The Braves enter the winter with plenty to sort through, but the biggest question may be the one that usually gets less attention than the offense: who takes the ball every fifth day in 2027?
Atlanta’s 2026 rotation was held together in less-than-ideal fashion after spring training injuries scrambled Alex Anthopoulos’ original plans. Even so, the group finished sixth in ERA, a sign that the pitching staff found enough answers to survive.
Still, it would be hard to look at that setup and call it a blueprint. Ray Kerr became an Atlanta legend overnight, but heading into October with only two viable starters is not a formula the Braves should want to repeat.
At the top of the projected 2027 group is still Chris Sale. The veteran left-hander remains the staff anchor, and he’s positioned for another top-three finish in NL Cy Young voting this year.
Atlanta already extended him before this season to keep him beyond 2026, and he’ll be due $27 million next season. The age curve is the obvious concern: Sale will turn 38 just after Opening Day, which puts him squarely in the territory where decline can hit at any moment.
And yet, he just posted the highest average fastball velocity of his career, a reminder that he’s still finding ways to beat time.
Tyler Mahle also looks like a strong fit, if Atlanta can keep him. The deadline pickup was a massive win for Anthopoulos, and maybe the best move made anywhere in baseball.
Mahle was outstanding down the stretch, working with pitching coach Jeremy Hefner and changing his pitch mix on the way to a 1.99 ERA, 3.32 FIP, and 1.8 bWAR in nine starts. He was just as sharp in the postseason, turning in two excellent outings during Atlanta’s run.
After the season, Mahle made it clear he wants to stay, and the Braves would be wise to match that desire rather than let his market get away from them.
Sonny Gray keeps surfacing in Braves circles, and the fit makes sense. He’s been linked to Atlanta for what feels like forever, and this winter might finally be the time the stars line up.
The soon-to-be 37-year-old put together another strong year with the Red Sox in 2026, finishing with a 2.72 ERA, 3.47 FIP, and 4.3 bWAR. Since 2019, Gray has had a FIP in the 3.00s every year except 2023, when it was 2.83, and over the last four seasons he’s averaged more than 30 starts a year.
That kind of durability and quality would make a short deal make plenty of sense.
Didier Fuentes is the wild card with real upside. One of MLB’s youngest players in 2026, the hard-throwing righty broke through with a promising rookie season after coming up as a starter in the minors and reaching Atlanta through the bullpen.
His ceiling is too high to box him into relief work for good. He probably shouldn’t be expected to pile up close to 190 innings next year, but he’s shown enough to get another shot in the rotation, especially now that his secondary pitches have taken a step forward.
The final spot is where things get messy. AJ Smith-Shawver seems like the safest internal bet for now, though that comes with plenty of risk.
His 2026 results were not the kind that inspire much confidence, but he is only 16 months removed from major elbow surgery, and the Braves have to keep in mind that he was trending in the right direction back in 2024. With Spencer Schwellenbach and Spencer Strider both carrying uncertain timetables, one of Atlanta’s younger arms may have to begin the year in the rotation.
Smith-Shawver, JR Ritchie, Owen Murphy, and Hurston Waldrep are all set to get a long look in spring training. Atlanta could also add another Martin Perez-type starter to keep the competition open. For now, Smith-Shawver looks like the leading candidate to come out of that group, but that picture could change several times before winter is over.
In Other News...
Braves Face One Offseason Problem That Could Shape Everything
Alex Anthopoulos spent the early part of the Braves offseason laying out the familiar mix of roster questions and organizational priorities, with the rotation at the center of it all. He talked through the statuses of Spencer Schwellenbach, Spencer Strider and Didier Fuentes, while also touching on Tyler Mahle, Jurickson Profar, Austin Riley, Mauricio Dubn and the continuity of the coaching staff. The tone was measured, which is usually how Atlanta handles this time of year, but it also made clear there is still a lot to sort through before the roster takes its final shape.
What stood out was Anthopouloss insistence that several of those decisions will require more internal discussion, rather than easy assumptions about how the staff will look when camp opens. He also made it clear he is comfortable with the current coaching group, which matters for a club that values stability as much as Atlanta does. The Braves have enough proven pieces to feel good about the framework, but the way they answer these offseason questions could end up influencing far more than just the back end of the rotation. [Read more 🡒]
Braves Could Feel Squeezed In A Salary Cap Fight More Than Fans Think
The looming labor fight in baseball is about more than whether the sport ends up with a salary cap. For Atlanta, it is also about how much room a club with a typically hefty payroll would actually have to maneuver if a new system comes in. The Braves have built around spending, but they have also tied themselves to a roster core through long-term commitments, which makes the conversation less abstract than it might seem from the outside.
If the next collective bargaining agreement brings a hard cap and a floor, Atlanta could find itself squeezed in a way fans do not usually associate with a team that has been willing to pay up. The issue is not just whether the Braves can keep spending, but whether their current approach leaves them enough flexibility to adjust if the rules of the market change underneath them. [Read more 🡒]
Braves 2027 Rotation Picture Still Looks Far From Settled
Alex Anthopoulos remarks about the Braves 2027 planning offered a reminder that even the broad outlines of the roster are still being sorted out. The president of baseball operations said Didier Fuentes should get a chance in the starting rotation, though the club would have to manage how much he throws, and he also pointed to the ongoing uncertainty around several other pieces as Atlanta looks ahead.
Spencer Strider and Spencer Schwellenbach remain part of the conversation, but injuries leave their roles unsettled and make it hard to project the rotation with any real confidence this far out. Beyond the mound, the Braves still have decisions pending on coaching changes and Jurickson Profars future, while talks continue with free agents Tyler Mahle and Mauricio Dubn, who could factor in at shortstop if he returns. [Read more 🡒]