The Braves are heading into the offseason with a long list of questions, but ESPN’s David Schoenfield sees one clear answer at the top of the board: shortstop.
Atlanta has been stuck patching that spot ever since Dansby Swanson left in free agency, and the options the Braves used this year never really solved the problem. Ha-Seong Kim, who was a $20 million disaster, hit .116 in 147 at-bats.
Mauricio Dubon ended up making the most starts there with 51, but he’s also a free agent, and Schoenfield points out that his best role is as a utility guy. Rookie Jim Jarvis got 35 starts and hit .207 with one home run, while prospect Tate Southisene remains a couple of years away.
“Shortstop,” Schoenfield writes. “Ha-Seong Kim is also a free agent and he was a $20 million disaster, hitting .116 in 147 at-bats.
Dubon ended up starting the most games there, 51, but he’s also a free agent, and his best role is as a utility guy. Rookie Jim Jarvis started 35 games, but he hit .207 with one home run.
Prospect Tate Southisene is a couple of years away.
“Aside from that, re-signing Mahle, who pitched so well after coming over at the trade deadline, is another big priority given the uncertainty of Spencer Strider and Spencer Schwellenbach returning from injuries. Didier Fuentes will be ready to replace Iglesias as closer, so given the subtraction of Kim, Fuentes and other free agents, there should be room to bring back Mahle.”
That leaves Atlanta in a familiar bind. The Braves have not been the type of team to dive headfirst into the kind of expensive shortstop pursuit that usually demands either a massive contract or a heavy prospect haul.
That makes a big external swing unlikely, which is why bringing Dubon back makes so much sense. He gives the Braves elite defense and enough production at the plate for the position, and he should come at a manageable cost on a two- or three-year deal in the $10-15 million AAV range.
Tyler Mahle is the other name that jumps out. The Braves need rotation answers, and they cannot simply assume Spencer Strider or Spencer Schwellenbach will be ready after injuries. Martin Perez is also a free agent, while Bryce Elder and Grant Holmes were steady for much of the season without looking like front-end difference-makers.
Mahle changed the picture after the trade deadline, putting up a 1.99 ERA in nine regular season starts. He then looked even sharper in October and gave Atlanta a real tandem with Chris Sale. The problem is that a finish like that may have driven his price beyond what the Braves are willing to pay, and losing him would leave the rotation with another major hole.
There is also a decision looming with Didier Fuentes. Schoenfield sees him as the future replacement for Raisel Iglesias at closer, and there is reason to believe he could handle that role. Still, the Braves may need him more as a starter, and moving him out of the rotation this early would be a mistake after how dominant he was out of the bullpen this year.
In Other News...
Braves Fans Still Have Every Right To Debate Chris Sale Decision
The argument over Chris Sales October usage has lingered because it touched two of the biggest issues any manager faces in the postseason: winning the game in front of him and preserving a frontline starter for what might come next. Walt Weiss had Sale available in a high-leverage spot against the Phillies, and some Braves fans have never forgiven the choice, while others point out the left-hander was prepared for the situation and the moment demanded it.
What keeps the debate alive is the contrast between the games themselves. Atlanta managed to win Game 2 without Sale, then dropped Game 3 with him in the mix, which only sharpened the hindsight scrutiny. Add in the broader playoff conversation around pitcher usage, with Yoshinobu Yamamoto part of the comparison, and it is easy to see why this one still has Braves fans split on whether the call was aggressive, necessary, or simply too costly. [Read more 🡒]
Braves Prospect Tate Southisene Is Finally Back But One Problem Remains
The Glendale Desert Dogs are still searching for traction in the Arizona Fall League, where a 5-4 loss to the Surprise Saguaros dropped them to 1-6. For Atlanta followers, the notable development was Tate Southisene finally getting back on the field after missing time with a hand and wrist injury, even if his night was a quiet one at the plate as he finished 0-for-2 with a walk.
Isaiah Drake offered one of the brighter spots with an RBI single in a 1-for-4 effort, and the bullpen pieced together innings from Owen Hackman, Logan Samuels and Tanner Bauman. The back end of the game still slipped away, though, and for a club already short on momentum, the larger concern now is how quickly Southisene can shake off the rust and settle back in. [Read more 🡒]
Braves Deadline Standoff Reveals How Highly They Value One Young Arm
The Braves deadline plans offered a clear look at how much they already value Didier Fuentes, even as they explored a run at Tarik Skubal. Atlanta weighed the idea of making a move for the frontline left-hander, but the organization was unwilling to part with one of its young right-handers in the process, a sign Fuentes has become more than just another arm in the system.
Fuentes has worked his way into the clubs future picture with a 2.04 ERA over his last 56 relief appearances, and that kind of performance has clearly raised the internal price tag. In the end, the Braves pivoted to Tyler Mahle instead, adding a pitcher who outperformed Skubal down the stretch without costing them any prospects, which only makes the original standoff look even more telling. [Read more 🡒]