs on the 53-man roster looked odd at first, especially with Tyler Goodson expected to be the No. 3 option. Instead, Atlanta kept Bijan Robinson and Brian Robinson Jr. active and pushed Goodson to the practice squad, a move tied directly to the teams choice to carry four quarterbacks on the roster as insurance.

For a team trying to balance depth across the roster, it was less about running back numbers than protecting itself at the most important spot on the field. Falcons executive Ian Cunningham made clear the setup is not fixed, either, saying the roster could change during the season depending on quarterback health and other needs, which leaves open the possibility that Atlantas backfield picture is only temporary. [Read more 🡒]

Falcons Still Have One Roster Debate Fans Cant Ignore

With the Falcons settling in around their 53-man roster for the upcoming season, the next phase is the part every front office has to navigate with patience: checking the practice squad market for help. There are always a few players around the league who slip through waivers, and for a team trying to squeeze every bit of value out of the bottom of the roster, that becomes a useful place to look.

Five names from other teams practice squads are already being floated as possible fits for Atlanta, each tied to a different need. Nothing is set, and that is what keeps the discussion alive, because the Falcons could still decide their best move is to wait, pounce later, or make a quiet addition that changes the depth chart in a hurry. [Read more 🡒]