The Atlanta Falcons made one of the biggest swings of the 2024 NFL Draft when they took Michael Penix Jr. at No. 8 overall, making him the fourth quarterback off the board in a class that kept coming. Caleb Williams, Jayden Daniels and Drake Maye went first, then J.J. McCarthy and Bo Nix followed shortly after, giving the draft six quarterbacks in the top 12 picks.
Now, two and a half seasons later, NFL Network’s Bucky Brooks has taken another pass at that quarterback class, ranking the group and weighing whether each first-round passer should have his fifth-year option picked up this spring. That call has to be made before a player enters his fourth season.
Brooks left the top three in the same order they were drafted, then started to shuffle the rest of the group. Penix landed behind McCarthy, a placement that won’t sit well in Atlanta.
Brooks cited Penix’s injury history and the missed development time that came with it as reasons he would not pick up the option. At the same time, he made it clear he still sees real talent there.
“In an offense that allows him to throw to multiple blue-chip playmakers, Penix could post ridiculous numbers while operating like a point guard leading a fast break. Although he is still finding his way in navigating Kevin Stefanski's system, the impressive flashes from the left-handed gunslinger could still allow one to envision him as a long-term solution in Atlanta,” Brooks wrote on NFL.com.
That praise came with a catch. Brooks also pointed to Penix’s struggles under pressure, calling him one of the worst quarterbacks in the NFL in those situations, while noting that the new system and lost time could be part of the explanation. The bigger concern, though, is whether he can stay on the field long enough to build the experience he needs.
Still, the McCarthy placement feels like a tough sell. Both quarterbacks came into the league with veterans ahead of them, and both have dealt with season-ending injuries. The Vikings moved on from McCarthy for a lowly fifth-round pick from the Giants.
McCarthy is 2-1 for the 5-3-1 Giants, but the production hasn’t exactly jumped off the page. He has 915 passing yards, two touchdowns and two interceptions.
There’s at least a case that Brooks leaned on McCarthy’s age and recurring injury history. McCarthy is 23, while Penix is 26, and Penix has had five season-ending injuries in seven seasons as a starter, dating back to college.
Even so, this has the feel of a familiar Falcons tax, where the team’s own mess colors how outsiders view the player. Penix hasn’t been better than McCarthy over the last two weeks, and he’s doing it on a worse team, but he has been better in almost every meaningful quarterback category.
Spencer Rattler, for what it’s worth, has played more games and owns a better TD-to-INT ratio and passer rating than McCarthy so far.
In the end, though, Penix’s real battle isn’t with McCarthy. It’s with himself. He has seven games left to convince general manager Ian Cunningham and the Falcons that he can be the guy in 2027 and help push this team toward a playoff run.
If he can’t do that, Atlanta will be back in the quarterback market this offseason.
In Other News...
Falcons Fans Are Already Turning On Kevin Stefanski Too Fast
The Falcons went into their bye week at 3-7, and the frustration around another losing season is easy to understand. Under new leadership with general manager Ian Cunningham, president of football Matt Ryan and head coach Kevin Stefanski, the team has still struggled to show much progress, extending a stretch of disappointing seasons and coaching turnover since its last playoff appearance in 2017.
Even so, Stefanski is not drawing the kind of national heat that usually comes with a record like this after 10 games. Some Atlanta fans may already be turning restless, but around the league he has not been widely mentioned among the coaches on the hot seat, which suggests the bigger judgment on this regime is still ahead rather than happening right now. [Read more 🡒]
Falcons Loss Just Turned Into A Costly Discipline Problem
The fallout from Atlantas Week 10 loss to the Chiefs did not stop at the final whistle. The NFL handed out fines to three Falcons players for separate incidents from that game, adding another layer of frustration to a defeat that already carried plenty of sting.
Brandon Dorlus was fined twice, once for taunting and again for a late hit on Patrick Mahomes, while DeMarcco Hellams was docked for a hit on a defenseless player and Harold Perkins was fined for helmet use. The part that will likely stand out to Atlanta is that neither the Hellams nor Perkins plays drew flags in the moment, turning what looked like a physical game into a postgame discipline issue the Falcons now have to absorb. [Read more 🡒]
A.J. Terrells Slide Puts A Bigger Falcons Decision In Focus
A.J. Terrells season has become a reminder of how quickly a cornerbacks margin for error can shrink once injuries start to pile up. After a hamstring issue and then a groin injury sent him to injured reserve, the Falcons have seen a version of Terrell that has not looked like the player who once anchored their secondary, with coverage breakdowns showing up against both established receivers and younger opponents.
For Atlanta, that slide does more than raise short-term concerns. It also sharpens a longer-range question the front office may have to answer, especially if the Falcons decide a premium draft pick in 2027 is the right time to start planning for a future cornerback who can eventually take over for Terrell. [Read more 🡒]
