Braves May Have To Pay A Painful Price To Fix Shortstop

Could Zach Neto be the solution to the Braves' enduring shortstop struggles despite the hefty price tag?

The Braves have been staring at the same problem for years, and shortstop remains the one hole that keeps showing up. Mauricio Dubon gave them a workable answer in 2025, but he’s a free agent now, and the fit is clearer as a super-utility option than as an everyday shortstop. With the free-agent market basically empty at the position, the real path to fixing it runs through a trade.

One name that stands out is Zach Neto.

Neto is not the kind of hitter some fans might prefer. He doesn’t profile as a table-setter, and he’s going to miss plenty of bats.

But Atlanta has never been shy about valuing power, and Neto brings plenty of it. He has hit at least 23 home runs and 29 doubles in each of the last three seasons, and he just finished a year in which he struck out 215 times.

Even so, the overall production has stayed steady: at least 5.0 WAR in each of the last three seasons, and he’s only 26 with three more seasons of team control.

That kind of player is never cheap.

The price tag here would be massive, and that’s before you even get to the fact that the Angels have no real reason to move him. With three years of control still on the books, they can afford to be patient and wait for a return they like. If the package doesn’t meet their standard, they can simply step away.

A deal built around Neto would almost certainly have to start with Hurston Waldrep, who has emerged as a top-30 prospect on most lists after a breakout 2026 season in the minors. He’s a true five-tool player with star upside if the bat keeps coming. Cam Caminiti would also be in the mix, and he’s the Braves’ top pitching prospect, ranked among the top 100 overall and viewed as a potential frontline arm down the road.

Even that may not be enough on its own.

AJ Smith-Shawver would add another layer to the return, bringing a big arm with real upside. Luke Sinnard would be another quality pitching prospect in the mix as well, coming off back-to-back encouraging seasons and a 2.94 ERA over 14 starts this year.

It’s a steep cost, no question. But landing a star shortstop with three years of control is going to hurt, and the Braves would have to give up real pieces to make it happen.

In Other News...

Braves Rotation Outlook Just Shifted With Two Huge Pitching Updates

The Braves got a pair of encouraging pitching updates that could reshape how they approach the winter and early spring. Alex Anthopoulos said Spencer Schwellenbach is aiming to start a throwing program around Thanksgiving and could be ready for the start of the season, a notably more optimistic timeline than earlier reports had suggested. For a rotation that has been forced to plan around uncertainty before, any sign of progress from a young arm like that matters.

Kyle Wright Strider is also expected to be ready for a normal spring after rehabbing from surgery, which gives Atlanta another reason to feel better about the depth picture. The health news is positive across the board, even if the bigger question still hangs over both pitchers: how quickly they can get back to being effective once they are back on the mound. [Read more 🡒]

Braves Just Got Pulled Into A New Tyler Mahle Price Debate

Dustin Mays new three-year, $52.5 million deal with the White Sox has already stirred up the kind of market debate that follows every mid-tier pitching contract, and it has a familiar ripple effect for clubs like the Braves that are always watching how starting pitching gets priced. Mays recent performance and injury history make him a tricky valuation case, but the agreement still gives teams another data point on what it costs to bet on upside when durability has been part of the conversation.

Tyler Mahle naturally gets pulled into that discussion because his own path has been so different, with a career that has not followed the same arc as Mays. For Atlanta, the comparison matters less as a direct fit and more as a reminder of how quickly the market can shift around pitchers who come with either health questions or uneven track records, and how one contract can reset the conversation for everyone else looking for rotation help. [Read more 🡒]

Braves Just Sent A Clear Message About Their Winter Pitching Plans

The Braves made their first clear winter roster moves before the protection deadlines arrived, adding pitchers Cdric De Grandpr and Davis Polo to the 40-man roster to keep them out of the Rule 5 Draft. In the same stretch, Atlanta also claimed reliever Cameron Foster off waivers from the Orioles, giving the bullpen mix another fresh arm to sort through as the offseason gets underway.

For a club that has spent the last few years trying to stay ahead of pitching depth issues, the timing matters as much as the names. These are the kinds of moves that can look minor in November but often tell you how a front office is thinking about its staff, especially with the non-tender and Rule 5 deadlines forcing decisions now rather than later. [Read more 🡒]