The Falcons’ quarterback situation is already shaping up as one of the bigger storyline magnets of the season, and now both names tied to Atlanta are showing up near the top of an award watch list.
Grant Gordon of NFL.com put Michael Penix at No. 7 and Tua Tagovailoa at No. 10 among his top Comeback Player of the Year contenders, a sign that both quarterbacks enter the year with plenty to prove.
Penix’s case starts with the long road back. He has returned from two ACL tears and four season-ending injuries, but he still has not taken a single 11-on-11 rep this year.
Gordon noted that “the franchise’s trajectory might well ride on the left shoulder of Penix.” He also pointed out that Penix has only 14 NFL games on his resume, yet has already thrown for 2,757 yards with 12 touchdown passes and six interceptions.
Before anything else, though, Penix has to get cleared for full work and then, as Gordon wrote, “convince head coach Kevin Stefanski to give him the starting nod over Tua Tagovailoa.”
Tagovailoa’s path is different, but the pressure is just as obvious. He looked overwhelmed in his preseason debut against Denver, though that came in a small sample against a defense that led the league in sacks last season.
Gordon placed him on the list at No. 10 and wrote, “Ultimately, his days with the Dolphins ended on the bench. That leads him to a pivotal season -- and a giant opportunity with Kevin Stefanski manning the sidelines.
He might be the perfect fit for Tagovailoa, having already brought the better out of Kirk Cousins, Jacoby Brissett and Joe Flacco in past seasons with the Vikings as an offensive coordinator and with the Browns as their head coach.”
For either quarterback to actually win the award, the rest of the offense may have to do a lot of heavy lifting. The source points to an all-time great season from Bijan Robinson as the biggest must-have, along with a breakout year from WR2 Jahan Dotson, another strong season from Kyle Pitts and Drake London, and a top-five showing from the Falcons’ offensive line.
If all of that comes together and the Falcons still can’t get into the Comeback Player of the Year conversation, the front office may need to think bigger. The source says that would mean hitting the reset button and building around one of the quarterback prospects in the loaded 2027 draft class.
In Other News...
Falcons Fans Just Got Another Reason To Revisit The Darnell Mooney Move
The Falcons moved on from Darnell Mooney earlier this offseason, then pivoted by bringing in Jahan Dotson to fill the WR2 spot, a swap that made Atlantas receiver reshuffle one of the more notable roster decisions of the summer. Mooney, meanwhile, landed a one-year deal with the New York Giants, a fresh start that was supposed to give him a chance to re-establish his value in a new offense.
Instead, his standing in New York has already become part of the conversation, with Mooney sitting behind other receivers on the depth chart and the Giants reportedly weighing trade options. For Falcons fans, it is another little reminder that the teams choice to move on was not just about making room for Dotson, but about betting the receiving room could look different very quickly if the market and the roster both keep shifting. [Read more 🡒]
Michael Penix Jrs Recovery Just Raised The Stakes In Atlantas QB Race
Michael Penix Jr. is moving through the next phase of his recovery from a knee injury, and the timing matters more now because Atlanta still has not settled its quarterback decision for the season. He has been working in 7-on-7 drills, but full participation is still waiting on a doctors clearance, leaving the Falcons in a holding pattern as they sort through the competition under center.
Tua Tagovailoa is currently leading the race, but Penix remains very much in the mix if he gets the green light soon enough to get back into 11-on-11 work. For Atlanta, the appeal is obvious: the longer Penix stays in position to push, the more pressure there is on the staff to weigh not just health, but timing, readiness and how much practice time he can still bank before the season arrives. [Read more 🡒]
Former Falcons Star Kroy Biermann Faces A Painful Family Spotlight
A troubling family development has pushed former Falcons linebacker Kroy Biermann back into the spotlight, this time for reasons far removed from football. His son, Kroy Biermann Jr., was arrested and is being held without bond after facing aggravated sodomy and aggravated sexual battery charges, according to the available facts. The alleged incident is said to have taken place on April 23, 2026, in a Lifetime Fitness changing room, adding another difficult chapter for a family that has long lived in public view.
Biermann Jr. was arraigned on Aug. 17, 2026, with attorney Jason Sheffield listed as his representative. For Falcons fans who remember Kroy Biermann as a steady defensive presence during his Atlanta years, the case is a stark and painful reminder of how quickly an athletes post-career life can be overshadowed by personal turmoil around him. [Read more 🡒]