The Baseball Writers’ Association of America rolled out its finalists for MLB’s major awards on Monday, setting up a week of reveals that begins Nov. 9 with the Rookies of the Year.
The biggest names are right where you’d expect them to be. In the American League MVP race, Houston Astros designated hitter Yordan Alvarez has made a strong case as the league’s top player after pushing hard for the Triple Crown.
But he won’t have a clean path to the trophy. Tampa Bay Rays third baseman Junior Caminero matched Alvarez for second in the league in homers, while Kansas City Royals shortstop Bobby Witt Jr. finished second in the majors in fWAR behind Chicago Cubs outfielder Pete Crow-Armstrong.
Crow-Armstrong is also front and center in the National League MVP conversation, where he’s trying to unseat Shohei Ohtani after the Los Angeles Dodgers star won the award in each of the past two seasons. PCA led the NL in OPS, tied for the league lead in home runs, and topped the majors in fielding run value and outs above average.
Ohtani still put together a combined 6.6 fWAR even while missing games and fading late because of injuries. Brice Turang, meanwhile, gave the World Series champion Milwaukee Brewers a steady offensive boost while continuing to play his usual high-level defense at second base.
The AL Cy Young finalists bring together a pair of pitchers who finished near the top of the league in strikeouts and ERA. New York Yankees ace Cam Schlittler and Toronto Blue Jays free-agent addition Dylan Cease tied for second in strikeouts in the AL and finished first and second in ERA, respectively. Parker Messick also earned a spot after a strong rookie year that included the third-lowest ERA in the AL and the fourth-best WHIP.
In the NL Cy Young race, Jacob Misiorowski looks like the clear favorite after a sophomore season that led the majors in both ERA and strikeouts. Chris Sale kept defying Father Time with one of the best seasons of his 16-year career, and Cristopher Sánchez anchored a strong Philadelphia Phillies rotation that also featured Jesús Luzardo and Zack Wheeler.
Manager of the Year in the AL has a familiar contender in Kevin Cash, a two-time winner already, after he guided the Rays to their first World Series appearance since 2020 and an AL-best 98 wins. Chad Tracy is in the mix after helping the Boston Red Sox climb to 77 victories following Alex Cora’s dismissal in April. Will Venable also has a real shot after helping turn around the Chicago White Sox, who had dropped three straight 100-loss seasons.
The NL Manager of the Year finalists include Pat Murphy, who can win the award for a third straight year after leading the Brewers to a major-league best 103 wins and the franchise’s first World Series title. He’s joined by Walt Weiss, who won 94 games in his first season managing the Atlanta Braves, and Don Mattingly, who helped revitalize the Phillies after the club fired Rob Thomson in April.
On the rookie side, the AL field features Detroit Tigers standout Kevin McGonigle, who turned in a historic debut and broke his franchise’s rookie record by reaching base safely 262 times. Messick is in position for a possible second award after also landing among the Cy Young finalists, while Payton Tolle’s breakout season and bright personality made him one of the league’s most popular players. Tolle also posted a 3.03 ERA with 171 strikeouts in 148 2/3 innings.
The NL Rookie of the Year finalists are led by Cincinnati Reds first baseman Sal Stewart, who wasted no time becoming one of the league’s premier power bats and finished second in RBIs and eighth in homers. Carson Benge’s case is built on all-around value, including one of the highest fWAR marks among qualified rookies and 10 outfield assists. JJ Wetherholt also made his mark with the glove, piling up 13 defensive runs saved while adding 17 homers and 14 steals.
In Other News...
Chris Sale Just Gave Braves Fans A New Reason To Celebrate
Chris Sales first season in Atlanta has already given the Braves plenty to feel good about, and now it has put him in line for one of the games top individual honors. The left-hander was dominant from start to finish, working to a 2.16 ERA while piling up 200 strikeouts over 162.2 innings, production that helped stabilize the rotation and justify the one-year contract extension he signed with the club.
The award race only adds to the sense that the Braves got exactly what they hoped for when they brought Sale in. His season put him among the National Leagues elite pitchers, and Atlanta also has another familiar face in the mix for postseason recognition, with Walt Weiss drawing consideration for manager of the year. For a team that spent the year chasing bigger goals, the hardware conversation is now part of the payoff. [Read more 🡒]
Braves Could Be Headed For More Hardware In November
The Braves are in line for more recognition this fall after two of the biggest names attached to the club landed among the National Leagues award finalists. Chris Sale is up for the Cy Young Award following a strong season in Atlanta, while Walt Weiss is in the mix for Manager of the Year after steering the Braves back to the top of the NL East.
Sale gave Atlanta the kind of front-line production it needed all year, and Weiss helped turn that into a division title and a much bigger win total than the club had a season ago. The winners will be announced in November, leaving the Braves with a chance to add some individual hardware to what was already a successful year. [Read more 🡒]
Brewers Face A Tough Trevor Megill Decision This Winter
With Raisel Iglesias heading into free agency after helping push Atlanta to the NLDS, the Braves are already looking ahead to how they might steady the back end of the bullpen. One name that keeps surfacing is Trevor Megill, the Brewers closer who has emerged as a possible trade target for a club that needs late-inning certainty and has a track record of being willing to shop from its pitching depth when the fit makes sense.
Megills appeal is obvious: he has the kind of stuff and role that can change a bullpens shape quickly, but Milwaukee also has to weigh the value of keeping him against the possibility of moving him while his market remains strong. For Atlanta, the question is whether the cost in young pitching is worth it, especially with the Braves trying to balance immediate help against the long view of a roster that still has plenty of moving parts this winter. [Read more 🡒]