Braves Rotation Search May Test Alex Anthopoulos Like Never Before

As the Braves mull over their strategy for the upcoming season, the spotlight is on veteran pitchers and contract negotiations that could mark a shift in their approach to free agency.

The starting-pitching market is finally moving, and the Braves look like they’re sitting right in the lane where the next wave of deals could land.

Dustin May got things rolling earlier in the week with a three-year contract from the White Sox. Then Sonny Gray came off the board yesterday, returning to the Minnesota Twins on a two-year, $55 million deal. That kind of movement matters for Atlanta, because the names still available line up with the kind of starter the Braves have tended to chase.

Jeff Passan of ESPN summed up that group this way: “Right-handed veterans abound. Sonny Gray, Nick Martinez, Gausman and Matthew Boyd fit perfectly in any rotation - and are expected to command two years tops, satisfying the teams looking for shorter-term options,”

That description fits the Braves’ usual approach more than most teams’. Alex Anthopoulos has shown plenty of willingness to spend on relievers, but when it comes to starting pitchers, he has rarely strayed far from shorter commitments. A multi-year deal for a starter has not exactly been his favorite lane.

Kevin Gausman is the most familiar name in the mix. Atlanta got him at the 2018 trade deadline, before he turned into the breakout arm he later became with the Giants and Blue Jays. He’s 36 now, and while he’s no longer the Cy Young-level pitcher he once was, a one-year deal would fit neatly into the Braves’ comfort zone.

Nick Martinez is another option who checks a lot of boxes. He’s coming off an All-Star season at 35, with a 3.10 ERA in 31 starts. It was the first time in his career he worked strictly as a starter, but he’s been dependable in whatever role he’s asked to fill, posting a 3.53 ERA across 704.2 innings since the start of the 2022 season.

Matthew Boyd belongs in that same conversation. He’ll turn 36 in a couple of months, and over the last two seasons with the Cubs he settled in nicely, putting up a 3.50 ERA in 53 starts. He’s steady, he’s proven, and he’s not the kind of arm that should require a massive financial commitment.

If Atlanta decides to push a little harder and look for a younger arm, the price tag probably climbs to three years. Passan noted that group includes Clay Holmes, Foster Griffin, Tyler Mahle and Michael Soroka, writing, “Want to lock a guy up for the long term?

Joining May in the three-year club could be Clay Holmes, Foster Griffin, Tyler Mahle and Michael Soroka, who, at 29, has youth and a 4-to-1 strikeout-to-walk ratio on his side. While not all of them will get that sort of deal, the patient ones will happily join the post-lockout side in hopes that desperation for pitching will supersede the effect of any incoming economic system,”

That would be a different kind of swing for Anthopoulos, because the Braves haven’t really handed out three-year free-agent deals to starting pitchers. Still, three of those names come with obvious Atlanta connections.

Mahle was excellent for the Braves after being acquired at the trade deadline, then carried that form into the postseason. Soroka, of course, came up through Atlanta’s system and once looked like the future of the rotation before injuries changed everything. Holmes also has a link to the organization through current Braves pitching coach Jeremy Hefner, under whom he developed as a starter while they were together in New York.

None of these pitchers figures to cost a fortune. The market point of comparison is May’s three-year, $52.5 million deal with the White Sox, and that sounds like the upper end of what Atlanta would be willing to do for a starter this winter.

In Other News...

Braves Shortstop Fix Could Cost A Young Arm They Hate To Lose

The Braves have spent plenty of time looking for a cleaner answer at shortstop, and Jacob Wilson keeps showing up as the kind of player who could stabilize the position for the long haul. The Athletics infielder is still early in his career, but his contract status and steady all-around profile make him an appealing fit for a club that wants more certainty in the middle infield without giving up the kind of future flexibility that usually comes with a bigger-name target.

For Atlanta, the tricky part is the price. A deal built around Didier Fuentes would force the Braves to part with a young arm they value, even with enough pitching depth in the organization to make the conversation at least plausible. Wilsons upside also has to be weighed against other shortstops who might be available, which is why this kind of swap feels like the sort of front-office idea that makes sense on paper before it gets tested against what Atlanta is actually willing to lose. [Read more 🡒]

Braves Rotation Search May Be Pointing To A Familiar Anthopoulos Bet

After missing out on Sonny Gray, the Braves search for rotation help may be drifting toward the kind of move Alex Anthopoulos has long preferred. Ken Rosenthal suggested the club could be shopping in the cheaper end of the market, which fits a front office that has generally steered away from multi-year commitments for free-agent starters and instead looked for upside on shorter deals.

Frankie Montas has emerged as one of the more obvious names in that lane. He recently threw a bullpen session in Arizona and drew positive reviews from scouts for his fastball velocity and mechanics, a reminder of why teams still see upside there despite the stops and starts in his recent career. The appeal is obvious for Atlanta, but so is the risk, since Montas is still trying to reestablish himself after injury and surgery. [Read more 🡒]

Braves May Have Avoided A Costly Pitching Mistake

The Braves have spent enough time trying to thread the needle on pitching that every veteran starter gets a close look, especially one with a track record and a contract that can reshape a roster decision. In this case, the appeal is obvious on paper: experience, innings, and a reputation that still carries weight. But the recent numbers tell a more complicated story, with strikeouts slipping and walks climbing, the kind of trend that can turn a familiar name into a risky bet.

For a club that has been careful about where it commits money, the bigger issue may not be whether this pitcher can still help, but whether the price tag makes sense for where he is in his career. Atlanta has seen before how quickly a rotation move can become a long-term burden if the decline is already underway. So even if the fit looked tempting at first glance, the Braves may have steered clear of a costly mistake by not rushing into a deal built on past performance rather than present production. [Read more 🡒]