The Phillies and Braves have turned this National League Wild Card Series into exactly what October is supposed to be: tense, loud and just a little bit chaotic.
After Atlanta’s wild Game 1 win and Philadelphia’s 4-3 comeback in Game 2 on Wednesday, everything now shifts to a winner-take-all Game 3 on Thursday at Truist Park. And both teams are arriving there with the same uneasy truth hanging over them: the bullpen is going to matter, but maybe not in the way either club expected.
For the Phillies, that problem showed up immediately in Game 1 when they tried to squeeze a three-inning save out of Jhoan Duran. It backfired, and the 27-pitch outing also kept him out of Game 2.
So Philadelphia leaned almost entirely on its starters Wednesday, with Cristopher Sánchez and Andrew Painter covering 29 of the team’s 30 outs. Rookie reliever Alex McFarlane, the only reliever used before Duran in Game 1, handled the cleanup work on one seventh-inning jam.
Duran’s availability for Game 3 is still up in the air. “We’ll see where he's at tomorrow,” interim manager Don Mattingly said.
If the Phillies need another heavy lift from the rotation, they have veteran right-handers Aaron Nola and Zack Wheeler available on short rest after pitching Sunday’s season finale. Mattingly wouldn’t say who would start, but both are expected to be in the mix.
Jesús Luzardo said he’s available too, and Painter didn’t sound like someone worried about another call.
“Yeah, everything on the line,” Painter said. “Luzardo would make fun of me if I didn't.
I'm 23. He says I should be good every day.”
Atlanta’s bullpen, meanwhile, has not looked like the group that was one of the best in baseball over the regular season. The Braves finished with a 3.44 ERA from the pen, fourth best in MLB, and led the National League with a 1.19 WHIP. None of that has translated cleanly so far in this series.
Didier Fuentes, who posted a 2.05 ERA in 70 1/3 innings as a reliever this season, gave up the go-ahead triple to J.T. Realmuto in Game 1 and then the game-winning homer to Alec Bohm in Game 2.
Dylan Lee has also been at the center of the action. Atlanta’s top left-handed reliever was supposed to be the answer for the Phillies’ lefty power bats, and in Game 1 he was, retiring Schwarber, Harper and Bohm in order.
On Wednesday, though, Schwarber and Harper went back-to-back on him.
“Lee is our high-leverage lefty,” Braves manager Walt Weiss said after Game 2. “Put down the same part of the order [in Game 1] pretty easily. … That's his inning every time.”
If Thursday brings another high-leverage moment for Lee, the Braves will need him to flip the script fast.
Game 2 was also a night built around recovery. Harper’s rough misplay in the bottom of the seventh could have easily become the lasting image of Philadelphia’s season.
Instead, he answered with a game-tying homer in the next inning. Bohm had already helped create the trouble by trying to get the lead runner on a sacrifice bunt and missing the throw with a runner on first and nobody out.
Later, he erased that mistake with his own homer.
Painter’s turnaround was just as striking. He was sent to Triple-A on June 17 with a 7.06 ERA, then came back six weeks later and pitched well enough to make the postseason roster. On Wednesday, he delivered three scoreless innings out of the bullpen and became the youngest pitcher in Phillies history to win a postseason game.
Now the series comes down to one final question: who gets the defining swing?
Schwarber and Harper delivered the big blows in Game 2, but the biggest hits in the series so far have come from unexpected places. Austin Riley, who struggled all season, hit the winning homer in Game 1. Bohm, whose Philadelphia run has been uneven, came through in Game 2.
So Game 3 offers one more chance for a new name to take over the story, whether that ends with Schwarber or Harper pushing the Phillies into an NLDS rematch with the Dodgers, or with Ronald Acuña Jr. or Matt Olson sending Atlanta back to the NLDS for the first time since 2023.
In Other News...
Braves Enter Do Or Die Game 3 With One Huge Pitching Problem
The Braves head into a must-win Game 3 against a division rival with the kind of pitching uncertainty teams try to avoid in October. Philadelphia is expected to counter with Zack Wheeler, which only sharpens the pressure on Atlanta to piece together a workable plan on the mound. Grant Holmes and Ray Kerr are expected to be central to that approach, but the larger issue is simpler and more unsettling: there is no obvious traditional starter waiting to take the ball.
Tyler Mahle gave Atlanta a strong outing in Game 2 and has been one of the brighter signs recently, but even that was not enough to change the result. The Braves lost anyway, undone by a quiet night for the lineups power and a bullpen that could not hold the edge. Now the series has reached the point where every pitching decision matters, and Atlanta still has to answer the biggest question of all before the first pitch is thrown. [Read more 🡒]
Braves Just Got A Real Opening In Winner-Take-All Game 3
The Phillies have handed Aaron Nola the ball for their winner-take-all Game 3 against the Braves, a choice that immediately changes the feel of this Wild Card finale. Atlanta now gets a different look than many expected, with Philadelphia going with the veteran right-hander instead of Zack Wheeler, whose strong season made him the more obvious option on paper.
For the Braves, the opening is in the matchup itself as much as the name on the lineup card. Nola has been uneven this season, but his history of success against Atlanta in past postseason moments gives the Phillies a reason to trust him, even if the move has sparked some second-guessing about leaving Wheeler out of the biggest start of the year. [Read more 🡒]
Braves Waste A Start That Should Have Changed This Series
Tyler Mahles first postseason start gave the Braves exactly the kind of pitching backbone they needed in a tense Wild Card Game 2 against the Phillies. After a shaky beginning, he settled in and worked effectively through seven innings, keeping Philadelphia in check and striking out several key batters along the way. For a team trying to swing the series back in its favor, it was the sort of outing that should have set up a much different night.
Instead, Atlanta kept leaving chances on the table. The Braves had multiple opportunities to break through, including a bases-loaded situation in the sixth inning, but could not fully cash in when the game was there to be taken. With the pitching doing its part and the offense unable to finish the job, it became one of those postseason losses that felt bigger than the final score. [Read more 🡒]