The Braves have done a lot right this season, but when it comes to ABS, they’ve been a mess.
Atlanta entered Wednesday with the lowest overturn rate in MLB at 40 percent, a number that lines up with what fans have seen all year: too many challenges lost, too many pitches left unchallenged, and too few clean wins in a system that can swing an inning in a hurry.
Among Braves hitters who had challenged at least five times, only Dominic Smith had even reached a 50 percent success rate. Smith had gone 5-for-10.
After him came Ronald Acuña Jr. at 45 percent, Ozzie Albies at 44 percent, Mauricio Dubón at 40 percent, Michael Harris II at 36 percent, Matt Olson at 32 percent and Austin Riley at 20 percent. The league-average success rate for hitters was 49 percent.
The problem hasn’t just been bad guesses. Atlanta has also left challenges on the table when the strike zone said it should have spoken up. MLB tracks those as “reasonable” challenges, defined as situations where at least one of three things is true: the original call was incorrect; the pitch is within 3 inches of the strike zone edge and an overturn would gain at least 0.3 runs; or the pitch carries an expected challenge rate of at least 20%.
By that measure, Braves hitters had challenged only 18 percent of reasonable opportunities, which ranked 25th in baseball. Their overall challenge quality wasn’t much better, either: just 64 percent of their hitter challenges met the reasonable standard, ranking 23rd in MLB. In other words, Atlanta has been taking a lot of shaky swings at the system.
The numbers back that up. Braves hitters had only 72 reasonable challenges all season, which ranked 28th in baseball. That bucket includes the pitches they should have challenged and the ones they probably shouldn’t have.
Some of the misses have been obvious in the moment. In an Aug. 19 game against the Twins, Riley passed on a challenge on strike three in a tie game with a runner at second and one out, even though the pitch was clearly off the plate and the Braves still had both challenges available. A few weeks earlier, Olson was on the other end of it against the Orioles on July 25, also in a tie game.
The postseason is where this stuff gets magnified. ABS is going to be part of the October equation for every team, and the margins are thin enough that one overturned pitch can ripple through an at-bat, an inning and maybe a series.
Atlanta’s catchers, at least, have handled the system much better on defense. Braves backstops entered Wednesday with a 62 percent overturn rate, eighth-best in MLB and well ahead of the hitters’ number. Sean Murphy added to that edge in the Braves’ 9-0 win over the Nationals, challenging a ball call against reliever Elieser Hernández that was overturned to Strike 2 on Abimelec Ortiz, who then popped out to end the sixth inning.
For the hitters, the challenge has been making the call fast enough in the moment.
“Looking back ... just got to trust your gut there,” Riley said after the Twins game. “I kind of went like I was going for it and ended up not ...
I think the big deal there is ... runner on second, ended up being a strikeout. I think that's a situation where I need to pull the trigger there.”
Weiss said the Braves keep talking through the right times to challenge based on count, game situation and circumstance, but he also made clear that the decision is rarely simple.
“This has been a running debate,” Weiss said after the Aug. 19 game in Minnesota. “It’s tougher than it looks.
It’s in the heat of the moment and it has to be a split-second decision. You’re trying to weigh the risk and the reward in the moment.
It’s just a lot to think about. After the fact, you’d like to have some of those calls overturned.
But I don’t think it’s quite as easy as it looks.”
Harris said the hardest part is reading just how close a pitch really is when everything is happening at full speed.
"The toughest part about it is, all [the ball] has to do is scrape the zone. And kind of knowing that in the box -- how far off or how much in the zone it is -- is kinda tough," Harris said.
"They're throwing 100 [mph] and you're trying to be on time for the pitch and make sure it's good enough or off the plate. It's one of those things that kind of gets better over time and just something you've gotta fix, I guess."
The Braves haven’t shied away from using ABS, but they have clearly not mastered it. And as Harris said, the stakes in October are obvious.
"It can change a playoff game real quick."
In Other News...
Which Braves Prospects Are Suddenly Closest To Atlanta
The Braves farm system has started to feel a little more immediate, with several of the organizations top young arms and bats moving into the part of their development where Atlanta can realistically start mapping out timelines. Owen Murphy, John Gil and Eric Hartman are among the prospects drawing the most attention right now, not just because of their talent, but because of the way their current minor league performances are nudging them closer to the big-league conversation.
For a club that always has one eye on the future, that matters because the next wave may arrive sooner than the usual wait-and-see approach suggests. The evaluation here is still built on minor league production and projection rather than any firm major league plans, but it does give Braves fans a clearer sense of which names could matter in the near term and which ones are shaping up as longer-view bets. [Read more 🡒]
Braves Division Lead Faces A New Test In Phillies Showdown
The Phillies have tightened the NL East race again, moving to 79-61 and trimming the gap behind Atlanta to four games as the two clubs head into a pivotal stretch. Philadelphia now gets a four-game set at home before the rivals meet again for three more in Atlanta, giving this week and the next one the feel of a division checkpoint rather than a routine September series.
One of the more interesting additions for Philadelphia has been Luis Arrez, who arrived Aug. 3 and has already changed the look of the lineup in the way Kyle Schwarber described. Schwarber pointed to Arrezs low-strikeout, high-contact style as a welcome layer of diversity, and that extra approach could matter in a matchup where every at-bat starts to carry a little more weight. [Read more 🡒]
Braves Rotation Shuffle Puts Bryce Elder In An Awkward Spot
The Braves are making another adjustment to their rotation as they prepare for their next meeting with the Phillies, with Grant Holmes set to take the ball instead of Bryce Elder. It is the latest sign that Atlanta is trying to thread the needle between getting more out of the matchup and keeping its pitching staff in a workable rhythm, especially after Holmes rain-shortened outing and Elders recent struggles.
Elder now finds himself in an awkward spot, waiting while the Braves sort through how best to handle him and manage his rest. The timing matters, too, because the series offers Atlanta a chance to tighten things up against a division rival, and every pitching decision carries a little more weight when the margin for error feels thin. [Read more 🡒]