The Braves have already made their most important Rule 5 decision, and it came before the draft itself. On Tuesday, Atlanta added pitchers Davis Polo and Cedric De Grandpre to the 40-man roster, shielding both from being taken in the 2026 Rule 5 Draft, which is scheduled for the MLB Winter Meetings on December 9 - unless the potential lockout wipes it out entirely.
Those two protections tell the story of where Atlanta sees real value in its system. Polo and De Grandpre are the names the Braves didn’t want exposed, while a handful of other recognizable prospects were left available and are unlikely to be selected anyway.
Polo was the biggest breakout in the system, and maybe the most surprising. He went from a player coming off injury with almost no information attached to him to one of the organization’s brightest pitching prospects.
His stuff took a major jump in 2026, he climbed all the way to Triple-A, and he impressed at every stop. Even after not pitching in 2025, he got through 129 innings this season and kept his stuff while sharpening his command.
The big remaining question is whether he can add strength to his frame and maybe find more velocity. For now, the Braves have what looks like a mid-rotation starter, and they’d have been foolish not to protect him.
His slider and command could even make him a bullpen option in 2027, with 2028 looking like a chance to compete for a rotation spot.
De Grandpre’s path has been quieter, but the Braves liked enough of what they saw to give him a 40-man spot as well. He went unselected in last year’s Rule 5 Draft, then flashed enough in 2026 to earn protection.
He missed 2024 after Tommy John surgery, but otherwise his minor league track record has been strong. The issue has been consistency: there have been stretches where the control is there, and others where he misses bats, but not as often where both show up together.
Still, he’s been a steady riser with an arsenal that already included a major league quality pitch, and his changeup took a real step forward last season. That helped him build out a five-pitch mix that can miss bats at any level, even if the command may not be good enough to keep him in a starting role.
Walks have been a problem over the last two seasons, and his stuff would likely tick up in the bullpen, but Atlanta is keeping him in the rotation for now.
As for the rest of the pool, the Braves are not expected to lose anyone in the Rule 5 Draft. In 2025, only 13 players were selected leaguewide, and nine of them have already been returned to their original teams.
Atlanta also doesn’t have the kind of depth that usually invites major Rule 5 risk, especially because the club tends to move successful minor leaguers quickly. It would be a surprise if any of these names actually came off the board.
Drue Hackenberg is one of the bigger names left unprotected, though that’s not much of a shock. He has shown flashes of being a big league starter, but after a strong 2024, his stuff backed up and injuries have been part of the picture in the last two seasons.
He has never found consistent command or enough bat-missing ability to become one of the organization’s better prospects, and that $2,000,000 signing bonus is looking as aggressive as it did on draft day. The athleticism is still there, but the performance hasn’t matched it.
Cade Kuehler’s situation is even bleaker. His stuff backed up almost immediately after he was drafted, and Tommy John surgery wiped out most of 2024 and all of 2025.
When he returned in 2026, he was far from the explosive pitcher he had been at Campbell and struggled even against High-A competition. The hope is that he can recover some of that stuff with more distance from surgery, but no team is likely to take him in the Rule 5 Draft.
He may be more likely to be released than selected.
Lisandro Espinoza is the most interesting unprotected name in the group. He has been Rule 5 eligible for a few years and was previously a Minor League Rule 5 pick of the Braves, yet he still stands out as the best prospect among Atlanta’s exposed players.
His approach finally came together in Double-A this season, where he posted an OPS over .900 and hit the ball harder than ever before. Injuries cost him a lot of time, and he struggled in Triple-A, but he remains a real player to watch.
The downside is that he doesn’t have convincing defense at shortstop and his power ceiling is limited, which makes him a tough fit as a big league regular. Even so, he’s more than the sum of his parts.
The problem is that teams usually won’t burn a 26-man roster spot on a player who can be replaced by veterans on minor league deals.
Isaac Gallegos also stayed exposed after becoming one of the more successful picks in Atlanta’s 2023 draft. A 16th-rounder, he needed a few years to settle in, but now he has an MLB-caliber slider that can miss bats. He throws strikes and profiles as a solid relief prospect, though the market for slider-heavy relievers is crowded enough that other teams can probably find similar arms without the Rule 5 constraints.
David McCabe is in his second year of eligibility, and the outlook hasn’t really changed. He finally found some Triple-A success, but it came with plenty of batted-ball luck.
The bat is consistent enough, but he doesn’t have the power for first base and doesn’t have the defense for anywhere else. That leaves him without enough value to force a roster decision.
Luis Vargas is another arm with real talent but a shaky recent track record. He broke out in 2024 and looked like a big league reliever, but injuries and command regression have slowed him over the last two seasons.
His fastball can reach the upper-90s, and his slider is a wipeout pitch. He also made major command gains at one point, only to backslide in each of the last two seasons.
He still misses plenty of bats and has the raw stuff to pitch in the majors, and there’s a small chance another team brings him to camp. Even so, the expectation is that he’ll still be with the Braves on opening day.
In Other News...
Braves Shortstop Search Took Another Turn Fans Will Want To See
The Braves are still working through a busy offseason, and shortstop remains one of the clearest spots they may try to upgrade while also keeping an eye on starting pitching. One name that had surfaced in the market was Maikel Garcia, with reports suggesting the Royals were open to moving the infielder in search of pitching help.
Garcia is no longer available after being traded to the Mariners, which changes the landscape for Atlanta as it weighs its options. The Braves still have pitching prospects who could draw interest in trade talks, so the search at shortstop is far from over, but it now heads into a different phase with one fewer potential fit on the board. [Read more 🡒]
Braves Rotation Pressure Just Got Worse After Another Target Came Off Board
The starting pitching market keeps moving, and another familiar name is gone before the Braves could get involved. Sonny Gray has agreed to a two-year, $55 million deal with the Twins after a strong season in Boston, a reminder that clubs looking for rotation help are watching proven arms disappear quickly as the offseason unfolds.
For Atlanta, the timing only adds to the pressure around a staff that could use more certainty. With a looming lockout hanging over the winter and the Braves history of being selective in free agency, every pitcher who comes off the board narrows the pool a little more, and Grays decision is another sign that the options are getting thinner by the day. [Read more 🡒]
Braves Offseason Priority Just Put One Key Position In Focus
The Braves offseason planning is already circling one of the most important spots on the diamond, and Alex Anthopoulos made it clear the club is not limiting itself to one path. Atlanta has free agents at shortstop, and the front office is weighing both the market and the trade landscape while trying to sort out a position that could shape the rest of the roster.
Anthopoulos also pointed to the organizations young shortstop prospects as a reason for optimism, while noting they may not be ready to take over right away. That leaves Atlanta in a familiar winter spot: balancing patience with urgency, and keeping an eye on trade possibilities involving names like Elly De La Cruz, CJ Abrams and Corey Seager as the Braves look for the right fit. [Read more 🡒]
