Sonny Gray has been tied to the Braves for years, and this winter was no different. Around the league, plenty of people saw Atlanta as a natural landing spot for the veteran right-hander.
On paper, it made sense. Gray is coming off a strong season with the Red Sox, posting a 2.72 ERA across 29 starts. He also fit one of Atlanta’s usual free-agent preferences: a pitcher who wouldn’t require a long-term deal because of age.
But the fit gets a lot less clean once you look past the surface.
Gray’s deal with the Twins is a big one, checking in at more than $27 million per year over the next two seasons as he heads into his age-37 season. That kind of commitment might have been manageable, but it also would have come with real risk for a Braves club that likely has only around $30-40 million more to spend this offseason and still has plenty of holes to fill.
The concern isn’t just the price tag. It’s whether Gray’s 2026 season was as sustainable as the raw numbers suggest.
He finished with a top-five AL Cy Young result, the second-best finish of his career, but the underlying indicators raised eyebrows. His Whiff % and K% dropped in 2026, and his strikeout rate fell to 7.9 per nine innings after he had averaged double digits in 2025.
His walk rate also climbed from 5% to 6.7%.
There was more bad news under the hood. Gray’s expected ERA in 2026 was more than a run higher than his actual ERA, and his expected FIP was actually better in 2025, when he finished with a 4.28 ERA.
That’s the heart of the argument here: the results looked good, but the process behind them didn’t look nearly as sturdy, especially for an older pitcher who doesn’t bring much velocity to the table.
That’s why the comparison to Atlanta’s past moves with Charlie Morton and Chris Sale only goes so far. Morton arrived after back-to-back All-Star appearances and a career-best strikeout rate.
Sale came with injury questions, but not with any real sign that his stuff had faded. Gray’s profile is different.
Even if the ages line up, the situations do not.
So while Gray would have been a name that made sense in a Braves uniform, missing out on him probably isn’t a loss Atlanta needs to dwell on. At $55 million over two years, it would have been a steep bet on a pitcher whose 2026 season may have been driven by more luck than certainty.
In Other News...
Braves Shortstop Fix Could Cost A Young Arm They Hate To Lose
The Braves have spent plenty of time looking for a cleaner answer at shortstop, and Jacob Wilson keeps showing up as the kind of player who could stabilize the position for the long haul. The Athletics infielder is still early in his career, but his contract status and steady all-around profile make him an appealing fit for a club that wants more certainty in the middle infield without giving up the kind of future flexibility that usually comes with a bigger-name target.
For Atlanta, the tricky part is the price. A deal built around Didier Fuentes would force the Braves to part with a young arm they value, even with enough pitching depth in the organization to make the conversation at least plausible. Wilsons upside also has to be weighed against other shortstops who might be available, which is why this kind of swap feels like the sort of front-office idea that makes sense on paper before it gets tested against what Atlanta is actually willing to lose. [Read more 🡒]
Braves Rotation Search May Be Pointing To A Familiar Anthopoulos Bet
After missing out on Sonny Gray, the Braves search for rotation help may be drifting toward the kind of move Alex Anthopoulos has long preferred. Ken Rosenthal suggested the club could be shopping in the cheaper end of the market, which fits a front office that has generally steered away from multi-year commitments for free-agent starters and instead looked for upside on shorter deals.
Frankie Montas has emerged as one of the more obvious names in that lane. He recently threw a bullpen session in Arizona and drew positive reviews from scouts for his fastball velocity and mechanics, a reminder of why teams still see upside there despite the stops and starts in his recent career. The appeal is obvious for Atlanta, but so is the risk, since Montas is still trying to reestablish himself after injury and surgery. [Read more 🡒]
Austin Riley Is Giving Braves Fans A Debate They Never Expected
Austin Rileys place in Atlanta used to feel straightforward. After back-to-back strong seasons, the Braves rewarded him with a significant extension in 2022, betting that his bat and presence at third base would remain central to the lineup for years to come. For a while, that looked like one of the easier long-term decisions the organization had made.
The conversation around Riley has shifted since then, with his production trending down over the past three seasons and both his OPS and home run totals slipping. That has turned what once looked like a cornerstone deal into a more complicated future call, with the Braves staring at a decision point around 2027 that could force them to weigh loyalty against roster value and contract obligations. [Read more 🡒]
