The Atlanta Falcons have made a bold move by hiring Kevin Stefanski as their new head coach, a decision that has already sparked plenty of discussion. According to the NFLPA's annual grading scale, Stefanski received the lowest rating among head coaches for his 2025 season with the Cleveland Browns, landing a “C-” grade.
NFLPA HC report card results:
— Dianna Russini (@DMRussini) February 26, 2026
A+ — Sean McVay, Dan Quinn
A — Ben Johnson, Dan Campbell, Andy Reid, Kevin O’Connell, Mike Vrabel, Aaron Glenn, Nick Sirianni, Mike Tomlin, Mike Macdonald
A- — Sean McDermott, Dave Canales, Zac Taylor, Brian Schottenheimer, DeMeco Ryans, Shane…
This grading, shared by Dianna Russini of ‘The Athletic,’ is based on anonymous surveys from active players, evaluating factors like on-field success, personality, player treatment, leadership, and professionalism. Stefanski's grade stands out as he was the only head coach to receive a “C-” last year, highlighting some challenges he faced in Cleveland.
Interestingly, while the Browns' defensive coordinator Jim Schwartz earned an “A-” grade, Stefanski's reception was less favorable, despite his accolades, including two AP NFL Coach of the Year awards during his six-year tenure. Notably, former Browns quarterback Baker Mayfield has been vocal about his criticisms of Stefanski, adding fuel to the fire.
Now, Stefanski steps into a high-pressure situation with the Falcons, who are eager for a turnaround. The team recently parted ways with Raheem Morris after back-to-back 8-9 seasons without playoff appearances. The Falcons' owner, Arthur Blank, also dismissed general manager Terry Fontenot, signaling a desire for swift progress.
Stefanski's appointment is a fresh start, yet the expectations are clear: Atlanta wants results, and they want them fast. As the Falcons look to break their cycle of coaching changes, Stefanski's leadership will be under the microscope. It's a new chapter for both the coach and the team, and all eyes will be on how this partnership unfolds.