The Yankees enter October with the kind of pitching depth that can make the rest of the bracket feel uneasy. They finished the season with the best team ERA in baseball at 3.24, and the gap to second place - 3.51 - was not small. That edge starts with a rotation that looks stacked from top to bottom: likely AL Cy Young winner Cam Schlittler, plus Max Fried, Gerrit Cole and Carlos Rodón, all of whom can give a lineup a miserable night.
And this time, the bullpen looks far more trustworthy than it has in some recent playoff runs. David Bednar has been a dependable closer, while Paul Blackburn and Brent Headrick have handled setup work beautifully.
It adds up to a staff that does not have a glaring weak spot. For a postseason field built on thin margins, that matters.
Milwaukee is right there behind them, and the Brewers have earned that spot with run prevention across the board. Their 2. second-ranked team ERA in baseball tells the story, but the names tell it even better.
Jacob Misiorowski has been the best pitcher in baseball this season and has the look of a playoff ace, while Logan Henderson gives them another strong arm near the top of the rotation. Trevor Megill and Abner Uribe anchor a bullpen that is both deep and excellent.
The one question hanging over Milwaukee is the back half of the rotation. Kyle Harrison fell apart, and that leaves a real hole.
Robert Gasser could help, and the Brewers may need to lean on a bullpen game or bulk innings from someone like Dustin May or Chad Patrick. They still look loaded, but that issue is not small.
The Dodgers, meanwhile, are trying to repeat a familiar postseason formula: get healthy, then let the talent take over. Tyler Glasnow and Blake Snell are back in the mix, joining Yoshinobu Yamamoto and the newly acquired Tarik Skubal.
That gives Los Angeles a rotation with the kind of upside that can carry a team deep into October. The bullpen may be messy, but there is real firepower there too, with Tanner Scott, Evan Phillips and Edwin Díaz at the back.
Boston has a staff that quietly belongs near the top of this conversation as well. Only the Yankees and Brewers finished with a better team ERA, and the Red Sox have the pieces to match up well in a short series.
Sonny Gray is an ace, and Payton Tolle, Ranger Suárez and either Brayan Bello or Jake Bennett can round out the rotation. Aroldis Chapman has turned in a remarkable second act as an elite closer, and Garrett Whitlock and Tyron Guerrero give Boston quality setup options.
Tampa Bay has also found a formula that looks dangerous if it holds. Freddy Peralta’s season was uneven overall - a 5.33 ERA through 26 starts - but he has caught fire lately, posting a 0.79 ERA over his last six.
If that version sticks, he can join Drew Rasmussen and Nick Martinez to form a strong top three while the Rays wait and hope for Shane McClanahan to return in time for the ALCS. Bryan Baker has emerged as one of the best closers in baseball, and the relief group around him has plenty of interesting pieces.
San Diego’s staff is built around elite bullpen work. The Casey Mize trade has not worked out and he is now on the injured list, but Nick Pivetta is back, which gives the Padres two possible frontline starters alongside Michael King.
Robbie Ray can fill the third spot, and Walker Buehler gives them a workable fourth starter. The real strength is late in games, where Adrián Morejon has become the best fireman in baseball and Mason Miller stands as the best closer.
Atlanta has a lot to like, but also a fair bit that could unravel quickly. Chris Sale gives them certainty at the top, and Tyler Mahle has been one of the bigger wild cards in the field.
After a 5.13 ERA in 18 starts with the Giants, he turned into something close to an ace for the Braves with a 1.28 ERA in his first eight starts. Then he gave up five runs on six hits in five innings last time out.
Martín Pérez is a solid No. 3, while Raisel Iglesias, Robert Suarez, Didier Fuentes and Dylan Lee round out a bullpen that could be excellent - or shaky - depending on who shows up.
Philadelphia has the most obvious upside in the rotation if everything clicks, but the warning signs are hard to ignore. Christopher Sánchez, Jesús Luzardo, Zack Wheeler and Aaron Nola give the Phillies a scary top four on paper.
The problem is that Luzardo is hurt, Sánchez had a 5.12 ERA in September, Wheeler has a 4.43 ERA since the All-Star break and Nola was hit hard in his last two starts, including a short-rest disaster on Saturday. The bullpen has power at the back with Jhoan Duran and José Alvarado, but the path to those arms could get rough.
Cleveland’s pitching profile is more about promise than certainty. The Guardians were eighth in team ERA, but this is not the dominant staff they’ve had in some recent seasons.
Parker Messick has the look of a possible playoff ace, and Gavin Williams can miss bats in bunches, though both come with concerns: Messick has no playoff experience, and Williams can be wildly inconsistent. Tanner Bibee slots in as the third starter, while Foster Griffin has struggled badly since arriving at the deadline.
Cade Smith is a legitimate weapon in the ninth, but the bridge to him is not as sturdy as Cleveland would like.
The Cubs are a different kind of gamble. For stretches, they have looked like a team searching for the right pitching formula rather than living it.
The bullpen has been plagued by late-inning blowups, and the overall staff has been subpar for most of the year. One possible answer would be a rotation mix that includes David Peterson, Clay Holmes, Matthew Boyd and Kevin Gausman, with starters-by-trade helping shore up the relief group ahead of Daniel Palencia, Ryan Zeferjahn and Ryan Rolison.
It is not hard to see the idea. It is harder to feel great about it.
The White Sox have a bullpen worth respecting, even if the rotation is a real problem. Grant Taylor and Hagen Smith have become reliable late-inning arms, with Bryan Hudson, Jordan Hicks and Sean Newcomb filling out a strong relief corps.
But the starting group is a different story. Sean Burke could surprise, Anthony Kay might still have a gem or two left, and Davis Martin has shown flashes.
Then there is Erick Fedde. Even with a generous reading, this is a shaky playoff rotation.
Houston sits at the bottom of this list because the overall picture is thin. Hunter Brown is a frontline starter, and Peter Lambert has settled in as a respectable option, while Josh Hader has returned to elite closer form.
The bullpen is actually pretty solid. The problem is everything around it.
The Astros ranked 24th in ERA this season at 4.45, and once you get past Brown, the playoff rotation becomes Lambert and Hayden Wesneski. That is a tough place to start in October.
In Other News...
Braves Fans Have Seen This MLB Playoff Slight Before
MLB has already put the Braves on the board for the 2026 Wild Card Series, and the timing is the kind of thing Atlanta fans noticed right away. The league announced start times for the opening round, and the Braves are set for a 2 p.m. EST first pitch, leaving them outside the later window while matchups involving teams like the Padres, Red Sox, Yankees, Rangers and Astros were given more prominent spots.
For a division winner, the early assignment is a familiar frustration and one that tends to spark plenty of debate around how MLB treats its playoff showcase. The Braves will still get their shot on the October stage, but the scheduling choice ensures the conversation around them begins well before game time and lingers long after the bracket is set. [Read more 🡒]
Braves Get Their Rival With One Big Edge In Game 1
The Braves will open their National League Wild Card Series at Truist Park on Tuesday, and they arrive with the kind of early advantage every short postseason series covets. Chris Sale is lined up to start Game 1 for Atlanta, giving the home club a defined plan on the mound as it welcomes the Phillies into a tense division-rival matchup.
Philadelphia locked up its postseason berth after beating the Rays and getting some help from the Padres against the Diamondbacks, but its biggest immediate question remains the one that matters most in a playoff opener. The Braves already know who they are sending out first, while the Phillies are still sorting through their choice, adding a layer of uncertainty to a series that figures to be decided by small edges from the start. [Read more 🡒]
Braves Postseason Hopes Suddenly Rest On A Risky Rotation X-Factor
Martin Perez landing on the injured list has forced Atlanta to lean harder on a rotation that already needed every useful arm it could get. In that mix, Grant Holmes has moved into an especially important spot, bringing value because he can work either as a starter or out of the bullpen. His season has been steady enough to keep him in the conversation, and the Braves have watched him sharpen as the months have gone on.
Holmes slider has given Atlanta a legitimate weapon, but there is still some concern about how often opponents are making hard contact against him. Even so, the Braves may not have many better options if they want to keep the staff afloat heading into October. How well Holmes holds up could end up shaping more than just his own role, because Atlantas postseason hopes now have a lot riding on whether that risk pays off. [Read more 🡒]