The Phillies have a new look after the trade deadline, but the most awkward part of the roster puzzle might be the one that involves Alec Bohm.
Philadelphia interim manager Don Mattingly now has to sort through a lineup that got more crowded when the club added Luis Arraez. The bullpen side of things is straightforward enough, with right-handers Caleb Kilian and Brooks Raley joining a relief group that also includes Orion Kerkering, Jose Alvarado and Jonathan Bowlan as the bridge to All-Star closer Jhoan Duran. The real mess is on the dirt and in the outfield.
Arraez is set to play second base, which pushes Bryson Stott to third, moves Bohm to first and sends Bryce Harper back into right field. That alignment was the one used in the first game with Arraez in the lineup, with Trea Turner at shortstop, Stott at third, Arraez at second and Bohm at first. Harper started in right and later came out for Derek Hill, who entered as a defensive replacement.
That setup is exactly what has one prominent writer raising an eyebrow.
“The most obvious solution would be to slide Bryson Stott to third base - not ideal for midseason - and install Arraez at second, with Alec Bohm, who can neither hit nor field at this point, going to the bench or beyond, rather than moving him to first base and Bryce Harper to right field, as the initial reports suggest,” wrote Keith Law of The Athletic (subscription required) on a piece that was published Aug. 3.
Law’s skepticism is easy to understand when you look at Bohm’s season. He’s carrying a career-worst OPS+ of 72, along with a .227 batting average and a .283 on-base percentage, both of which would be single-season lows. If the numbers hold, his -1.1 bWAR would also move past his previous low of -1.2 from 2021.
That production level has also left his trade market dry. Philadelphia reportedly shopped Bohm before the deadline, but there were no takers. Law didn’t mince words about where that leaves the Phillies.
“I don’t know whether Bohm even has trade value at this point, with a $10.2 million salary and production below replacement level. And because he’s a free agent after the season anyway, the Phillies have no incentive at all to keep playing him. (Also, today’s Bohm’s 30th birthday, so, uh, happy birthday, have you considered celebrating in the Lehigh Valley?),” Law added.
If the goal is to keep the team from taking on more defensive strain than necessary, the cleaner answer may be to reduce Bohm’s role rather than force more moving parts around him. A platoon or bench arrangement, with Bohm sitting against some right-handed pitchers, would let Harper stay at first base.
That matters because Harper has already shown he’s willing to head back to the outfield if it helps the club. He can do it, and he’s willing to do it. But the Phillies don’t need to ask for more wear and tear if they can avoid it.
Philadelphia didn’t bring in another outfielder before the deadline, but Hill and Bryan De La Cruz have both handled work against left-handed starters. The question now is whether they can hold up well enough against right-handers too, because the Phillies may be better off using them more often and keeping Harper out of right field.
Bohm, meanwhile, is the piece that keeps dragging the conversation back to the same place. If he isn’t hitting and isn’t helping much in the field, the logic points to a smaller role. And for a Phillies team trying to get through the rest of the season with its best players intact, that may be the cleanest answer.
In Other News...
Ronald Acua Jr. Could Barely Believe How This Braves Homer Happened
Ronald Acua Jr. added another jolt to Atlantas offense against Miami, but this one came with a strange twist. What looked at first like a deep drive that might fall short turned into a two-run homer after a chaotic play in the Marlins outfield kept the ball alive and sent it over the fence, giving Acua one of the more unusual home run trots of his season.
It was the kind of moment that fit Acuas year in miniature, full of impact whenever hes been on the field and still shadowed by the hamstring issues that have limited him to 63 games. Hes up to 10 homers with 56 hits and 17 RBIs in 231 at-bats, and Atlanta would gladly take more swings like this one, even if the route around the bases is a little hard to explain. [Read more 🡒]
Braves Came Dangerously Close To A Deadline Move Fans Didn't See
The Braves spent the trade deadline searching for a starter who could genuinely change the shape of their rotation, and Alex Anthopoulos made clear the market was thin once Tarik Skubal was off the board. Ken Rosenthal reported that Atlanta and Texas got especially close on Jacob deGrom, with the club still probing other names such as Jos Soriano and ultimately deciding those arms did not represent enough of an upgrade over what was already in place.
What makes the deGrom pursuit stand out is how serious Atlanta was willing to be about making it work, even in a deal that would have required a major financial commitment. The framework never got to the finish line, and the final obstacle was tied to deGroms own approval, leaving the Braves to walk away from one of the most aggressive swings they apparently considered all deadline season. [Read more 🡒]
Brewers Prospect Sent Braves Top Prospect A Brutal Double-A Welcome
Cam Caminitis first step into Double-A came with the kind of spotlight that follows the Atlanta Braves top prospect everywhere he goes. The 2025 first-rounder worked 5 1/3 innings for Columbus in a win over Biloxi, and the outing gave Braves fans a decent early look at how his stuff can play against older hitters after a season spent climbing the ladder in the minors.
The night also served up a quick reminder that Double-A is often where every mistake gets amplified. Brewers prospect Josh Adamczewski set the tone immediately, and his strong 2026 season has only made him more of a challenge since his promotion, leaving Caminiti with a welcome-to-the-level test that carried plenty of edge even in defeat. [Read more 🡒]