The Big 12 has acknowledged another replay mistake in a BYU game, and this one came in a matchup that ended with the Cougars on top.
No. 8 BYU beat Arizona State 27-20 on Saturday to move to 7-1, a result that helped the Cougars rebound from their loss to UCF and remain in the College Football Playoff conversation. But the win was shadowed by a first-quarter call that the conference later said should not have stood.
On BYU’s opening drive, the Cougars faced second-and-goal from the 1-yard line. Quarterback Bear Bachmeier tried to power in for the score, but the ball came loose. Sione Moa scooped it up and crossed the goal line for a touchdown, though officials initially stopped the play and ruled Bachmeier down at the 1.
After the first review, the call changed to a fumble by Bachmeier with BYU recovering at the 1-yard line. Then, after a second review, the Big 12’s replay operations center ruled the play should be overturned to a touchdown.
Arizona State coach Kenny Dillingham was visibly upset with the ruling, but the score stood. After the game, the Big 12 said that decision was wrong. The conference said Moa’s recovery at the 2-yard line should have ended the play.
Under conference rule 12-3-3-d-2, when replay determines the ball was not dead, the recovering team gets the ball at the spot of recovery and cannot advance it. In this case, that would have meant BYU should have had third-and-goal from the 2, not a touchdown.
Dillingham said after the game that the call changed the outcome.
"I was trying to argue that he does have the right to recover it post-whistle, but that's not a clear advancement, which means the ball should be at the 3," Dillingham said, per ESPN. "Obviously, that wasn't what happened.
It's not the officials' fault. Those officials don't have say in that.
That's all back home."
It was the second time in three weeks the Big 12 has had to admit a replay error in a BYU game. On Oct. 17 against Notre Dame, the conference said one more second should have been put on the clock for the Fighting Irish, which would have given them another shot to win. BYU still came away with the upset.
Now the Cougars turn to another major test, with No. 6 Utah waiting on the road next week.
In Other News...
Tommy Lloyd Already Has One Arizona Lineup Decision Hanging Over UCLA
Arizona is heading toward its season opener against UCLA in Las Vegas with more than just a marquee matchup on the schedule. Tommy Lloyd spent the lead-up talking through lineup choices and development opportunities as the Wildcats try to build on last seasons run to the Final Four and a strong early stretch, while also adjusting to the reality that one piece of the rotation is unavailable.
RJ Godfreys absence has already complicated the picture for Lloyd, who is weighing whether to keep the current group intact or make a change before the opener. The preseason exhibitions offered one look at the rotation, but Arizona still has a few internal options to consider, including Cameron Holmes, Ugnius Jarusevicius and Maksim Brnovic, before the Wildcats settle on how they want to line up against UCLA. [Read more 🡒]
Arizona Opens With A Test That Will Reveal Plenty Fast
A top-five ranking brings a certain kind of pressure, and Arizona will feel it immediately when the 2026-27 season opens against No. 22 UCLA in the Hall of Fame Series in Las Vegas. The Wildcats are stepping into the new year with a roster that looks different from the one that finished last season, but the early spotlight will still be bright enough to show what kind of team Tommy Lloyd has assembled.
What makes this matchup especially revealing is how much both programs have had to reload after losing major scoring from a year ago. Arizona will lean on its returning frontcourt presence and on senior transfer RJ Godfrey to help supply offense, while UCLA arrives with its own questions after saying goodbye to its top scorers. It is the kind of opener that should tell a lot fast, even if it does not answer everything. [Read more 🡒]
Arizona Faces One Big Test After Its Final Four Breakthrough
Tommy Lloyd spent the offseason looking back at a breakthrough run that carried Arizona to the Elite Eight and then the Final Four, and now the conversation has shifted to what comes next. The Wildcats head into the 2026-27 season with the kind of expectations that follow a deep tournament march, and the early buzz around the program says the standard has changed as much as the roster has.
Arizona enters with a strong core still in place, led by senior center Motiejus Krivas and forward Ivan Kharchenkov, while highly ranked freshman Caleb Holt adds another layer to the mix. The challenge now is less about proving last season was real and more about handling the pressure that comes with being viewed as one of the nations top teams before a game has even been played. [Read more 🡒]