Michael Penix Jr.’s grip on the Falcons’ quarterback job is looking shaky enough that a new 2027 mock draft already has Atlanta eyeing a replacement.
In Connor Rogers’ latest mock for NBC Sports, the Falcons are projected to take Missouri quarterback Austin Simmons with the 10th overall pick. That would put Atlanta in position to move on from Penix just three years after drafting him eighth overall, a stunning turn for a player the team clearly hoped would be the answer.
The timing matters here. Atlanta is 3-6 after back-to-back losses to the Tampa Bay Buccaneers and Cincinnati Bengals, and the latest 22-point defeat to the Kansas City Chiefs in Week 10 only poured more fuel on the fire. The rumor mill is already spinning, and even the fanbase has started to turn on Penix.
Rogers made the case that the Falcons could be willing to reset at quarterback if they remain in the top 10.
"The Falcons are in an interesting spot with Michael Penix," Rogers wrote. "He’s shown he can hit big throws and attack down the field, but on top of injury issues he’s still significantly struggling under pressure (yards per attempt drops to 5.1 when pressured). Even more notable is that this regime did not draft him, leaving quarterback very much on the table if they pick this high."
That pressure number jumps off the page. Penix is supposed to be the guy who can push the ball downfield, but Rogers pointed to his struggles when the pocket gets messy as a major concern. The fact that this coaching staff wasn’t the one that drafted him only adds another layer to the situation.
Simmons, meanwhile, brings the kind of profile that can tempt a team looking for a fresh start. He’s left-handed like Penix, but he’s younger, more mobile and better when plays break down. Rogers described him as a player with arm talent, athleticism and youth, and called him a phenomenal processor.
Penix has had moments this season that still give Atlanta something to work with. Before the Week 8 game against Tampa Bay, he had thrown nine touchdown passes against only one interception. He also earned NFC Offensive Player of the Week honors in Week 7 against the San Francisco 49ers.
But the last three games have been a different story. Against the Buccaneers, he went 8 of 24 for 125 yards and threw four interceptions in one of the roughest outings of his young career, even with the weather playing a role.
In the 34-17 loss to Cincinnati in Madrid, he completed 20 of 31 passes for 162 yards, one touchdown and one interception. Then in Week 10, he needed 43 pass attempts to get to 286 yards, threw another interception, and failed to score a touchdown.
The Falcons haven’t said anything publicly about moving on from Penix, and they still have seven games left in the 2026 regular season to see if he can steady himself. But the warning signs are piling up fast, especially with Atlanta averaging just 10 points per game since Week 8.
In Other News...
Falcons Future QB Search Just Took A Telling Turn After Penix
The Falcons are still trying to solve the quarterback position for the long haul, and the latest signs suggest the search is already moving beyond the current roster. Since the Matt Ryan trade, Atlanta has cycled through multiple starters without finding a clear answer, and Michael Penix Jr. is expected to open the upcoming season as the starter while the organization keeps looking ahead.
What makes this notable is how far ahead the new front office is already planning. Kevin Stefanski and Ryan are reportedly evaluating quarterback prospects for the 2027 NFL Draft, with scouting attention on names such as CJ Carr and others, a reminder that Atlantas next franchise QB hunt is not being treated as a short-term fix. Penix may get the first crack, but the bigger picture around the position is still very much unsettled. [Read more 🡒]
Falcons Slide Has Put One Brutal Stefanski Question Back In Play
The Falcons latest skid has only sharpened the frustration around a season that has gone off the rails, with the team losing five of its last six and sitting at 3-7 in last place in the NFC South. For a fan base that has already grown restless, the conversation around head coach Kevin Stefanski has shifted from disappointment to the kind of hard question that tends to surface when a season starts slipping away.
Even so, the expectation inside the organization is that Atlanta will keep moving forward with Stefanski while trying to get through a year defined by limited resources. The bigger plan appears to be aimed beyond this season, with the Falcons looking ahead to a much better financial position and a stronger haul of draft picks next offseason, all while keeping an eye on building toward the 2027 draft class. [Read more 🡒]
Michael Penix Jr. Sends Clear Message After Falcons' Third Straight Loss
The Falcons are still hanging around in the NFC South race, but the margin for error is getting thinner after a third straight loss dropped them to 3-7. Michael Penix Jr. did his part to keep the offense moving, going 23 of 43 for 286 yards with one interception, while Bijan Robinson gave Atlanta a steady early boost by averaging 6.0 yards per carry on seven first-half runs.
Penix made it clear the message inside the locker room is simple now: every game left has to be treated like a must-win if Atlanta wants to stay in the playoff conversation. The upcoming bye week gives the Falcons a chance to reset and clean up some of the issues that have piled up during this skid, and it arrives at a time when they need it most. [Read more 🡒]
