Brewer Hicklen Gave The Braves A Tough Roster Question

Brewer Hicklen's ups and downs with the Atlanta Braves in 2026 reveal both his potential and the challenges that lie ahead for the outfielder.

Brewer Hicklen spent 2026 doing something a lot of Braves minor leaguers only dream about: turning a strong Triple-A run into real big league chances, then making enough of them count to stick around.

That wasn’t the expectation when Atlanta signed him to a minor league deal in the 2025-2026 offseason. Hicklen had the look of a classic journeyman outfielder, with stops that included being drafted by the Royals in 2017, traded to the Phillies for cash in 2023, signing a minor league deal with Philadelphia ahead of 2024, getting dealt to the Tigers for cash in 2025, then being traded back to the Phillies for cash later that same year before landing with the Braves.

The major league track record was tiny. Before 2026, Hicklen had only 13 big league plate appearances total: four with the Royals in 2022, five with the Brewers in 2024, and four with the Tigers in 2025.

He hadn’t done much with those chances, and the bigger concern was that his Triple-A bat had gone cold in 2025 after a better run in the minors before that. On paper, that made him look like a player whose ceiling was pretty modest.

Then 2026 happened.

Hicklen’s season split into two Braves call-ups: a two-week stretch in July around the All-Star break, then another run from late August through the end of the year. He forced his way into those opportunities by hammering Triple-A pitching. Through July 10, he had a 131 wRC+ for Gwinnett, and he finished the minor league season at 134 wRC+, with a .350 xwOBA backing it up.

The first big-league look was the loudest. In 21 plate appearances over five games, Hicklen came out swinging and produced a 200 wRC+ with a .355 xwOBA.

He was clearly running hotter than the underlying contact quality, but the production was real enough to matter. Later on, he shifted into more of a pinch-runner and defensive replacement role, taking nine plate appearances over 10 games and still holding his own with a 109 wRC+.

Down the stretch, though, the contact got shakier again: 17 plate appearances in five games, a .209 wOBA, and a .234 xwOBA.

All told, Hicklen finished with 47 plate appearances in the majors, a .348 wOBA, a 120 wRC+, and a .306 xwOBA. He played mostly right field, turned in nondescript defense, and was worth 0.2 fWAR. He also struck out in his lone postseason plate appearance.

What made him interesting was the shape of the skill set. Hicklen looked like the kind of tools-first player the 2019-2024 PowerPoint Braves tended to like: fast, aggressive, willing to swing hard and often, especially early in counts, and inclined to lift pulled contact rather than just spray the ball around.

The strange part was that he did all that without chasing much. For a player swinging with that much reckless abandon, the discipline was a surprise.

There were a few moments where that approach paid off. He had an RBI double against the Padres that stretched a 2-1 lead to 3-1 in the ninth, and another RBI double that did the same thing in the sixth in a different game.

He never had one signature swing that completely flipped a game, but he did post two games with more than 0.06 WPA. He also had three games at -0.06 WPA.

The problem was contact. Hicklen simply didn’t make enough of it.

His z-contact rate sat around 71 percent, well below the league average of about 83 percent, and that number was among the worst in baseball for anyone with at least 50 plate appearances. His o-contact rate was even rougher at 23 percent, compared with a league average around 58 percent, and it was the lowest for anyone with his plate appearance total or more.

That showed up in some ugly at-bats. In his Braves debut on July 12, he came up in the second inning after Dustin May had walked the first two batters and a bunt had moved them over.

Hicklen took a strike, fouled one off, then swung through a fastball in the zone for the strikeout. Atlanta only scored on a wild pitch in that inning, and the team won by a run late.

On July 21, he struck out three times and walked once in a blowout loss to the Padres. One of those strikeouts came with the bases loaded and two outs, when he was the tying run in the sixth.

The sequence was brutal: foul off a non-strike, miss a non-strike, then miss a pitch in the zone. The other two came after he fell behind by taking strikes and then waved at strike three.

Even with those issues, Hicklen’s 2026 season changed his standing. He’s still on the 40-man roster, and right now he projects as roughly a 0.5 WAR fifth outfielder thanks to his speed, his not-awful overall 2026 line, and the minor league production that got him here.

Atlanta could do worse, especially given how often it has carried bench players who don’t really offer much. But Hicklen is also out of options, which makes the roster math trickier.

The Braves could choose a player with more flexibility, or simply aim higher and look for someone projected closer to 1.0-1.5 WAR instead.

In Other News...

Braves Just Opened A Trade Debate Fans Never Wanted

Alex Anthopoulos has never been shy about keeping the Braves flexible, and his latest comments made that clearer. In an interview, the general manager said there are no untouchable players on the roster and that he is willing to listen to trade conversations involving anyone, a stance that fits the way he has tended to operate when the market starts moving.

Ronald Acua Jr. was the obvious name fans wanted reassurance on, and Anthopoulos gave it. He reiterated that the star right fielder is not expected to be traded, even if offers are out there, while also noting that conversations sometimes open the door to other possibilities. It is the kind of front-office language that keeps the phone lines active, even if the biggest name on the roster is not going anywhere. [Read more 🡒]

Braves Linked To Major Rotation Target With A Tough Trade Catch

The Braves are already being pushed toward a busy winter, and the rotation picture is part of why. With a shortstop still on the shopping list and another starting pitcher likely needed for the 2027 season, Atlanta has been tied to MacKenzie Gore as a possible answer if the club decides to get aggressive on the trade market. The left-hander is the kind of arm that can change the look of a staff, and the fact that he has one year left on his contract only adds to the appeal for a team trying to balance present needs with longer-term planning.

The catch, of course, is what it would take to pry him loose. One hypothetical framework has the Braves sending pitching prospects Owen Murphy and Luke Sinnard to land Gore, which tells you how steep the price could be for a pitcher with that profile. Atlanta has spent enough time dealing with roster gaps to know these conversations rarely come cheap, and this one would force the front office to weigh immediate rotation help against the value of two young arms it has reason to protect. [Read more 🡒]

Braves May Have A Mauricio Dubon Problem They Didnt Expect

The Braves may have a little more competition than expected if Mauricio Dubon reaches the market after his strong 2026 season in Atlanta. The Dodgers are already looking ahead to the 2027 offseason with infield needs of their own, and Dubon fits the kind of profile they tend to value: a right-handed hitter who can move around the middle infield and help cover for a roster with aging veterans and some uncertain futures.

For Atlanta, the wrinkle is less about what Dubon has done than what his next contract could look like if another contender decides he is the kind of versatile piece worth paying for. Utility players who can stabilize multiple spots are always in demand, and the Dodgers' interest suggests Dubon could have a broader market than the Braves might want to deal with. [Read more 🡒]