The Falcons took Michael Penix Jr. eighth overall in the 2024 NFL Draft hoping they were landing a quarterback with the kind of arm talent that could grow into the job. Instead, Atlanta is staring at a decision that looks worse by the week.
Penix came into the league with plenty of shine after finishing as a Heisman Trophy finalist and leading Washington to the national championship. But the college version of him has not carried over to Sundays. He has had trouble staying healthy, and through 20 starts he owns a rough 7-13 record.
That frustration only got louder in Atlanta’s 35-13 loss to the Chiefs in Week 10. Penix needed 43 attempts to get to 286 passing yards, and he threw his sixth interception in the last three games.
At this point, it’s hard to argue he looks like the long-term answer. He has struggled under pressure, hasn’t been able to escape the pocket, and the idea of a long-term extension feels far away.
The pain is made worse by who was sitting there as an alternative. Falcons fans wanted a pass-rusher on Day 1, and the names tied to Atlanta were Jared Verse, Laiatu Latu, and Dallas Turner. Latu was the closest to being the pick, but Turner was in the mix too, and he’s now making that debate sting.
Turner went nine picks later to the Vikings at No. 17, and his career arc has only climbed since. He had a slow rookie start, but the flashes were there. Then he jumped to eight sacks last year, and Year 3 has been the biggest leap yet.
While Penix has looked lost and more like a bridge quarterback than a franchise centerpiece, Turner has broken out in a big way. He has already matched his 2025 sack total of eight, and he’s been playing like a future All-Pro for what has been the best defense in football.
At 23, Turner has become a key piece of Brian Flores’ defense. Only Will Anderson has more sacks than him this season, and Turner is also near the top of the league in tackles for loss.
He showed it again in Minnesota’s 30-10 win over the Packers on Sunday. Turner posted a sack, a QB hit, two tackles for loss, and a crucial fumble recovery on an aborted snap that set the Vikings up deep in Green Bay territory and helped them stretch the lead to 20 in Kirk Cousins’ first game back in purple.
The one wrinkle in the alternate timeline is obvious: if Atlanta had taken Turner, it likely would not have drafted Jalon Walker and James Pearce Jr. But that’s a trade the Falcons probably would have taken by now. Turner looks like a star, and anything would have been better than what Atlanta has gotten from Penix so far.
In Other News...
Falcons Slide Has Put One Brutal Stefanski Question Back In Play
The Falcons latest slide has pushed a familiar question back into the spotlight, and it is one the fan base has been asking louder with each loss. After dropping five of their last six games and sinking to 3-7, Atlanta sits at the bottom of the NFC South, with frustration around head coach Kevin Stefanski only growing as the season has unraveled.
For now, though, the expectation is that the Falcons will keep moving forward with Stefanski in place and turn their attention toward the bigger rebuild ahead. The organization is operating with limited resources this season, but the front office is looking ahead to a much cleaner financial picture next offseason, when cap space and draft capital should give Atlanta a better chance to reshape the roster and start planning beyond the current mess. [Read more 🡒]
Falcons Just Made Penix Jrs Evaluation A Lot Harder
The Falcons spent the deadline reshaping the middle of their roster, sending starting center Ryan Neuzil to the Ravens in exchange for guard Andrew Vorhees and a 2028 sixth-round pick. It was the kind of move that can look tidy on paper, but it also takes an experienced center out of the offensive line at a time when Atlanta is trying to get a clear read on Michael Penix Jr. and the offense around him.
Corey Levin is now the remaining option at center, and that makes the evaluation process a little messier than it needed to be. Atlantas other deadline deal, involving Jessie Bates III, brought back a more substantial draft return, so the Neuzil move stands out for a different reason: it adds uncertainty to the line just when the Falcons would prefer stability most. [Read more 🡒]
Falcons Just Gave Fans Another Reason To Question This Secondary
The Falcons secondary drew fresh scrutiny in Week 10 when rookie cornerback Avieon Terrell was inactive despite not being injured. The move was not tied to performance or discipline, but rather to a roster-management plan that has the team rotating defensive backs as it tries to sort out its options on the back end.
Terrell has been one of the brighter spots in that group this season, which is why the decision landed awkwardly with fans already uneasy about the cornerback depth chart. With the defense still searching for consistency, leaving a productive rookie on the sideline only adds another layer to the questions surrounding how Atlanta is handling its secondary. [Read more 🡒]
