The Falcons are heading toward 2026 with a quarterback situation that still feels unresolved, and Michael Penix Jr. sits right at the center of it.
Atlanta stunned the league when it took the Washington quarterback with the eighth-overall pick in the 2024 NFL Draft, especially after signing Kirk Cousins to a $180 million deal just a month earlier. Two years later, there still isn’t enough on Penix to say with certainty what the Falcons actually have. That uncertainty is part of why he’s being framed as the team’s biggest bust entering 2026, even if the blame doesn’t really belong to him.
The issue is opportunity. Penix Jr. is behind in his rehab, and the new coaching staff isn’t expected to show him the same patience the previous one did. That leaves Atlanta in a spot where it may never get a clean answer on the quarterback it invested so heavily in.
Bleacher Report’s Moe Moton pointed to that reality while ranking the Falcons’ biggest busts for 2026, and he put Penix Jr. at the top of the list.
"By default, Tagovailoa has the upper hand in this battle heading into training camp," Moton wrote. "As the Falcons' starter from the previous two seasons, Penix doesn't have the advantage of being the incumbent under a new coaching staff...
"By the start of the preseason, Tagovailoa may be in pole position for the lead role. Even if Penix wins the competition, his spotty 59.6 percent completion rate could eventually cost him the job.
Tagovailoa has a career 68 percent completion rate."
That lines up with the way the competition is being viewed. The coaching staff has said the battle won’t begin until Penix Jr. is a full participant, but that feels like a hard sell. Tua Tagovailoa has had more time to get back into rhythm and shake off the offseason rust, while Penix has been focused on recovering from his surgically repaired knee.
That difference matters. Tagovailoa should be able to pick up Kevin Stefanski’s offense and show it in live action much faster than Penix Jr., who is still working his way back. And that’s why, for now, the Falcons’ future at quarterback remains as murky as ever.
In Other News...
Falcons Suddenly Have A Tyler Shough Problem They Can't Ignore
Tyler Shoughs first season in New Orleans gave the Falcons a reminder that quarterback development does not always move in a straight line. After taking over for the Saints, Shough helped them win four of their final five games in 2025 and finished with a strong closing stretch that made the rest of the division take notice, especially after he piled up big passing numbers down the stretch and ended up near the top of the rookie awards conversation despite a limited sample.
Now the Saints have tried to make the next step easier, adding more help around him while keeping the core pieces in place. With Kellen Moore running the offense and a deeper group of weapons available, Shough looks set up for a real Year 2 jump, which is exactly the kind of development Atlanta cannot afford to dismiss in a division that already feels tighter than it should. [Read more 🡒]
Falcons May Be Counting On Brandon Dorlus For Something Much Bigger
Brandon Dorlus went from promising piece to real difference-maker for Atlanta in 2025, turning in a breakout season that gave the Falcons a legitimate interior pass-rush threat. Under Jeff Ulbrich, the defense found some welcome continuity, and Dorlus looked like the kind of player whose growth can change how opponents have to protect the quarterback.
ESPN analyst Ben Solak pointed to that rise as something Atlanta can build on, noting that the development should keep moving in a straight line after a season that showed the team a version of Dorlus it had been waiting to see. With the Falcons already seeing how effective he can be in pass-rush situations, the bigger question now is how far his role can grow as the front continues to evolve around him. [Read more 🡒]