Patrick Mahomes’ rehab situation is giving Falcons fans a little perspective on Michael Penix Jr.
Atlanta has taken a cautious approach with Penix, and that looks even more sensible when you compare it with what Kansas City is doing with Mahomes. Penix tore his ACL in mid-November, and the Falcons have kept him on a careful recovery path because it’s his third ACL tear in the last seven years. He also has a history of lower leg injuries, which is part of why the team appears comfortable starting Tua Tagovailoa in Week 1 and giving the young quarterback more time to get right.
As things stand, Penix still has not been cleared for full contact heading into training camp. The Falcons are scheduled to begin summer practices on July 29, and a quarterback battle is set to start then, but Kevin Stefanski knows better than to bite off more than he can chew with Penix.
The Chiefs, though, are moving far more aggressively with Mahomes. He tore his ACL and his UCL in mid-December, which leaves him only seven months removed from reconstructive ACL surgery.
Even so, Kansas City has already cleared the two-time MVP to practice when training camp opens, and he has been cleared for full participation. That stands in contrast to Penix, whose injury was less severe but who still has not taken any 11-on-11 reps since getting hurt.
Andy Reid must be petrified of the idea of having to start Justin Fields against the Denver Broncos in Week 1 if he's rushing Mahomes back like this. We all saw how that ended last time. But it seems like Kansas City is playing it much more fast-and-loose with their QB's recovery than the Dirty Birds are.
It’s not hard to see why the Chiefs would want Mahomes back quickly, especially with Fields as the alternative. But the risk is obvious.
Rushing a quarterback back to avoid an early skid can create bigger problems later, and getting him on the field before he’s truly ready can lead to a setback. Playing him before he’s 100% also means it could take longer for him to look like himself again.
There is at least one reason Kansas City can afford to be patient if it chooses to. Outside of the Broncos, the Chiefs have a favorable opening stretch, with the Colts, Dolphins, and Raiders next on the schedule. The smarter move, as laid out here, would be to put Mahomes on PUP and give him the four weeks to recover.
For Falcons fans, the takeaway is simple: the way Atlanta is handling Penix should be encouraging. Compared with what’s happening in Kansas City, the Falcons look like the team taking the safer road.
In Other News...
Falcons Rookie Faces Troubling Camp Setback At Thin Position
Anterio Thompsons first summer with the Falcons has already taken an unwelcome turn, with the rookie defensive lineman missing organized team activities and minicamp before landing on the non-football injury list as training camp opens. Head coach Kevin Stefanski confirmed the absence is injury-related, and for a player trying to carve out a role on a defensive line that already has several bodies in the mix, every missed rep matters.
The timing is especially tough because Thompson was already facing an uphill climb to make the roster, and now he has even less room to make up ground. Atlanta will keep sorting through its defensive line depth as camp goes on, with Thompson needing to get healthy and rejoin the competition before the conversation about the final spots starts to narrow. [Read more 🡒]
Falcons Young Core Is Drawing A Frustrating Reality Check
The Falcons long-term outlook is getting a tougher look than the hype around their young core might suggest. ESPNs Aaron Schatz ranked Atlanta 22nd among NFL teams in elite talent under 25, a reminder that the rosters future foundation is not as deep as it can seem from the outside. On offense, the age curve has already started to flatten, and Bijan Robinson stands out as the lone top piece still under 25 without a new contract.
The defensive side brings its own uncertainty, with several of the younger names either still adjusting to bigger roles or carrying off-field questions that cloud their development. James Pearce Jr. is dealing with legal trouble and the possibility of a suspension, Jalon Walker is learning a new role, and Avieon Terrell remains unproven. Even the younger depth chart pieces, including Zachariah Branch, are still waiting to show they can translate promise into actual NFL production. [Read more 🡒]