Braves Rotation Search May Be Pointing To A Familiar Anthopoulos Bet

The Braves are eyeing high-upside pitcher Frankie Montas as a cost-efficient addition to strengthen their rotation, aligning with GM Alex Anthopoulos's strategic approach to free agency.

If the Braves are going to shop the cheaper end of the free-agent market for rotation help, Frankie Montas makes a lot of sense as a name to keep circling.

Ken Rosenthal recently suggested Atlanta passed on Sonny Gray because the club may be aiming lower financially, and that tracks with how Alex Anthopoulos has handled starting pitching in free agency. He has never signed a free-agent starter to a multi-year deal, and that history points toward shorter, lower-risk bets instead of a big commitment. Gray’s two-year deal with the Twins carried a $27.5 million average annual value, which would have been the highest on the Braves’ roster.

Montas fits the kind of gamble that could come next. According to Will Sammon and Dennis Lin of The Athletic, nearly every team was represented at a bullpen session Montas threw earlier this week in Arizona, and his fastball was sitting at 95-98 MPH.

“Multiple scouts said Montas, whose fastball sat at 95 mph and was up to 98 in front of an audience featuring roughly 35 scouting personnel, appeared to be in great shape and displayed sharp mechanics. Evaluators said that based on Tuesday’s workout, they would recommend their clubs sign him to a major-league contract. The sources pointed to the lack of intriguing options in this year’s free-agent class as another reason to like Montas.”

The appeal is obvious, even with the risk baked in. Montas looked like a frontline arm early in his Athletics days, but his career hit a rough patch after the Yankees acquired him. He put up a 6.35 ERA in the second half of 2022, then missed essentially all of 2023.

He later signed a two-year deal with the Mets before the 2025 season, but that stint went sideways quickly. After only nine appearances, he was shut down and had Tommy John surgery, which kept him out for the entire season.

Now he’s back in the conversation as a possible rotation add for 2027 and beyond. He’s 33, still has obvious talent, and the report from Arizona suggests his arm is back to full strength. That combination should be enough to land him a major-league deal somewhere.

There’s also a built-in connection to the Braves. Montas and Jeremy Hefner crossed paths with the Mets, and that familiarity could matter given the respect Hefner earned in his first season as Atlanta’s pitching coach.

In Other News...

Braves Shortstop Fix Could Cost A Young Arm They Hate To Lose

The Braves have spent plenty of time looking for a cleaner answer at shortstop, and Jacob Wilson keeps showing up as the kind of player who could stabilize the position for the long haul. The Athletics infielder is still early in his career, but his contract status and steady all-around profile make him an appealing fit for a club that wants more certainty in the middle infield without giving up the kind of future flexibility that usually comes with a bigger-name target.

For Atlanta, the tricky part is the price. A deal built around Didier Fuentes would force the Braves to part with a young arm they value, even with enough pitching depth in the organization to make the conversation at least plausible. Wilsons upside also has to be weighed against other shortstops who might be available, which is why this kind of swap feels like the sort of front-office idea that makes sense on paper before it gets tested against what Atlanta is actually willing to lose. [Read more 🡒]

Braves May Have Avoided A Costly Pitching Mistake

The Braves have spent enough time trying to thread the needle on pitching that every veteran starter gets a close look, especially one with a track record and a contract that can reshape a roster decision. In this case, the appeal is obvious on paper: experience, innings, and a reputation that still carries weight. But the recent numbers tell a more complicated story, with strikeouts slipping and walks climbing, the kind of trend that can turn a familiar name into a risky bet.

For a club that has been careful about where it commits money, the bigger issue may not be whether this pitcher can still help, but whether the price tag makes sense for where he is in his career. Atlanta has seen before how quickly a rotation move can become a long-term burden if the decline is already underway. So even if the fit looked tempting at first glance, the Braves may have steered clear of a costly mistake by not rushing into a deal built on past performance rather than present production. [Read more 🡒]

Austin Riley Is Giving Braves Fans A Debate They Never Expected

Austin Rileys place in Atlanta used to feel straightforward. After back-to-back strong seasons, the Braves rewarded him with a significant extension in 2022, betting that his bat and presence at third base would remain central to the lineup for years to come. For a while, that looked like one of the easier long-term decisions the organization had made.

The conversation around Riley has shifted since then, with his production trending down over the past three seasons and both his OPS and home run totals slipping. That has turned what once looked like a cornerstone deal into a more complicated future call, with the Braves staring at a decision point around 2027 that could force them to weigh loyalty against roster value and contract obligations. [Read more 🡒]