Braves Just Got Pulled Into A New Tyler Mahle Price Debate

Dustin May's new contract sets a benchmark for Tyler Mahle's market value, highlighting the balance between potential and reliability in team investment decisions.

Dustin May’s new deal with the Chicago White Sox is already giving the starting pitching market a fresh benchmark, and Tyler Mahle looks like the next name who could cash in.

May landed a three-year, $52.5 million contract, a price that says plenty about how teams are valuing upside right now. On the surface, it’s a hefty number for a pitcher whose recent track record has been uneven.

He posted a 4.70 ERA this past season, then finished with a 5.65 mark in 10 starts after being traded to the Brewers. In 2025, he worked to a 4.96 ERA.

Still, the appeal is obvious if you buy into the stuff. The analytics like May’s arsenal, and that kind of belief often carries more weight than the numbers already in the books.

Chicago is not paying for what May has done lately. It is betting that the best version of him is still out there.

That’s the same kind of calculation clubs now have to make with Mahle, even if the profile is a little different. When he was with the Giants, he “barely looked like he belonged on a major-league mound.”

Then the Braves got him, and the transformation was immediate. Over the final two months, he put up a 1.99 ERA, then backed it up with two strong postseason outings against the Phillies and Dodgers.

That stretch is the version of Mahle that could push him past the $50 million line. But there’s a catch: it was a short window, and teams will have to decide how much stock to put into it. Mahle has been around a long time, and most of his career has looked more like that of an innings eater than a frontline arm.

May and Mahle are not exact matches. May brings the bigger arm and the clearer upside swing. Mahle, on the other hand, doesn’t carry the injury history, and teams know exactly what kind of floor he offers as a back-of-the-rotation starter.

In Other News...

Braves Just Sent A Clear Message About Their Winter Pitching Plans

The Braves used a busy roster day to make their winter pitching priorities plain, adding Cdric De Grandpr and Davis Polo to the 40-man roster before the Rule 5 Draft protection deadline. Those kinds of moves are often about more than just filling space, because they show which arms the organization wants to keep out of reach and continue developing as the offseason gets underway.

Atlanta also claimed reliever Cameron Foster off waivers from the Baltimore Orioles, a reminder that the club is still looking for pitching depth wherever it can find it. With the non-tender and Rule 5 deadlines now in the rearview, the Braves have already started shaping the pitching inventory they want to carry into the winter, and there should be more roster maneuvering to come as they sort out the rest of the bullpen picture. [Read more 🡒]

Orioles Lose Another Pitching Depth Arm In Quiet Roster Shuffle

The Braves made a quiet but meaningful roster move, claiming right-hander Cameron Foster off waivers from the Orioles while also using two 40-man roster spots to protect Cedric De Grandpre and Davis Polo from the Rule 5 Draft. It is the kind of November housekeeping that rarely grabs headlines, but it can shape the back end of a pitching staff and the organizations depth chart for months to come.

Foster reached the majors with Baltimore in 2026, giving Atlanta another arm with big-league experience to evaluate as it sorts through its pitching inventory. De Grandpre and Polo, meanwhile, bring recent minor league innings and the usual mix of promise and uncertainty that comes with young arms, including varying degrees of success and injury history. For the Braves, the shuffle is less about the present than about keeping options intact while the roster fills up. [Read more 🡒]

Braves Still Have One Offseason Problem They Cannot Solve Internally

The Braves have spent enough time around this roster to know the shortstop question is not going away on its own. President of baseball operations Alex Anthopoulos said the club has discussed trading for help at the position, a sign Atlanta is still weighing outside options even with several shortstop prospects in the system. The issue has lingered long enough that it has become one of the clearer remaining offseason priorities.

What makes the search tricky is the timing. Atlantas internal options are not viewed as close to a full-time major league role, and free agency does not offer many obvious upgrades, which leaves the trade market as the likeliest path to a real solution. For a team trying to keep its roster in championship shape, it is a familiar kind of winter problem: the need is obvious, but the clean fix is not sitting there for the taking. [Read more 🡒]