With the offseason on pause thanks to the looming lockout, the Braves’ pending free agents are turning into pure rosterbation material. And the biggest question isn’t just who they like - it’s who makes sense once the market actually opens back up.
Raisel Iglesias feels like the clearest name in the bunch. Atlanta already showed last offseason it was willing to add him, and there’s not much reason to think that appetite has disappeared.
The Braves also handed Robert Suarez a multiyear deal, which looked at least partly like protection against an Iglesias downturn and eventual exit. Suarez wound up hurt and missed a chunk of time, while Iglesias mostly did his job: 61/76/82 ERA-/FIP-/xFIP-, right in line with his career composite of 68/76/80.
He’s getting older, sure, but he also mixed things up with pitch sequencing and location this year, so the fit still looks pretty clean.
Tyler Mahle is the other obvious case, and maybe the trickiest one. He’s already said he wants to keep rolling after his summer stint in Atlanta, though that kind of talk usually gets louder before free agency actually starts.
The Braves got him for $10 million after a half-season where he benefited from a low HR/FB, and now he’s coming off a fuller season that was solid overall and excellent once he joined Atlanta. The problem is price.
The sense here is that Mahle would be looking at something like $26 million for one year under the current market. Atlanta could go there, but if another team starts layering on years without really lowering the annual value, the Braves would probably step aside.
Mauricio Dubon is a tougher read. He fits the clubhouse, and the rest of the group would probably be happy to have him back.
But his market is murky, especially with the lockout hanging over spending plans, and he didn’t hit particularly well, posting a .304 xwOBA while beating it a fair bit. His style also doesn’t line up neatly with a lot of what the Braves already have.
It’s a little funny, though not necessarily meaningful, that he went on a huge run in June while the rest of the offense was falling apart. If Atlanta eventually adds true regulars at short and left field, Dubon could become a useful catch-all for several players with shaky outlooks, including Austin Riley and Ozzie Albies.
Still, it’s hard to picture the Braves landing two full-time bats and Dubon on top of that.
Ha-Seong Kim looks like more of a long shot. He was flat-out bad, and at this point he’s probably headed toward a small pillow deal if he stays in MLB at all.
The Braves don’t really need him after what he showed, though if the price drops far enough, the “why not?” argument starts to creep in.
Even so, it feels more likely that he gets a fresh start somewhere else.
There are also the lower-profile names that technically count if Atlanta brings them back: Joe Jimenez, Kyle Farmer, Lane Thomas, and Brent Suter. Jimenez and Farmer are basically non-factors in this discussion, while Thomas would be a modest add at most and Suter would be fun without moving the needle much. Those are the low-stakes names in the pile.
The real decision points, though, are Iglesias and Mahle. Those are the ones that actually tell you something about how the Braves want to spend once the lockout dust settles.
In Other News...
Braves Shortstop Debate Is Back And One Name Sits At Center
The Braves are already sorting through an offseason shaped by an NL Division Series exit at the hands of the Dodgers, and the list of decisions is longer than just a few roster tweaks. With Tyler Mahle and Mauricio Dubon among the players heading toward free agency, Atlanta may have some priorities on the retention side, but the most intriguing discussion may be the one surrounding shortstop and whether the club wants to keep leaning on Ha-Seong Kim.
Kims year did not give the Braves much reason to settle the debate quickly, and that leaves the position squarely in play as the front office maps out the next step. Atlanta has options to weigh and other areas to address, but shortstop now feels like one of the spots where a new direction is at least on the table, making this one of the more revealing choices of the winter. [Read more 🡒]
Braves Offseason Mistakes Left Atlanta Exposed When October Finally Hit
Atlantas postseason unraveling against the Dodgers did not happen in a vacuum. It traced back to the way the front office tried to patch together the roster last winter, from searching for a shortstop answer to trying to stabilize left field and build enough starting pitching depth to survive October.
Ha-Seong Kim was supposed to help solve one problem in the infield, while Jurickson Profar was part of the outfield plan, and the Braves also bet they had enough on the mound to carry them through the grind. Instead, the offense never found the kind of rhythm Atlanta needed in the NLDS, and the pitching staff did not have much room for error when the games tightened up against Los Angeles. [Read more 🡒]
Max Frieds Yankees Move Suddenly Looks Different To Braves Fans
Max Frieds first season in pinstripes gave the Yankees plenty to feel good about, at least in the long view. The former Braves left-hander settled in as a high-end starter in New York, finished fourth in AL Cy Young voting, and delivered the kind of steady regular-season work that made his move from Atlanta look like a clean fit for a contender. From the Braves side, it was easy enough to understand why his departure stung, but the bigger picture still looked familiar: a frontline pitcher landing with a club built to chase October.
The postseason, though, has a way of changing the mood around a season fast. Frieds numbers have looked less secure once the games have tightened, and the Yankees again found themselves out early in the ALDS, extending a recent pattern that Braves fans know well from their own October frustrations. For Atlanta followers still keeping one eye on their former ace, the question is no longer whether he can handle the spotlight over six months. It is how much the gap between that regular-season comfort and the October finish will shape the way this move gets remembered. [Read more 🡒]