Hurston Waldrep’s 2025 finish had Braves fans dreaming about a rotation answer. His 2026 instead turned into a wreckage report.
The right-hander, the 24th overall pick in the 2023 draft, had shown enough late in 2025 to look like a real candidate for a bigger role the next season. He made that leap feel justified with seven strong outings down the stretch, then two more solid ones to close the year, finishing with a 68/79/89 line (ERA-/FIP-/xFIP-) across 56 1/3 innings and 1.2 fWAR.
For a team with a battered rotation and thin depth, that looked useful. Projection systems saw him as a below-average-to-average starter by rate, even if the innings weren’t likely to pile up.
Then the elbow issues hit.
Waldrep was first said to be dealing with elbow discomfort in mid-February, and a few days later he had surgery to remove loose bodies from the elbow. He didn’t get back into games until June, then took regular Triple-A turns before the Braves brought him up for three appearances, two of them starts.
After that, he went back down, made one more minor league start, and left it because of arm discomfort. A shutdown followed, then a return to throwing, and finally Tommy John Surgery.
By the end, he had just 29 innings total in 2026 after logging 148 innings across the minors and majors in 2024.
The big problem for Waldrep was that the stuff didn’t even resemble the version that flashed in 2025. In his three MLB outings, two graded out badly by ERA, xERA, and xFIP, and all three were bad by FIP.
His season debut against the Giants was a two-inning escape act with two hits, four walks, three strikeouts, and no runs. He was better against the Cardinals, working 5 1/3 innings with a 4/1 K/BB ratio and allowing a homer.
Then the Pirates got him, with two homers and a 2/5 K/BB ratio in the outing that basically ended the goodwill from the strong finish the year before. In 10 2/3 innings before the surgery, he posted -0.3 fWAR.
There were a few tiny bright spots, but not many. The Braves won his season debut.
His start against the Cardinals was at least passable. Otherwise, the team’s win expectancy dropped in all three appearances.
Waldrep leaned back into his junkball style, but it never really took hold. He threw more sinkers than his better splitter, and with his command wandering all over the place, that became a bad mix fast.
The Pirates start summed up the whole mess. Waldrep faced Paul Skenes with a 1-0 lead, then watched it flip on a grand slam.
Two of the runners had reached via hit by pitch and walk. After a quick second out, he issued another walk, gave up an infield single, and then Ryan O’Hearn - the same hitter who connected on the slam - tagged him for a three-run homer.
Waldrep also walked two of the three batters he faced in the fourth before coming out. It was third-worst on the Braves by ERA, FIP, and xFIP, bottom ten by xERA, and second-worst by WPA.
Now the timeline gets even longer. Waldrep will spend 2027 rehabbing from Tommy John Surgery.
That means the most realistic path has him ramping up for Spring Training 2028, especially given how long the elbow trouble dragged on before the procedure. And when he does come back, there’s no guarantee of anything.
Maybe he rebounds. Maybe he becomes another arm whose promise gets swallowed up by the wear and tear of pitching.
In Other News...
Braves Fans Will Instantly Recognize This World Series Parallel
A late-inning jolt from a rookie can feel like the kind of moment that shifts a World Series, especially when it comes in the 12th and puts his team ahead in dramatic fashion. Cooper Pratt delivered exactly that kind of swing, and for Braves fans, the scene probably felt uncomfortably familiar right away. The energy, the timing and the sense that a postseason game had just turned were all there, along with the uneasy memory of how quickly a championship script can change.
Milwaukee got the kind of lift that usually becomes a postseason legend, only for the Tampa Bay Rays to answer in the bottom half and flip the night back the other way. It is the sort of sequence Atlanta followers know too well from a recent October heartbreak, when a huge swing seemed to set one path in motion before the other dug in and changed the outcome. For Braves fans, the parallel is hard to miss, and it leaves plenty of room to wonder whether this latest version ends the same way or breaks the pattern instead. [Read more 🡒]
Braves Suddenly Face A Tough Jurickson Profar Decision
Jurickson Profar is back on a field again, but his return comes with more uncertainty than clarity for the Braves. The outfielder recently played for Tiburones de La Guaira in the Venezuelan Winter League, his first game action since receiving a 162-game suspension for a second PED violation that cost him the 2026 season, and Atlanta is now sorting through what comes next as it tries to map out the roster and the clubhouse.
Alex Anthopoulos has said the organization plans to have internal discussions about Profars future, which puts the Braves in an awkward spot after a season lost to suspension. Ronald Acua Jr. has also said Profar distanced himself from the team after the ban, adding another layer to a situation that is still very much unresolved as Atlanta weighs how to handle one of its more complicated offseason questions. [Read more 🡒]
Braves Face Tough Price Decision On Two Key Free Agents
Jim Bowdens free-agent projections put the Braves in a familiar winter spot, trying to weigh fit against price on two players who matter in very different ways. Mauricio Dubon brings the kind of defensive versatility teams value when the market gets thin, and the Athletic piece suggests there may not be much competition at shortstop if clubs start circling. For Atlanta, that can turn a reasonable ask into a tougher one, especially if other teams decide they need a glove-first option who can move around the diamond.
Raisel Iglesias is the more straightforward name, but not necessarily the easier call. Bowden projected the veteran closer at one year and $17 million after another All-Star-level season, yet the Braves may pause before going that high with a reliever on the roster already and some age-related caution attached to the deal. It leaves Atlanta staring at two free agents who could help right away, while also forcing a decision on how much certainty they want to buy this offseason. [Read more 🡒]