In a move that could shake up the NFL landscape, the Atlanta Falcons are emerging as a potential landing spot for Derek Carr, should he decide to come out of retirement. Carr has publicly stated his willingness to return to the league, provided he's healthy and has a shot at a Super Bowl. With reports indicating Carr is in top shape, the real question is whether the Falcons can offer that championship potential.
While the Falcons share the best odds in the NFC South for a Super Bowl win in 2027, it's still a gamble in a division known for its unpredictability. Remember, the Seahawks defied the odds with a Super Bowl win after starting the 2025 season with +6000 odds, highlighting the NFL's ever-changing dynamics.
Carr has plenty of reasons to consider Atlanta. The Falcons boast offensive weapons like Drake London, known for his impressive catch radius, and Bijan Robinson, whose agility and elusiveness make him a standout talent. On defense, Atlanta has transformed significantly since Carr's last stint in the NFL, breaking their franchise sack record and showcasing a promising rookie with five interceptions.
From the Falcons' perspective, bringing Carr on board is a strategic move. Michael Penix Jr., while promising with his strong arm, has shown inconsistency in deep ball accuracy and has limited experience with only a dozen games under his belt. The uncertainty around Penix's readiness for the starting role makes Carr an attractive option.
Carr's NFL track record speaks for itself. Over 11 years, including nine with the Raiders and two with the Saints, he has demonstrated resilience and skill, boasting a 68.2% completion rate and a 40:13 TD:INT ratio in New Orleans. Despite retiring mid-contract due to an injury in 2024, Carr's potential return could inject much-needed experience and leadership into the Falcons' roster.
However, acquiring Carr isn't straightforward. The Falcons would need to negotiate a trade with the Saints, as Carr remains under contract until 2027.
Regardless of the Saints' willingness to deal, Atlanta must explore this opportunity. With Kirk Cousins nearing the end of his tenure, the Falcons are in need of a seasoned veteran who can either mentor Penix or take the reins as the starting quarterback.
Carr could be just the player to lead Atlanta into a new era.