The Falcons’ quarterback problem is staring them in the face, and the latest stretch from Michael Penix Jr. hasn’t done anything to soften it. After the 35-13 loss to the Chiefs in Week 10, Atlanta has managed just 10 points per game over its last three outings. A promising run earlier in the season has given way to a mess, and the idea that Penix is the long-term answer is looking thinner by the week.
That’s why the front office picture matters so much here. Matt Ryan is now in the building, and Kevin Stefanski is in place as head coach for a reason.
Stefanski has never chosen a first-round quarterback himself across seven seasons as a head coach. The two first-round passers he’s been around, Penix and Baker Mayfield, were already in the pipeline when he arrived.
The quarterbacks he helped bring in, Dillon Gabriel and Shedeur Sanders, were later-round bets. Getting the chance to land his own guy clearly played into why this job appealed to him.
And right now, Penix looks more like a bridge than a building block. He has thrown six interceptions over the last three games, which only strengthens the sense that Atlanta’s next real quarterback search is already underway.
The new group, with Ryan and Stefanski leading the way, is expected to do plenty of homework on the 2027 class. Ian Cunningham and the scouting staff have been tracking names like CJ Carr, Drew Mestemaker, and Darian Mensah, with Penix still the most likely Week 1 starter next season.
Among that next wave of quarterbacks, Notre Dame’s CJ Carr is the one most closely tied to Atlanta. If the Falcons are not in Drew Mestemaker territory, Carr is the name that keeps coming up.
He has 23 touchdown passes and just two interceptions this season, and he added another solid outing in Notre Dame’s 41-7 win over Boston College. Carr finished 20 of 28 for 217 yards, two touchdowns, and an interception, while the run game handled most of the heavy lifting for the No.
3 Irish.
Carr is near the top of the Heisman conversation, but the scouting picture is less clean than the numbers. He has plenty to like, but not a lot that screams elite.
He is accurate, he runs an offense well, and he looks comfortable within structure. The questions are about what happens when things break down and whether he can handle the College Football Playoff stage.
There’s real intrigue, but also plenty he still has to prove.
That said, there’s a case for why Stefanski would be drawn to him. Carr fits the mold of a high-floor quarterback, and there are shades of Brock Purdy in his game. If Stefanski wants a passer with sound mechanics who can execute what’s asked of him inside an offense, Carr makes a lot of sense.
Missouri’s Austin Simmons is another name worth watching, even if Saturday didn’t help his stock much. Simmons started last season at Ole Miss before Trinidad Chambliss took the job while he was hurt, and he has since broken out at Missouri after the Tigers lost Beau Pribula.
Ian Cunningham was in Athens for Missouri’s trip to face No. 1 Georgia, and Simmons had a rough afternoon in a 48-21 loss.
He completed 17 of 25 passes for 175 yards, three touchdowns, and a pick. The opponent matters, of course, but it wasn’t the kind of performance that leaves scouts buzzing.
Still, Simmons brings a lot to the table. He has strong arm talent, he processes the game well, and he’s a dangerous runner when plays break down.
He also graduated college at 19. One wrinkle: he signed an NIL deal to return to Missouri next season, though he remains eligible to enter the draft if he chooses.
If Atlanta doesn’t use one of its four top-100 picks on a quarterback, then the options get ugly fast. That would likely mean waiting until Day 3, and that would leave Penix in place for the rest of his rookie deal. Nobody in Atlanta wants that path.
In that lower-tier scenario, LSU’s Sam Leavitt would be the kind of fallback name to surface, but his stock has cratered this season. In LSU’s 22-21 loss to No.
6 Texas, Leavitt threw three interceptions, all of them in Longhorns territory. LSU failed to score on its final three possessions, and Leavitt now has 12 interceptions in 10 games, tied for the most in the nation.
Arch Manning also threw three picks in that game, but he delivered when it counted. Leavitt did not. At this point, the source material makes the evaluation plain: he is not viewed as an NFL-caliber quarterback and is seen as worth little more than a seventh-round pick, if that.
In Other News...
Falcons Slide Has Put One Brutal Stefanski Question Back In Play
The Falcons latest slide has pushed a familiar question back into the spotlight, and it is one the fan base has been asking louder with each loss. After dropping five of their last six games and sinking to 3-7, Atlanta sits at the bottom of the NFC South, with frustration around head coach Kevin Stefanski only growing as the season has unraveled.
For now, though, the expectation is that the Falcons will keep moving forward with Stefanski in place and turn their attention toward the bigger rebuild ahead. The organization is operating with limited resources this season, but the front office is looking ahead to a much cleaner financial picture next offseason, when cap space and draft capital should give Atlanta a better chance to reshape the roster and start planning beyond the current mess. [Read more 🡒]
Falcons Just Made Penix Jrs Evaluation A Lot Harder
The Falcons spent the deadline reshaping the middle of their roster, sending starting center Ryan Neuzil to the Ravens in exchange for guard Andrew Vorhees and a 2028 sixth-round pick. It was the kind of move that can look tidy on paper, but it also takes an experienced center out of the offensive line at a time when Atlanta is trying to get a clear read on Michael Penix Jr. and the offense around him.
Corey Levin is now the remaining option at center, and that makes the evaluation process a little messier than it needed to be. Atlantas other deadline deal, involving Jessie Bates III, brought back a more substantial draft return, so the Neuzil move stands out for a different reason: it adds uncertainty to the line just when the Falcons would prefer stability most. [Read more 🡒]
Falcons Just Gave Fans Another Reason To Question This Secondary
The Falcons secondary drew fresh scrutiny in Week 10 when rookie cornerback Avieon Terrell was inactive despite not being injured. The move was not tied to performance or discipline, but rather to a roster-management plan that has the team rotating defensive backs as it tries to sort out its options on the back end.
Terrell has been one of the brighter spots in that group this season, which is why the decision landed awkwardly with fans already uneasy about the cornerback depth chart. With the defense still searching for consistency, leaving a productive rookie on the sideline only adds another layer to the questions surrounding how Atlanta is handling its secondary. [Read more 🡒]
