Sitting at 3-7 going into the bye week, the Falcons are exactly where nobody in Atlanta wanted them to be. That much is obvious. What’s less obvious is how much of the blame should already land on Kevin Stefanski in his first season running the show.
Atlanta brought in a new football structure this year with general manager Ian Cunningham, president of football Matt Ryan and head coach Kevin Stefanski. Through 10 games, though, the results look a lot like the same old Falcons instead of any real step forward. That’s why Stefanski is already catching heat, even if not all of it is fair.
The easy reaction is to ask whether he should already be on the hot seat. Carter Bahns’ CBS Sports list of the top 10 coaches entering Week 11 didn’t include him. The names ahead of him were Aaron Glenn, Shane Steichen, Brian Schottenheimer, Jim Harbaugh, Nick Sirianni, Dan Quinn, Todd Bowles, Robert Saleh, Kellen Moore and DeMeco Ryans.
That list says plenty on its own. Dan Quinn, Atlanta’s former coach, is still trying to hold onto his job in Washington.
Bowles and Moore are both in the NFC South. And of the 10 coaches on that list, every one except Saleh has at least one full season in place with his current team.
Sirianni is in Year 6 in Philadelphia, and Bowles is in Year 5 in Tampa Bay.
It’s easy to understand why some Falcons fans would already be ready to move on from Stefanski. His hire didn’t exactly come with universal applause.
But it was still a more defensible move than the one before it, when Raheem Morris was brought back after being fired following just two seasons. Even so, writing Stefanski off after one year feels premature.
The truth is, he walked into a franchise that has been broken for a long time. The Falcons have not reached the playoffs since 2017, and since then they’ve gone 55-78 over eight seasons without a winning record. They’ve also burned through three general managers - Thomas Dimitroff, Terry Fontenot and now Cunningham - and five head coaching tenures.
The unraveling started with Quinn, who led Atlanta to Super Bowl LI and then won 10 games the next season. He was fired after an 0-5 start in 2020, along with Dimitroff.
Morris finished that year as the interim coach and went 4-7. Arthur Smith followed and went 7-10 in each of his three seasons before getting fired.
Then Atlanta circled back to Morris, the same coach it had passed over in 2021. Before his 2024 hire, his head coaching record was 17-31 in three seasons with Tampa Bay, plus that 4-7 interim run in Atlanta.
He went 8-9 in both of his seasons and was fired in January.
If Morris was the answer, the obvious question is why he wasn’t the answer in 2021.
That’s the backdrop Stefanski inherited. He didn’t just take over a team with issues; he took over a mess that had been building for nearly a decade. And that’s before even getting to the quarterback situation, which has been a disaster from the start.
Atlanta had to restructure Kirk Cousins’ contract in the offseason and then cut him. That left the Falcons with a banged-up Michael Penix Jr., which pushed them to sign Tua Tagovailoa because the Dolphins were paying him. Atlanta got him for the veteran minimum of $1.215 million, while Miami is responsible for the remaining $52.785 million of his 2026 salary and an NFL-record $99.2 million in dead money.
By the time the season began, Tagovailoa wasn’t available for his first start, Penix said he wasn’t ready, and Cooper Rush ended up under center. Then Penix finally got the nod, played well for two games and briefly made it look like Atlanta might have something. Since then, the draft has started to look a lot closer on the calendar.
That part matters because Stefanski knew what kind of quarterback situation he was stepping into. It’s not exactly new territory for him.
In six seasons with the Browns, he started 13 different quarterbacks, including seven over his final two years in Cleveland. Maybe he figured he’d eventually get his guy in the draft.
Maybe he thought Penix would be that guy. Either way, he knew the position could be a problem.
Now the question is how long Atlanta will give him to sort it out.
His Cleveland résumé cuts both ways. Stefanski went 45-56 in the regular season with the Browns, made the playoffs twice and won AP Coach of the Year in both 2020 and 2023.
From 2020 through 2023, he delivered Cleveland’s best four-year winning percentage since the late 1980s. But the Browns dropped to 8-26 over his final two seasons, and he was fired in January.
Cleveland hasn’t exactly fallen apart without him, either. Under first-year coach Todd Monken, the Browns are 6-4 and have already passed last season’s win total.
Even with that, Stefanski probably deserves more than a one-year verdict. The NFC South still looks winnable, and the division is hardly loaded.
Two of his rivals’ coaches are already on the hot seat list, and the Panthers lead the division at just 4-5. Nobody is separating from the pack.
Stefanski’s first job is simple enough to say and hard to do: get the Falcons back to the playoffs and end the drought. But before that can happen, he has to find a franchise quarterback. If that search stretches into 2027, then the next question becomes how much time he’ll have left to develop one before the pressure starts all over again.
In Other News...
Falcons Loss Just Turned Into A Costly Discipline Problem
The fallout from Atlantas Week 10 loss to the Chiefs did not stop at the final whistle. The NFL handed out fines to three Falcons players for separate incidents from that game, adding another layer of frustration to a defeat that already carried plenty of sting.
Brandon Dorlus was fined twice, once for taunting and again for a late hit on Patrick Mahomes, while DeMarcco Hellams was docked for a hit on a defenseless player and Harold Perkins was fined for helmet use. The part that will likely stand out to Atlanta is that neither the Hellams nor Perkins plays drew flags in the moment, turning what looked like a physical game into a postgame discipline issue the Falcons now have to absorb. [Read more 🡒]
A.J. Terrells Slide Puts A Bigger Falcons Decision In Focus
A.J. Terrells season has become a reminder of how quickly a cornerbacks margin for error can shrink once injuries start to pile up. After a hamstring issue and then a groin injury sent him to injured reserve, the Falcons have seen a version of Terrell that has not looked like the player who once anchored their secondary, with coverage breakdowns showing up against both established receivers and younger opponents.
For Atlanta, that slide does more than raise short-term concerns. It also sharpens a longer-range question the front office may have to answer, especially if the Falcons decide a premium draft pick in 2027 is the right time to start planning for a future cornerback who can eventually take over for Terrell. [Read more 🡒]
Michael Penix Jr. Is Already Facing A Falcons Future Debate
Michael Penix Jr. arrived in Atlanta with plenty of intrigue when the Falcons took him eighth overall in the 2024 NFL Draft, making him the fourth quarterback selected. He was viewed as a big swing on upside, and NFL Networks Bucky Brooks recently reinforced that by praising Penixs potential while also putting his long-term outlook under a brighter spotlight.
Brooks assessment centered on the kind of caution teams often weigh with young quarterbacks who have already dealt with injury issues and lost development time. For Penix, the next stretch matters because he has seven games left to show the Falcons he can be the kind of quarterback worth building around, and the kind of player who can quiet an early debate about whether Atlanta should commit to his future. [Read more 🡒]
