Joel Payamps’ stint with the Braves never had much runway, and it barely got off the ground before the organization moved on. Atlanta gave the right-hander a guaranteed one-year, $2.25 million deal after claiming him on waivers in the winter, then watched him last only into May before designating him for assignment.
That outcome fit the uneasy feel of the move from the start. Payamps had been around the block long before arriving in Atlanta, with stops in Colorado, Arizona, Boston, Toronto, Kansas City, Oakland and Milwaukee.
He was also part of the trade that sent Sean Murphy to the Braves and William Contreras to the Brewers, going from Oakland to Milwaukee in that deal. The Brewers kept him for a few seasons and got a breakout year out of him in 2023, but they cut ties late in 2025.
The numbers that followed him into 2026 were never especially loud. Entering the season, Payamps had 2.2 fWAR across 269 career innings with an 81/95/100 line in ERA-/FIP-/xFIP-.
That profile pointed to a useful but limited reliever, the kind of arm teams will use but rarely prioritize. More than half of that career value came from his 2023 spike with Milwaukee, when he threw 70 2/3 innings, posted 1.5 fWAR and turned in a 59/79/83 line.
His 2024 season was worse, and 2025 dragged things down further.
Atlanta still committed to him anyway, even after two late-2025 appearances in a Braves uniform didn’t provide much reason for confidence. Projection systems saw him as either replacement level or a little better than that, but the Braves handed him the sort of deal that suggested they expected him to serve as a middle reliever.
Instead, he was gone after 12 games. Payamps debuted in the second game of the season and was DFA’d on May 1 after throwing 7 2/3 innings.
In that stretch, he was worth -0.1 fWAR, posted -0.58 WPA and allowed a brutal 196/138/116 line. He also finished with one shutdown and four meltdowns, and the Braves went 2-3 in the five games where he was used in something other than low leverage.
There were a few things to point to, but not much to build around. His sweeper command was passable, and his four-seamer produced a .191 wOBA-against and .247 xwOBA-against with a strong whiff rate. He also recorded his lone shutdown on April 24, working the eighth inning with a two-run lead over the Phillies and getting three flyouts to right, with an Alec Bohm single mixed in.
The problem was the rest of it. His sweeper had strong spin deflection and lived near the bottom edge of the zone, but the pitch lacked shape, which may have limited its swing-and-miss ability.
Even with some success on the four-seamer, the overall package unraveled quickly. A walk rate of 11 percent made the margin for error tiny, and the combination of a pitch that didn’t move enough and another that he couldn’t command cleanly was enough to send him out the door.
His roughest outing by WPA came in his final appearance. He entered the eighth inning with a one-run lead, then watched Kerry Carpenter hit a barreled triple and Matt Vierling follow with a weak roller double.
Payamps walked a batter, struck out one, and that was the end of his night; Aaron Bummer and Jose Suarez made the damage worse, and the Braves fell 5-2. He was gone the next day.
Looking ahead, the path is murky. Payamps did not land a minor league deal to try to rebuild in Triple-A, so it is unclear whether he’ll get another shot before next season’s equivalent of Spring Training.
He got $2.25 million from the Braves after 2025, which suggests someone could still see a short-term role for him. What looks far less likely is another guaranteed major league deal.
In Other News...
Braves Left Field Problem Just Made This Lineup Decision Bigger
Atlantas left-field picture has already changed once with the arrival of Lane Thomas from the Royals, and the move now looks even more important as the Braves sort through the fallout from Jurickson Profars situation. Thomas is expected to handle left field in a platoon role with Mike Yastrzemski, giving the club at least one more established option while it tries to steady a spot that suddenly feels more unsettled than it did a few days ago.
The Braves still have reason to keep scanning the market if they want more than a patchwork answer, and that is where the conversation has turned toward Japanese player Teruaki Sato. He would be a major swing for a lineup that could use impact and certainty on the outfield corners, and the fit is only getting easier to imagine as the club weighs how aggressively to address the opening in left. [Read more 🡒]
Braves Offseason Plans Hinge On One Unsettled Pitching Question
The Braves are heading into the 2027 planning cycle with the same kind of uncertainty that can quietly shape an entire offseason: who will actually be available on the mound when the season begins. Joe Jimenez and Martin Perez are both free agents coming off significant injuries, while a group that includes Spencer Strider, Spencer Schwellenbach, Joey Wentz and Bryce Elder carries its own mix of health questions as Atlanta tries to sort out what kind of rotation and bullpen depth it can realistically count on.
Hurston Waldrep adds another layer to the puzzle after undergoing Tommy John surgery in mid-September, making his timeline a long one for a club that needs clarity sooner rather than later. Even with so many names in flux, there is still one particularly important pitching situation hanging over the Braves as they map out their next steps, and the answer there could have a ripple effect on how aggressively they need to shop for arms this winter. [Read more 🡒]
Red Sox May Be Letting A Key Rotation Piece Walk
Sonny Grays stint with the Red Sox appears headed toward a short shelf life, with Boston unlikely to pick up the mutual option on his contract. For Atlanta, that immediately makes him one of the more interesting names to watch on the pitching market, especially with the Braves looking for rotation help and any fit that trims down the travel from his Tennessee home carrying obvious appeal.
Boston does have other pitchers it expects to be part of its 2027 rotation, so Gray is not the only arm shaping the clubs long view. Even so, his path beyond this season remains unsettled, and the Braves could be positioned to benefit if the veteran right-hander reaches free agency and starts weighing where he wants the next chapter of his career to land. [Read more 🡒]